文献速递口腔修复与种植口腔颌面外科

Lekholm和Zarb分类的观察者间与观察者内可靠性及基于影像组学数据驱动聚类对无牙颌牙槽嵴定性评估的初步探索

Inter and intra-operator reliability of Lekholm and Zarb classification and proposal of a novel radiomic data-driven clustering for qualitative assessment of edentulous alveolar ridges.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Oral Implants Res · 2024-04-17

本研究评估Lekholm和Zarb分类(L&Z)对无牙颌牙槽嵴骨质量评估的可重复性,并探索数据驱动方法用于骨质量分类的潜力。基于影像组学特征的无监督聚类将110个CBCT聚为三组,三种聚类方法结果一致。结论提示L&Z分类可靠性可能低于既往认知,影像组学数据驱动方法或可用于无牙颌牙槽嵴分类。

要点

  • L&Z分类观察者间一致性极低(FK T0: 0.273; T1: 0.243),观察者内一致性弱(CK 0.515)。
  • 基于影像组学特征的无监督聚类可重复地将110个CBCT聚为三组。
  • L&Z分类用于无牙颌牙槽嵴骨质量评估的可靠性可能低于既往认知。

核心结论

  • L&Z分类在临床医生间一致性低,可能不如既往认为的那样可靠。
  • 基于影像组学的数据驱动聚类方法可能用于无牙颌牙槽嵴分类,但需进一步研究确定临床意义。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用Cohen's kappa系数(CK)和Fleiss' kappa系数(FK)分别分析观察者内和观察者间一致性。
  • 从同一110个CBCT提取无牙颌牙槽嵴3D块的影像组学特征,并使用三种无监督聚类方法识别数据模式。

主要发现

  • 观察者内一致性T0与T1之间为弱(CK 0.515)。
  • 观察者间一致性在两个时间点均为极低(FK T0: 0.273; FK T1: 0.243)。
  • 三种基于影像组学特征的无监督聚类方法以相同方式将110个CBCT聚为三组。

临床怎么用

  • 临床使用L&Z分类评估无牙颌牙槽嵴骨质量时需注意其观察者间可靠性较低。
  • 影像组学数据驱动聚类方法可能为无牙颌牙槽嵴分类提供可重复的辅助手段,但尚未推荐常规使用。

局限性

  • 研究未确定影像组学聚类结果的临床意义。
  • 需进一步研究开发更标准化和准确的无牙颌牙槽嵴骨质量评估方法。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: The present study was conducted to evaluate the reproducibility of Lekholm and Zarb classification system (L&Z) for bone quality assessment of edentulous alveolar ridges and to investigate the potential of a data-driven approach for bone quality classification. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty-six expert clinicians were asked to classify 110 CBCT cross-sections according to L&Z classification (T0). The same evaluation was repeated after one month with the images put in a different order (T1). Intra- and inter-examiner agreement analyses were performed using Cohen's kappa coefficient (CK) and Fleiss' kappa coefficient (FK), respectively. Additionally, radiomic features extraction was performed from 3D edentulous ridge blocks derived from the same 110 CBCTs, and unsupervised clustering using 3 different clustering methods was used to identify patterns in the obtained data. RESULTS: Intra-examiner agreement between T0 and T1 was weak (CK 0.515). Inter-examiner agreement at both time points was minimal (FK at T0: 0.273; FK at T1: 0.243). The three different unsupervised clustering methods based on radiomic features aggregated the 110 CBCTs in three groups in the same way. CONCLUSIONS: The results showed low agreement among clinicians when using L&Z classification, indicating that the system may not be as reliable as previously thought. The present study suggests the possible application of a reproducible data-driven approach based on radiomics for the classification of edentulous alveolar ridges, with potential implications for improving clinical outcomes. Further research is needed to determine the clinical significance of these findings and to develop more standardized and accurate methods for assessing bone quality of edentulous alveolar ridges.

来源:Clin Oral Implants Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Troiano G, Rapani A, Fanelli F, et al. Inter and intra-operator reliability of Lekholm and Zarb classification and proposal of a novel radiomic data-driven clustering for qualitative assessment of edentulous alveolar ridges. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2024. PMID: 38629945. doi:10.1111/clr.14271

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。