义齿基托材料的机械与颜色性能体外评价
本研究比较了四种义齿基托材料(Polyan IC、切削PMMA、3D打印树脂和SR Ivocap)的物理机械性能。结果显示切削PMMA和Polyan IC的抗压强度优于其他材料,Polyan IC硬度最高,3D打印树脂颜色稳定性最差。考虑机械性能和颜色稳定性,Polyan和切削PMMA更适合全口义齿制作,但需注意Polyan的修复受限和操作复杂。
要点
- 切削PMMA和Polyan IC抗压强度优于3D打印树脂和SR Ivocap。
- 除Polyan IC抗弯强度优于3D打印树脂外,其余材料间抗弯强度相似。
- Polyan IC硬度最高,3D打印树脂颜色稳定性最差。
核心结论
- 切削PMMA和Polyan IC的抗压强度优于其他测试材料。
- 除Polyan IC抗弯强度优于3D打印树脂外,其余材料抗弯强度相似。
- Polyan IC硬度最高,3D打印树脂颜色稳定性最差。
研究设计与样本
- 材料包括:3D打印树脂(Asiga DentaBASE)、切削PMMA(Ivotion Base)、Polyan IC(BredentSenden)和SR Ivocap(Ivoclar VivadentSchaan)。
- 测试项目包括双轴弯曲强度、压缩强度、维氏表面硬度和在咖啡及可口可乐中的颜色稳定性。
- 统计采用单因素方差分析和Tukey事后检验(α=0.05)。
主要发现
- 切削PMMA的压缩强度(p=0.002)和颜色稳定性(p<0.001)优于3D打印树脂,弯曲强度(p=0.336)和硬度(p=0.708)相似。
- 切削PMMA与Polyan IC的压缩强度(p=0.081)、弯曲强度(p=0.159)和可乐中颜色稳定性(p=0.071)相似,但切削PMMA硬度较低(p<0.001)且咖啡中颜色稳定性较差(p<0.001)。
- 切削PMMA压缩强度高于SR Ivocap(p<0.001),但弯曲强度、硬度和颜色稳定性相似(p>0.05)。
- 3D打印树脂压缩强度与Polyan IC相当(p=0.334),但弯曲强度(p=0.005)、硬度(p<0.001)和颜色稳定性(p<0.001)显著较低。
- Polyan IC压缩强度(p<0.001)、硬度(p=0.001)和咖啡中颜色稳定性(p<0.001)高于SR Ivocap,弯曲强度和可乐中颜色稳定性相似(p>0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 综合考虑机械性能和颜色稳定性,全口义齿制作可优先选择Polyan IC和切削PMMA。
- 选择Polyan IC时需考虑其修复受限和操作复杂的特点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to compare the physical and mechanical properties of four denture base materials: Polyan IC (PA), milled polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA), three-dimensional (3D)-printed resin (3DP), and SR Ivocap (SR). METHODS: Ninety-six samples were prepared and divided into four groups as follows. Group A consisted of 3DP (Asiga DentaBASE, Asiga) fabricated using a manufacturer-recommended 3D printer (Asiga Pro 4k, Asiga). Group B comprised milled PMMA (MP) (Ivotion Base, Ivoclar Vivadent). Group C included PA (BredentSenden), meanwhile, group D involved SR (Ivoclar VivadentSchaan). Cuboid samples (65 mm x 10 mm x 2.5 mm) were used for biaxial flexure strength testing in a universal testing machine (UTM). Cylindrical samples of 20 mm x 40 mm were used for compressive strength testing in a UTM. Additionally, cuboid samples (65 mm x 10 mm x 2.5 mm) were used for Vickers surface hardness testing in a microhardness tester. disk samples (10 mm x 2.5 mm) were employed for color stability testing both in a coffee solution and Coca-Cola, using a digital spectrophotometer. Statistical analyses were performed using one-way analysis of variance and Tukey's post hoc analysis (α=0.05). RESULTS: MP demonstrated superior compressive strength (p = 0.002) and color stability compared to that exhibited by 3DP (p < 0.001) while displaying similar flexure strength (p = 0.336) and hardness (p = 0.708). MP and PA displayed similar compressive strength (p = 0.081), flexure strength (p = 0.159), and color stability in coke (p = 0.071). However, MP had reduced hardness (p < 0.001) and color stability in coffee (p < 0.001). Moreover, MP demonstrated a higher compressive strength (p < 0.001) than that displayed by SR. However, the flexure strength, hardness, and color stability were similar (p > 0.05). Furthermore, 3DP exhibited comparable compressive strength (p = 0.334) to that of PA but demonstrated significantly lower flexure strength (p = 0.005), hardness (p < 0.001), and color stability (p < 0.001) compared to PA. In comparison to SR, PA had a higher compressive strength (p < 0.001), hardness (p = 0.001), and color stability in coffee (p < 0.001), although they demonstrated similar (p > 0.05) flexure strength and color stability in coke. CONCLUSIONS: The MP and PA demonstrated superior compressive strength than that exhibited by the other materials tested. The tested materials had similar flexure strengths, except for PA which demonstrated superiority over the 3DP. Among all tested materials, PA exhibited the highest hardness, while the 3DP was the least color-stable. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Considering the mechanical properties and color stability, Polyan and milled polymethylmethacrylate are preferred for complete denture fabrication. However, the limited repairability and complex handling of Polyan should be considered.
引用
- Arora O, Ahmed N, Nallaswamy D, et al. Denture base materials: An in vitro evaluation of the mechanical and color properties. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 38657724. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.104993
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。