以人为中心理论教育干预改善青少年口腔卫生的随机对照研究
该研究分析了一项在瑞典公共牙科服务中开展的前瞻性多中心准随机对照研究,比较以人为中心、基于社会认知理论与动机性访谈的教育干预与常规信息指导对口腔卫生较差青少年的效果。
要点
- 以人为中心理论教育干预在牙龈炎教育满意度上优于常规指导(61% vs 37%)。
- 试验组沟通满意度更高(69% vs 50%),且更自报治疗后口腔卫生更仔细(30% vs 15%)。
- 两组差异均具有统计学意义(p < .01),但研究为准随机设计且分析为符合方案集。
核心结论
- 以人为中心、基于理论的干预在青少年教育体验、沟通满意度及6个月自报口腔卫生行为结局上优于常规信息指导。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性、多中心、两臂准随机对照现场研究,由瑞典Västra Götaland公共牙科服务的牙科保健员实施。
- 试验组采用基于社会认知建构的以人为中心干预,沟通中使用动机性访谈;对照组接受常规信息/指导。
- 基线及6个月时进行临床检查并发放问卷。
主要发现
- 试验组对牙龈炎教育评价为「非常好」的比例为61%,对照组为37%。
- 试验组对治疗期间沟通评价为「非常好」的比例为69%,对照组为50%。
- 试验组报告治疗后对口腔卫生「更加仔细」的比例为30%,对照组为15%。
- 试验组对维持健康牙龈状况的信心高于对照组,以上比较均p < .01。
临床怎么用
- 对口腔卫生较差的青少年,可采用以人为中心、基于社会认知理论的教育干预,并结合动机性访谈改善沟通体验与自我护理行为。
局限性
- 研究为准随机设计,非完全随机。
- 结局包含自报体验与行为,可能受主观报告影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To analyse adolescents' self-reported experiences and behavioural outcomes of a person-centred, theory-based intervention in comparison with conventional information/instruction for improved oral hygiene. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Data were derived from a prospective, multi-centred, two-arm, quasi-randomized field study focusing on the effectiveness of educational interventions for improved oral hygiene. Dental hygienists working within the Public Dental Service, Västra Götaland, Sweden, provided treatments, and adolescents with poor oral hygiene conditions were eligible for participation. The person-centred test intervention was based on social cognitive constructs, and motivational interviewing was used as an approach in communication. The control intervention included conventional information/instructions. Clinical examinations were performed, and questionnaires were distributed at baseline and at 6 months. Three-hundred and twelve patients were enrolled, and data from 276 patients, following treatment per protocol, were analysed. RESULTS: The test group was more satisfied with the education about gingivitis (very good: 61% vs. 37%) and communication during therapy (very good: 69% vs. 50%) and reported to a larger extent that they were much more careful regarding their oral hygiene after the treatment (30% vs. 15%) and had higher confidence about keeping up healthy gingival conditions, in comparison with the control group (all p < .01). CONCLUSIONS: The person-centred, theory-based intervention was superior in terms of adolescents' experiences of education and communication during therapy and self-reported oral hygiene behavioural outcomes at 6 months, in comparison with conventional information/instruction.
引用
- Dimenäs SL, Andersson JS, Jönsson B, et al. Adolescents' self-reported experiences following a person-centred, theory-based educational intervention versus conventional education for improved oral hygiene: Analysis of secondary outcomes of a randomized field study. J Clin Periodontol. 2023. PMID: 37822115. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13883
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。