Er:YAG激活冲洗的脉冲能量、工作尖设计与插入深度对模拟重度弯曲复杂根管系统清洁效果的影响
该体外研究用3D打印重度弯曲根管模型(25/.06,长20 mm,弯曲60°,半径5 mm,距根尖2、5、8 mm处设侧支根管)比较Er:YAG激光激活冲洗(LAI)不同脉冲能量、工作尖设计与插入深度,并与声波激活(EDDY)和传统针头冲洗(NI)对比。结果显示LAI2(50 mJ、25 PPS、P400FL、距根尖止点9 mm)与LAI3(80 mJ、25 PPS、P400FL、距根尖止点9 mm)清洁效果最佳,LAI6(30 mJ、25 PPS、R200T、距根尖止点9 mm)最差;R200T工作尖冲洗液溢出根尖孔的发生率显著更高。
要点
- 工作尖设计、能量设置及工作尖置于根管口以下可改善Er:YAG激光激活冲洗的清洁效果。
- LAI2与LAI3对全根管系统的水凝胶去除率最佳,LAI6最差。
- R200T小工作尖因能量更集中,冲洗液溢出根尖孔的发生率显著更高。
核心结论
- 工作尖设计、能量设置和工作尖位于根管口以下可改善LAI的清洁性能;但R200T小工作尖因能量更集中,导致冲洗液溢出等操作失误显著增多。
研究设计与样本
- 体外研究,采用3D打印根管模型(25/.06,长20 mm,弯曲60°,半径5 mm),距根尖2、5、8 mm处设直径0.2 mm侧支根管,内充有色生物膜模拟水凝胶。
- LAI共6种设置(n=20),每组冲洗3×20 s;EDDY与针头冲洗(NI)为对照组;采用Kruskal-Wallis与Dunn检验(p=.05),并记录冲洗液溢出根尖孔情况。
主要发现
- LAI2全根管系统水凝胶去除率为99.08%(IQR 96.85-100.00),LAI3为97.50%(96.24-100.00),在全部LAI配置中显著最佳(p<.05)。
- LAI6全根管系统水凝胶去除率为80.08%(73.41-84.69),在全部LAI配置中显著最差(p<.05)。
- LAI6、EDDY(72.89%,67.49-76.22)与手动冲洗(54.39%,51.01-56.94)之间无显著差异(p>.05)。
- R200T激光工作尖导致冲洗液溢出根尖孔的发生率显著高于所有其他技术(p<.05)。
关键数值与推荐
- LAI1:50 mJ、25 PPS、P400FL、根管口,3×20 s。
- LAI2:50 mJ、25 PPS、P400FL、距根尖止点9 mm(约第一侧支根管上方1 mm),3×20 s。
- LAI3:80 mJ、25 PPS、P400FL、距根尖止点9 mm,3×20 s。
- LAI4:80 mJ、25 PPS、P400FL、根管口,3×20 s。
- LAI5:50 mJ、25 PPS、P400FL于根管口2×20 s,加R200T(30 mJ、25 PPS)距根尖止点9 mm 1×20 s。
临床怎么用
- 在重度弯曲复杂根管系统中,采用P400FL工作尖并置于根管口以下(距根尖止点9 mm)可提升Er:YAG激光激活冲洗的清洁效果。
- 选用R200T小工作尖时需警惕冲洗液溢出根尖孔的风险,因其能量更集中。
局限性
- 本研究为体外3D打印根管模型实验,结果不能直接等同于临床疗效。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To investigate the influence of pulse energy, tip geometry and tip position in simulated 3D-printed root canals with multiple side canals at different levels in all directions on the cleaning performance of laser-activated irrigation (LAI) compared to sonic activation (EDDY) and conventional needle irrigation (NI). METHODOLOGY: 3D-printed root canal models (25/.06, length 20 mm, curvature 60°, radius 5 mm) with side canals (diameter 0.2 mm) at 2, 5 and 8 mm from the apex were filled with coloured biofilm-mimicking hydrogel. LAI (Morita AdvErL Evo, Kyoto, Japan) was performed with six settings (n = 20; pulse-energy, pulses per second [PPS], tip position): LAI1 (50 mJ, 25 PPS, P400FL, canal entrance [CE]), LAI2 (same as LAI1, but insertion depth 9 mm before the apical endpoint [AE] [corresponding to 1 mm above the first lateral canals]), LAI3 (80 mJ, 25 PPS, P400FL, 9 mm before AE), LAI4 (same as LAI 3, but at CE) for 3 × 20 s each, LAI5 (50 mJ, 25 PPS, P400FL 2 × 20 s, CE & R200T (30 mJ, 25 PPS, 1 × 20 s, 9 mm before AE), LAI6 (30 mJ, 25 PPS, R200T, 9 mm before AE, 3 × 20 s). A continuous irrigation (3 mL/20 s) using distilled water accompanied the irrigation cycles. NI and EDDY (3 × 20 s each; 3 mL/20 s irrigation, insertion AE minus 1 mm, amplitude 4 mm) served as control groups. Biofilm-mimicking hydrogel removal (ImageJ, NIH) was assessed for the entire system, the central canal and the lateral canals using standardized photographs with a microscope (Expert DN, Müller-Optronic) and statistically analysed was performed using Kruskal-Wallis and Dunn tests (p = .05). Irrigant extrusion beyond the foramina was also recorded. RESULTS: LAI2 (99.08%; interquartile range [IQR]: 96.85-100.00) and LAI3 (97.50%; 96.24-100.00) achieved the significantly best and LAI6 (80.08%; 73.41-84.69) the significantly worst removal of hydrogel from the entire root canal system amongst all LAI configurations (p < .05). There were no significant differences between LAI6, EDDY (72.89%; 67.49-76.22) and manual irrigation (54.39%; 51.01-56.94) (p > .05). R200T laser tip caused significantly more often irrigant extrusion than all other techniques (p < .05). CONCLUSION: Tip design, energy settings, and the positioning of the laser tip below the canal entrance caused an improvement in cleaning performance of the LAI. However, the small R200T tip created significantly more procedural errors (irrigant extrusion) due to higher concentrated energy.
引用
- Bürklein S, Abdi I, Schäfer E, et al. Influence of pulse energy, tip design and insertion depth during Er:YAG-activated irrigation on cleaning efficacy in simulated severely curved complex root canal systems in vitro. Int Endod J. 2023. PMID: 37947444. doi:10.1111/iej.13992
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。