牙间口腔卫生干预在自然发生的牙龈炎中引起不同的微生物组组成变化:临床试验的二次数据分析
本研究为临床试验二次分析,评估两种冲牙器与牙线对龈下微生物组的影响。结果显示所有组牙龈炎症均显著减轻,两种冲牙器在减少探诊出血方面优于牙线(p < .001)。冲牙器组在4周时微生物组多样性基本稳定,但共生菌相对丰度增加、晚期定植菌和牙周病原体减少,且变化因牙间卫生方式而异。
要点
- 冲牙器在减少探诊出血方面优于牙线(p < .001)。
- 冲牙器组4周时共生早期定植菌如链球菌、韦荣球菌和梭杆菌相对增加。
- 微生物组变化因牙间卫生方式不同而异,Group 1变化更显著。
核心结论
- 冲牙器组4周时牙龈炎症减轻伴随微生物组组成的轻微但关键变化。
- 自然发生的牙龈炎消退4周内生物多样性无实质变化,但共生早期定植菌相对增加并伴随向低厌氧微生物群转变。
- 这些变化取决于牙间卫生方式,Group 1微生物组组成向牙周健康相容群落的变化更显著。
研究设计与样本
- 临床试验的二次数据分析,纳入评估两种冲牙器(Waterpik Water Flosser为Group 1、Oral-B Water Flosser为Group 2)与牙线(Group 3)口腔卫生疗效的成人参与者。
- 龈下菌斑样本反映基线时自然发生的菌斑诱导牙龈炎和终点(4周)时牙龈健康状态。
- 通过16S rRNA测序分析龈下微生物组以鉴定扩增子序列变体。
主要发现
- 所有组自我实施手动刷牙和冲牙灌溉的口腔卫生指导均导致炎症显著减轻。
- 两种冲牙器在减少探诊出血方面优于牙线(p < .001)。
- 龈下菌斑微生物组多样性随时间保持相对稳定,但某些分类群有显著变化。
- 冲牙器组中共生菌相对丰度增加、晚期定植菌和牙周病原体减少。
- Group 1在微生物组组成向牙周健康相容群落变化方面更显著。
临床怎么用
- 对于自然发生的菌斑诱导牙龈炎患者,冲牙器可作为减少探诊出血的牙间卫生选择。
- 冲牙器使用4周可伴随龈下微生物组向牙周健康相容群落转变。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To evaluate the effect of different oral irrigators on the sub-gingival microbiome composition in patients with naturally occurring plaque-induced gingivitis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Sub-gingival plaque was collected from adults participating in a clinical trial assessing the efficacy of oral hygiene with two different oral irrigators (Waterpik Water Flosser [Group 1] and Oral-B Water Flosser [Group 2]) versus dental flossing (Group 3) for microbiome analysis. Plaque samples were reflective of naturally occurring plaque-induced gingivitis at baseline and of gingival health at the endpoint (4 weeks). Clinical measures of gingival inflammation were collected, and the sub-gingival microbiome was analysed by 16S rRNA sequencing to identify amplicon sequence variants. RESULTS: Oral hygiene instruction with self-performed manual toothbrushing and water-jet irrigation led to significant reductions in inflammation for all groups; both oral irrigators outperformed flossing in bleeding-on-probing reduction (p < .001). Microbiome diversity of sub-gingival plaque remained relatively stable over time, but significant changes were noted in certain taxa, consistent with increases in the relative abundance of commensals and reductions in late colonizers and periodontal pathogens in the water-jet groups. CONCLUSIONS: Reduction in gingival inflammation at 4 weeks within the water-jet groups is accompanied by slight but critical changes in microbiome composition. Although biodiversity does not substantially change within 4 weeks during the resolution of naturally induced gingivitis, significant relative increases in commensal early colonizers such as Streptococcus, Veillonella and Fusobacterium were accompanied by a shift towards a less anaerobic microbiota associated with return to health. These changes were contingent upon the type of interdental hygiene, with Group 1 exhibiting more significant alterations in microbiome composition towards a periodontal-health-compatible community.
引用
- Ge Y, Bamashmous S, Mancinelli-Lyle D, et al. Interdental oral hygiene interventions elicit varying compositional microbiome changes in naturally occurring gingivitis: Secondary data analysis from a clinical trial. J Clin Periodontol. 2023. PMID: 38088457. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13899
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。