密苏里/南伊利诺伊地区牙髓病锥形束CT诊断参考水平的建议
该剂量学研究使用指形电离室和聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯模体,采用SEDENTEXTCT方法对21台锥形束CT(CBCT)设备测量电离辐射剂量指数1(DI1),基于中位数输出值的第75百分位数(第三四分位数)建立区域诊断参考水平(DRL)。建议DRL为剂量面积乘积(DAP)838 mGy cm²、DI1 3.924 mGy;排除3台采用360°全旋转采集模式的J Morita Veraview X800异常设备后,DI1与DAP强相关。基于降低电离辐射输出,临床可行时牙髓病专科推荐使用4 cm×4 cm视野。
要点
- 建议区域DRL:DAP 838 mGy cm²,DI1 3.924 mGy
- 4 cm×4 cm视野第三四分位中位值:DAP 500.6 mGy cm²,DI1 2.006 mGy
- 排除3台J Morita Veraview X800异常设备后DI1与DAP强相关
核心结论
- 建议的CBCT区域DRL为DAP 838 mGy cm²和DI1 3.924 mGy。
- 排除3台采用360°全旋转采集模式的J Morita Veraview X800异常设备后,DI1与DAP值强相关。
- 基于降低电离辐射输出,牙髓病专科临床可行时推荐使用4 cm×4 cm视野。
研究设计与样本
- 该剂量学研究使用指形电离室和聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯模体,采用SEDENTEXTCT方法对21台不同CBCT设备测量DI1值。
- DRL基于中位数输出值的第75百分位数(第三四分位数)计算。
主要发现
- 调查的CBCT设备建议DRL为DAP 838 mGy cm²和DI1 3.924 mGy。
- 4 cm×4 cm视野第三四分位中位值为DAP 500.6 mGy cm²和DI1 2.006 mGy。
- 5 cm×5 cm视野第三四分位中位值为DAP 838 mGy cm²和DI1 3.906 mGy。
- 排除3台采用360°全旋转采集模式的J Morita Veraview X800异常设备后,DI1与DAP值强相关。
- 所调查的CBCT设备间,可选曝光参数与电离辐射输出的直接相关性得到展示。
关键数值与推荐
- 建议区域DRL:DAP 838 mGy cm²,DI1 3.924 mGy。
- 4 cm×4 cm视野第三四分位中位值:DAP 500.6 mGy cm²,DI1 2.006 mGy。
- 5 cm×5 cm视野第三四分位中位值:DAP 838 mGy cm²,DI1 3.906 mGy。
- 基于降低电离辐射输出,牙髓病专科临床可行时推荐4 cm×4 cm视野。
临床怎么用
- 牙髓病专科进行CBCT检查时,临床可行时应优先选择4 cm×4 cm视野以降低辐射输出。
- 可参考本区域DRL(DAP 838 mGy cm²,DI1 3.924 mGy)评估设备辐射输出是否合理。
- 选择曝光参数时需关注其对电离辐射输出的直接影响。
局限性
- DRL基于21台CBCT设备的中位数输出值第三四分位数计算,为区域建议值。
- DI1与DAP强相关是在排除3台采用360°全旋转采集模式的J Morita Veraview X800异常设备后得出。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) are intended to improve patient safety and ensure that patient ionizing radiation doses are as low as reasonably achievable. The purpose of this dosimetry study was to establish regional DRL levels for cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) imaging for specialty endodontics. Another aim was to compare phantom-measured ionizing radiation dose index 1 (DI1) index doses to the manufacturer-provided dose area product (DAP) radiation output values for each of the CBCT machines studied, to ascertain their degree of correlation. DAP refers to the dose area product, a measure of radiation dose monitoring which represents the dose within the beam times the area within the beam at that position. METHODS: A thimble ionization chamber and polymethyl methacrylate phantom were used to obtain DI1 values using the SEDENTEXTCT method from 21 different CBCT units. DRLs were calculated based on the 75th percentile (third quartile) of the median output values. RESULTS: The proposed DRL from the CBCT units surveyed has a DAP value of 838 mGy cm2 and a DI1 value of 3.924 mGy. DAP versus DI1 values of 500.6 mGy cm2 versus 2.006 mGy, and 838 mGy cm2 versus 3.906 mGy represented the third quartile of the median values for the 4-cm × 4-cm and 5-cm × 5-cm field of views (FOVs), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The DI1 and DAP values strongly correlated when 3 outlier CBCT machines (J Morita Veraview X800) using a novel 360° (full rotation) acquisition mode were excluded. The importance of selectable exposure parameters as directly related to ionizing radiation output is illustrated among the CBCT units surveyed. Although the actual FOV that is selected is ultimately dictated by the specific clinical requirements, a 4-cm × 4-cm FOV is recommended for specialist endodontics practice, whenever clinically practical, based on the decreased ionizing radiation output, as compared to that from a 5-cm × 5-cm FOV.
引用
- Popkowski A, Rhodes SC, Hatton JF, et al. Proposed Diagnostic Reference Levels in the Missouri/Southern Illinois Region Associated with Cone-beam Computed Tomography Use in Endodontics. J Endod. 2024. PMID: 38382736. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2024.02.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。