深龋选择性去腐与牙髓切断术一年结局的随机对照试验
该先导性随机对照试验比较选择性去腐(SCR)与牙髓切断术治疗深龋(龋坏达牙本质厚度至少75%)的一年结局。共纳入活髓成熟恒牙,SCR组58颗、牙髓切断组55颗完成治疗。一年时SCR组98.3%、牙髓切断组87.3%牙齿可分析,牙髓切断组需根管治疗的比例(2.1%)低于SCR组(14.0%,p<.05)。结论认为牙髓切断术在保存剩余牙髓和根尖周健康方面优于SCR。
要点
- 深龋达牙本质至少75%的活髓成熟恒牙,牙髓切断术一年需根管治疗率低于SCR。
- 牙髓切断术患者费用更高且治疗时间更长。
- 两种治疗一年总体无进一步干预生存率为91.4%。
核心结论
- 在研究的局限性内,牙髓切断术在保存剩余牙髓和根尖周健康方面优于SCR。
- 牙髓切断术的患者费用更高且完成治疗时间更长。
研究设计与样本
- 两臂平行组随机优效性试验,纳入影像学显示龋坏至少达牙本质厚度75%的活髓成熟恒牙。
- SCR组58颗、牙髓切断组55颗完成治疗,排除6颗未完成分配治疗及1颗因严重牙周病。
- 采用计算机生成随机患者代码并隐藏于不透明信封进行盲法分配。
- 治疗后6个月和1年进行临床和影像学复查,使用对数秩检验和Cox比例风险回归分析。
主要发现
- 一年时SCR组57/58(98.3%)、牙髓切断组48/55(87.3%)牙齿可分析。
- 牙髓切断组1颗(2.1%)、SCR组8颗(14.0%)需进一步根管治疗(p<.05)。
- 两种治疗一年总体无进一步干预生存率为91.4%。
- 未发现其他显著生存预后因素,复查期间无其他不良事件。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准:活髓成熟恒牙,原发或继发深龋影像学至少达牙本质厚度75%,无不可逆性牙髓炎症状或根尖周病变影像学证据。
- 需进一步根管治疗比例:牙髓切断组2.1% vs SCR组14.0%(p<.05)。
临床怎么用
- 对于深龋达牙本质至少75%的无症状活髓成熟恒牙,牙髓切断术可能更有利于保存牙髓和根尖周健康。
- 选择牙髓切断术时需考虑患者费用更高和治疗时间更长。
局限性
- 为先导性随机对照试验,样本量有限。
- 随访时间仅一年,需长期随访研究牙髓和修复结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: This study aimed to compare the outcome of SCR and Pulpotomy in teeth with deep caries extending at least 75% into dentine. METHODOLOGY: This two-armed, parallel-group, randomized, superiority trial included vital mature permanent teeth with deep primary or secondary caries diagnosed radiographically as being at least 75% into the thickness of dentine, without clinical signs of symptomatic irreversible pulpitis or radiographic evidence of a periapical lesion. Carious teeth were blindly allocated to receive either SCR or Pulpotomy using computer-generated randomized patient codes concealed in opaque envelopes. All teeth were reviewed clinically and radiographically at 6 months and 1 year post-treatment. Using a significance level of p < .05, the log rank test and Cox proportional hazards regression were used to compare the outcome of SCR and Pulpotomy and to identify potential prognostic factors, respectively. RESULTS: In all, 58 teeth in the SCR group and 55 teeth in the pulpotomy group completed treatment, after excluding 6 teeth because they did not complete the allocated treatment and another due to severe periodontal disease. At one year, 57/58 (98.3%) teeth from the SCR group and 48/55 (87.3%) teeth from the Pulpotomy group were available for analysis. One tooth in the Pulpotomy group (2.1%) and eight teeth in the SCR group (14.0%) required the further intervention of root canal treatment (p < .05). There were no other significant prognostic factors for survival. Overall, 91.4% of teeth treated with either SCR or Pulpotomy survived without requiring further intervention over a period of one year. No other adverse events occurred over the review period. CONCLUSION: Within the limitations of this study, Pulpotomy fares better than SCR in preserving the remaining pulp and periapical health. As a treatment modality, Pulpotomy carries greater cost outlay to patient and takes a longer time to complete treatment than SCR. Long-term follow-up is needed to study the pulpal and restorative outcomes of Pulpotomy and SCR.
引用
- Chua SKX, Sim YF, Wang WC, et al. One-year outcome of selective caries removal versus pulpotomy treatment of deep caries: A pilot randomized controlled trial. Int Endod J. 2023. PMID: 37795835. doi:10.1111/iej.13978
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。