新冠疫情前后牙科本科生牙科及牙髓相关压力的混合方法研究
该混合方法研究评估了牙科本科生在新冠疫情期间牙科及牙髓相关压力的主要来源。结果显示,所有年级压力最大的领域为「表现压力」、「工作量」和「临床培训」;牙髓相关压力在低年级主要来自「自我效能信念」等,高年级则来自「牙髓患者治疗」等。定性分析表明患者和新冠疫情是学生压力的重要来源,但牙髓教学特点可能降低压力。
要点
- 牙科本科生总体压力主要源于表现压力、工作量和临床培训。
- 牙髓相关压力低年级以自我效能信念为主,高年级以患者治疗为主。
- 牙髓问卷中17个共同问题的压力评分低于牙科环境压力问卷。
核心结论
- 学生认为牙髓治疗有压力,但教育可在减少压力方面发挥核心作用,尤其在本科课程早期。
研究设计与样本
- 采用解释性序列设计的混合方法研究,纳入二、三、四年级志愿学生,使用牙科环境压力问卷和牙髓相关压力问卷,并进行焦点小组访谈。
主要发现
- 牙科环境压力问卷显示所有年级压力最大的领域为表现压力、工作量和临床培训。
- 牙髓压力问卷显示低年级压力最大领域为自我效能信念、牙髓临床培训和教师与行政,高年级为牙髓患者治疗、牙髓表现压力和临床培训。
- 两问卷共同问题比较显示,牙髓压力问卷在17个问题上压力评分更低,其中13个问题显著更低(p < 0.05),无问题显著更高。
- 定性研究显示学生压力与患者、临床操作、组织、员工、学术教育、评估和COVID-19相关问题有关。
关键数值与推荐
- 牙髓压力问卷在13个共同问题上显著低于牙科环境压力问卷(p < 0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 口腔教育者可关注表现压力、工作量和临床培训等压力源,尤其在早期课程中加强牙髓教学支持。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To determine and explain the principal sources of stress among preclinical and clinical dental undergraduate students with a particular focus on the stressors linked to endodontics. METHODOLOGY: A mixed-methods study, with an explanatory sequential design, was employed. Volunteer students of second, third and fourth years were asked to complete both the Dental Environment Stress (DES) questionnaire and a bespoke questionnaire for endodontic-related stress assessment, which had 21 questions in common with the DES. The results were analysed by Kruskal-Wallis and Marginal Homogeneity tests. In the second part of the study, a qualitative phase was conducted through focus group interviews of students from each academic year included in the study. Interviews were analysed by inductive content analysis. RESULTS: The DES questionnaire determined that for all years the most stressful domains were 'performance pressure', 'workload' and 'clinical training'. According to the endodontic stress questionnaire, the most stressful domains were 'self-efficacy beliefs', 'endodontic clinical training' and 'faculty and administration' in early years, while they were 'endodontic patient treatment', 'performance pressure in endodontics' and 'clinical training' in later years. Comparing questions common to both questionnaires revealed that the stress score was lower for the endodontic stress questionnaire than in the DES questionnaire for 17 questions, being significantly lower for 13 questions (p < 0.05) and significantly higher for no question. The qualitative study showed that students' dental and endodontic-related stress was linked to different domains: patient, clinical procedure, organization, staff, academic education, evaluation and COVID-19-related issues. Qualitative aspects highlighted the important role that patients and COVID-19 have played in student stress. However, they suggested a possible explanation for the lower endodontic stress observed in this dental university hospital, which was based on: the nature of the teaching in endodontics, the consensus between endodontic supervisors, the use of a logical, progressive procedure and the considerable experience that students gain over the years. CONCLUSION: Students considered endodontics stressful; however, education can play a central role in reducing stress, particularly during the early parts of the undergraduate course.
引用
- Chevalier V, Bonnabesse ALF, Honari B, et al. Dental and endodontic-related stress amongst undergraduate students before and during the COVID-19 pandemic: A mixed-methods study. Int Endod J. 2023. PMID: 38054567. doi:10.1111/iej.14002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。