氟化氨银或SMART技术治疗低矿化恒磨牙初期龋的3年随机对照试验
本研究纳入48名儿童的112颗伴ICDAS 1或2级龋损的低矿化恒磨牙,采用裂口设计随机分为SDF+KI组和SMART(SDF+KI+GIC)组,每组56颗。3年结果显示两组均能有效缓解过敏,但SMART组防龋效果优于SDF+KI组,尽管封闭剂逐渐脱落。
要点
- SMART(SDF+KI+GIC)封闭剂对低矿化磨牙的3年防龋效果优于单独SDF+KI。
- 两种处理均能显著降低低矿化磨牙的过敏症状,18个月后无牙齿过敏。
- SMART封闭剂存在逐渐的保留率下降,需长期监测。
核心结论
- SMART(SDF+KI+GIC)封闭剂在3年内对低矿化恒磨牙初期龋的防龋效果优于SDF+KI,尽管有逐渐的保留率下降。
- 两种处理均能有效缓解低矿化磨牙的过敏,且18个月后无牙齿过敏。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机对照试验,采用裂口设计,纳入48名儿童的112颗低矿化恒磨牙(ICDAS 1或2级龋损)。
- 牙齿随机分为SDF+KI组和SMART(SDF+KI+GIC)组,每组56颗。
主要发现
- SDF+KI组在12、24、36个月的防龋效果分别为100%、67.9%、65.4%;SMART组分别为100%、97.6%、94.7%。
- SDF+KI组平均防龋生存概率为31.01个月,显著低于SMART组的35.61个月(p < 0.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 防龋效果:SDF+KI组36个月65.4%,SMART组94.7%。
- 平均生存概率:SDF+KI组31.01个月,SMART组35.61个月(p < 0.001)。
- 过敏评估使用SCASS,临床评估使用修改USPHS标准,在1、6、12、18、24、36个月进行。
临床怎么用
- 对于低矿化恒磨牙伴初期龋,SMART(SDF+KI+GIC)封闭剂可提供更好的长期防龋保护。
- 两种方法均可用于缓解低矿化磨牙的过敏,但SMART需定期监测封闭剂保留情况。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to assess the clinical outcomes of utilizing silver diamine fluoride + potassium iodide (SDF + KI) treatment and Silver-Modified Atraumatic Restorative Technique (SMART/SDF + KI + Glass Ionomer Cement) over a three-year period on hypomineralised permanent molars with initial carious lesions. METHODS: 112 hypomineralised permanent molars with ICDAS 1 or 2 lesions were selected in 48 children. The teeth were randomized into SDF + KI and SMART (SDF + KI + GIC) groups (n = 56 teeth/group) in a split-mouth design. Hypersensitivity and caries development were evaluated in both groups. Schiff Cold Air Sensitivity Scale (SCASS) was used for evaluation of hypersensitivity, and the modified USPHS criteria were utilised for clinical assessments of SMART sealants at 1,6,12,18,24 and 36 months. Fisher's Exact test, Kaplan-Meier Survival Curves, Log-rank test, Mann Whitney U test, and Friedman test was performed for the statistical analysis. RESULTS: The caries preventive effect was 100 %, 67.9 % and 65.4 % for SDF + KI-treated teeth; and 100 %, 97.6 % and 94.7 % for SMART(SDF + KI + GIC)-treated teeth at 12, 24 and 36 months, respectively. The mean survival probabilities for caries-preventive effect were significantly lower in SDF + KI-treated teeth (31.01 months) than SMART-treated teeth (35.61 months), (p < 0.001). Twenty-six molars with initial hypersensitivity due to hypomineralization demonstrated a significant reduction at all evaluation periods compared to baseline SCASS scores (p < 0.001). Additionally, there was no significant difference in hypersensitivity scores between the groups during the re-call periods, and none of the teeth exhibited hypersensitivity at the 18-month and beyond evaluations. CONCLUSIONS: During the three-year assessment, both groups demonstrated effectiveness in reducing sensitivity in hypomineralised molars. However, SMART (SDF + KI + GIC) sealants offered better protection against tooth decay over time, despite experiencing gradual retention loss. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Both SMART (SDF + KI + GIC) sealants and SDF + KI proved effective in alleviating hypersensitivity in hypomineralised molars for up to three years. SMART (SDF + KI + GIC) sealants showed greater caries-preventive effect compared to SDF + KI. However, continuous long-term monitoring is crucial due to the gradual decline in retention of SMART (SDF + KI + GIC) sealants. CLINICALTRIALS REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT03862014.
引用
- Erbas Unverdi G, Ballikaya E, Cehreli ZC, et al. Clinical comparison of silver diamine fluoride (SDF) or silver-modified atraumatic restorative technique (SMART) on hypomineralised permanent molars with initial carious lesions: 3-year results of a prospective, randomised trial. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 38797490. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105098
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。