指南与共识牙体牙髓病

国际共识研究确定牙髓治疗核心结局集(COSET)应包含的结局

An international consensus study to identify "what" outcomes should be included in a core outcome set for endodontic treatments (COSET) for utilization in clinical practice and research.
指南 / 共识 · Int Endod J · 2023-12-27

该国际共识研究旨在确定牙髓治疗核心结局集(COSET)应纳入的结局。研究采用标准化的核心结局集开发方法,通过范围综述、患者访谈、e-Delphi流程和共识会议对永久牙的牙髓治疗结局进行优先排序。最终推荐8个跨所有治疗模式共享的结局纳入COSET,包括疼痛、感染迹象、进一步干预/加重等。

要点

  • COSET推荐8个跨所有牙髓治疗模式共享的结局,包括疼痛、感染迹象、进一步干预/加重、叩诊/触诊敏感、影像学疾病进展/愈合证据、功能、牙齿存留和患者满意度。
  • 共识标准为:结局评分7-9分且≥70%参与者评为7-9分且<15%评为1-3分视为达成纳入共识。
  • 许多纳入COSET的结局是患者报告的,应纳入未来结局研究。

核心结论

  • COSET通过严格方法确定了患者和临床医生重要的结局,并推荐8个跨所有治疗模式共享的结局纳入COSET。
  • 进一步工作正在进行以确定这些结局应如何以及何时测量。

研究设计与样本

  • 国际共识研究,采用标准化的核心结局集开发与报告方法。
  • 通过四项已发表的范围综述识别现有结局,经半结构化患者访谈、e-Delphi流程和共识会议进行优先排序。
  • 共95名参与者(包括患者)参与COSET开发过程。

主要发现

  • 共识小组强烈推荐8个跨所有治疗模式共享的结局纳入COSET:疼痛;感染迹象(肿胀、窦道);进一步干预/加重;叩诊/触诊敏感;影像学疾病进展/愈合证据;功能;牙齿存留;患者满意度。
  • 还推荐了额外的治疗特异性结局。
  • 许多纳入COSET的结局是患者报告的。

关键数值与推荐

  • 结局采用1-9分Likert量表优先排序:7-9分为关键,4-6分为重要,1-3分为较不重要。
  • ≥70%参与者评为7-9分且<15%评为1-3分的结局视为达成纳入COSET的共识。
  • 第一轮未达成共识的结局在第二轮Delphi和共识会议中进一步优先排序。
  • 最终纳入COSET的结局由共识小组会议期间通过Zoom Poll功能投票决定。

临床怎么用

  • 临床实践和研究中应纳入COSET推荐的8个共享结局,以标准化牙髓治疗结局报告。
  • 关注患者报告的结局,如疼痛和患者满意度。
  • 考虑治疗特异性结局用于相应治疗模式的评估。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Development of a standardized set of topic-specific outcomes known as a Core Outcome Set (COS) is important to address issues of heterogeneity in reporting research findings in order to streamline evidence synthesis and clinical decision making. AIM: The aim of the current international consensus study is to identify "what" outcomes to include in the Core Outcome Set for Endodontic Treatments (COSET). Outcomes of various endodontic treatments (non-surgical root canal treatment, surgical endodontics, vital pulp treatment and revitalization procedures) performed on permanent teeth were considered. METHODS: A standard validated methodology for COS development and reporting was adopted. The process involved identification of existing outcomes through four published scoping reviews. This enabled creation of a list of outcomes to be prioritized via semi-structured patient interviews, e-Delphi process and a consensus meeting with a range of relevant global stakeholders. Outcomes were prioritized using a 1-9 Likert scale, with outcomes rated 7-9 considered critical, 4-6 are important and 1-3 are less important. Outcomes rated 7-9 by ≥70% and 1-3 by <15% of participants were considered to achieve consensus for inclusion in the COS. The outcomes that did not achieve consensus in the first round were considered for further prioritization in the second Delphi round and consensus meeting. Final decisions about the outcomes to include in COSET were made by voting during the consensus panel meeting using the Zoom Poll function. RESULTS: A total of 95 participants including patients contributed to the COS development process. The consensus panel recommended, with strong consensus, eight outcomes shared across all treatment modalities for inclusion in COSET: pain; signs of infection (swelling, sinus tract); further intervention/exacerbation; tenderness to percussion/palpation; radiographic evidence of disease progression/healing; function; tooth survival; and patient satisfaction. Additional treatment specific outcomes were also recommended. DISCUSSION: Many of the outcomes included in COSET are patient reported. All should be included in future outcomes studies. CONCLUSION: COSET identified outcomes that are important for patients and clinicians and validated these using a rigorous methodology. Further work is ongoing to determine "how" and "when" these outcomes should be measured.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. El Karim I, Duncan HF, Cushley S, et al. An international consensus study to identify "what" outcomes should be included in a core outcome set for endodontic treatments (COSET) for utilization in clinical practice and research. Int Endod J. 2023. PMID: 38314586. doi:10.1111/iej.14008

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。