E-Connect S+与Morita Tri Auto ZX2+根管长度测定准确性的体外对比研究
结果显示所有测量均在1±Δmm内且与真实长度强相关(ρ>0.97),在更严格的0.5±Δmm范围内准确率为84%-94%,所有设备与功能平均均短于真实长度。
要点
- 两种无线根管预备机的EAL与AAS功能测定根尖孔位置均可靠。
- 所有测量与真实长度强相关(ρ>0.97),偏差在1±Δmm内。
- 在0.5±Δmm严格范围内准确率为84%-94%,平均偏短。
核心结论
- E-Connect S+与Morita Tri Auto ZX2+根尖定位仪在确定根尖孔位置方面均提供可靠准确性。
- 无论使用EAL还是AAS功能,两种无线根管预备机的根管长度测量均具有高度可重复性。
研究设计与样本
- 开髓预敞后,将15号K锉插入至根尖孔记录为真实长度(AL),并用AAS和EAL功能测量,经共聚焦显微镜视觉确认。
主要发现
- 无论设备或功能,所有测量均在1±Δmm内,且与AL强相关(ρ>0.97)。
- 在0.5±Δmm的严格临床可接受范围内,所有设备与功能准确率相似(84%-94%)。
- 在更低容差范围时,E-Connect设备的EAL功能表现出最高准确率。
- 平均而言,所有设备与功能均停止在AL之前(平均Δmm>0)。
关键数值与推荐
- 所有测量与AL的偏差在1±Δmm内。
- 与AL的相关系数ρ>0.97。
- 在0.5±Δmm范围内准确率为84%-94%。
临床怎么用
- 两种无线根管预备机均可用于根管长度测定,EAL与AAS功能选择不影响可靠性。
- 临床操作中需注意测量值平均偏短于真实根尖孔位置。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: This ex vivo study evaluated the accuracy of the Electronic Apex Locator (EAL) and Automatic Apical Stop (AAS) functions of the E-Connect S+ and Morita Tri Auto ZX2+ cordless apex locators in determining patency length. METHODS: Sixty-four human teeth with a single root were randomly allocated into E-connect or Morita groups (n = 32). The canals were accessed and preflared, after which a size 15 K-file was inserted into the canal to the major foramen and recorded as the actual length (AL). Matched measurements were taken using the AAS and EAL functions and visually confirmed with confocal microscopy. The variance between canal length (mm), the persons correlation (ρ) between function and AL, and the accuracy (%) of the canal length relative to the AL (Δmm) between devices and functions were assessed. RESULTS: Regardless of device or function, all measurements were within 1±Δmm and correlated strongly (ρ > 0.97) with the AL. When considering a more stringent clinically acceptable range of 0.5±Δmm from the AL, all devices and functions demonstrated similar accuracy levels (84%-94%). However, at lower tolerance ranges, the E-connect device with the EAL function exhibited the highest accuracy. On average, all devices and functions stopped short of the AL (mean Δmm>0). CONCLUSION: The E-Connect S+ and Morita Tri Auto ZX2+ apex locators provided reliable accuracy in determining the position of the major foramen. These findings demonstrate a high level of reproducibility in canal length measurements using both cordless endodontic handpieces, regardless of whether the EAL or AAS functions were employed.
引用
- Bailey D, Anderson R, Brady K, et al. An Ex-Vivo Study Comparing the Accuracy of the E-Connect S+ and Morita Tri Auto ZX2+ Endodontic Handpieces in Root Canal Length Determination. J Endod. 2024. PMID: 38631475. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2024.04.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。