短种植体(6 mm)与上颌窦底提升联合长种植体(11-15 mm)的10年随机对照多中心研究
这项随机对照多中心研究比较了上颌后牙区牙槽嵴高度5-7 mm患者使用6 mm短种植体与经上颌窦底提升植入11-15 mm长种植体并单冠修复的10年结局。两组种植体生存率、边缘骨水平、技术并发症、种植体周围炎率及OHIP-49评分均无显著组间差异。结论认为短种植体可作为上颌后牙区骨高度不足患者的替代方案。
要点
- 上颌后牙区骨高度5-7 mm时,6 mm短种植体与上颌窦底提升联合长种植体的10年种植体生存率相似。
- 两组边缘骨水平、技术并发症、种植体周围炎率及OHIP-49评分均无显著差异。
- 短种植体可能降低患者发病率与费用,可作为替代治疗概念。
核心结论
- 基于相似的10年种植体生存率、降低的患者发病率与更低的费用,短种植体可作为上颌后牙区骨高度不足患者替代上颌窦底提升联合长种植体的治疗概念。
研究设计与样本
- 最终修复后定期复查至10年,5-10年随访期77例患者(105枚种植体)复查,脱落率21%。
主要发现
- 患者水平种植体生存率:短种植体组96.0%(2枚失败),上颌窦底提升组100%,组间p=.24。
- 边缘骨水平中位数:短种植体组0.00 mm(最小0.00,最大3.25),上颌窦底提升组0.00 mm(最小0.00,最大4.55),组间p=.73。
- 技术并发症主要发生在最初5年内,组间p>.05。
- 种植体周围炎率:短种植体组4.2%,上颌窦底提升组13.3%,组间p=.37。
- 10年时OHIP-49评分中位数:短种植体组7.00(0.00;39.00),上颌窦底提升组9.00(0.00;196),组间p=.61。
临床怎么用
- 对于上颌后牙区牙槽嵴高度5-7 mm的患者,可考虑使用6 mm短种植体作为上颌窦底提升联合长种植体的替代方案。
局限性
- 5-10年随访期脱落率为21%,可能影响结果解释。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To compare implant survival and complication rates between shorter and standard-length implants with sinus augmentation and restored with single crowns, at 10 years of loading. MATERIALS AND METHODS: One-hundred and one patients (137 implants) with a ridge height of 5-7 mm in the posterior maxilla were randomly assigned to two treatment modalities: shorter implants (6 mm) (group short [GS]) or standard-length implants (11-15 mm) with sinus grafting (group graft [GG]). Following the insertion of final restorations, patients were regularly recalled for up to 10 years. Assessed outcomes encompassed implant survival, marginal bone levels (MBLs), biological and technical parameters and patient-reported outcome measures (OHIP-49 = Oral Health Impact Profile). Non-parametric statistical analysis was used to analyse the data. RESULTS: For the 5- to 10-year follow-up period, 77 patients with 105 implants (GS: 36 patients/48 implants; GG: 41/57) were available for re-examination (drop-out rate 21%). Implant survival rates at the patient level were 96.0% (GS; 2 failures) and 100% (GG) (inter-group p = .24). Median MBLs amounted to 0.00 mm (min 0.00; max 3.25; GS) and 0.00 mm (min 0.00; max 4.55; GG) (inter-group p = .73). Technical complications predominantly occurred within the first 5 years (inter-group p > .05). Peri-implantitis rates were 4.2% (GS) and 13.3% (GG) (intergroup p = .37). Median OHIP-49 scores were 7.00 (0.00; 39.00; GS) and 9.00 (0.00; 196; GG) (inter-group p = .61) at 10 years. CONCLUSIONS: Based on similar 10-year implant survival rates, reduced patient morbidity and lower costs, the use of shorter dental implants might well serve as an alternative treatment concept to longer implants placed in conjunction with sinus grafting for patients with a limited ridge height in the posterior maxilla. Study register: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT01030523.
引用
- Thoma DS, Haas R, Sporniak-Tutak K, et al. Randomized controlled multi-centre study comparing shorter dental implants (6 mm) to longer dental implants (11-15 mm) in combination with sinus floor elevation procedures: 10-year data. J Clin Periodontol. 2024. PMID: 38296249. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13954
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。