第2组ITI共识报告:种植修复技术的技术发展
该共识报告系统综述了种植修复中数字化制造技术、基台选择及后牙多单位固定修复体的证据,共纳入67篇文献形成3篇系统综述。共识认为临时冠可选用增材或减材制造,钛基台单冠短期表现与其他基台相似,后牙多单位修复推荐整体氧化锆以减少技术并发症。
要点
- 临时牙色种植单冠可采用增材或减材制造,两者均为可行技术
- 钛基台支持的单冠1年存留率与其他类型基台无显著差异
- 后牙多单位种植固定修复推荐整体氧化锆以降低技术并发症
核心结论
- 临时牙色种植单冠的增材与减材制造均为可行技术,增材制造修复体的临床性能尚待研究。
- 钛基台单冠的临床性能与其他类型基台相似,但仍需随机对照试验的长期临床数据。
- 基台选择应在规划阶段即予考虑,数字化规划有助于实现修复体设计(含基台选择)的三维可视化。
- 后牙区多单位种植修复推荐整体氧化锆作为首选材料以减少技术并发症。
研究设计与样本
- 本共识报告由ITI第2组制定,按PRISMA指南系统筛选文献,共67篇出版物经批判性评价形成3篇系统综述。
- 共识声明提交全体会议讨论,经修改后获得通过。
主要发现
- 增材制造的氧化锆和聚合物种植修复体在边缘/内部适合性及机械性能方面被研究,但无明确结果支持某一技术或材料。
- 钛基台支持螺丝固位种植单冠与定制基台相比,1年存留率无显著差异。
- PFM、饰面氧化锆和整体氧化锆种植支持的后牙多单位固定修复体3年存留率相似且较高,而饰面修复体的年度陶瓷折裂和崩瓷率最高。
关键数值与推荐
- 临时牙色种植单冠:增材和减材制造均为可行技术。
- 钛基台单冠:1年存留率与其他类型基台无显著差异。
- 后牙多单位种植固定修复:推荐整体氧化锆以减少技术并发症。
临床怎么用
- 临时牙色种植单冠可灵活选择增材或减材制造工艺。
- 基台选择应在治疗规划阶段结合数字化三维设计一并考虑。
- 后牙多单位种植固定修复优先选用整体氧化锆以降低陶瓷折裂和崩瓷风险。
局限性
- 增材制造修复体的临床性能尚缺乏研究数据。
- 钛基台单冠的长期临床证据仍需随机对照试验提供。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Group-2 reviewed the scientific evidence in the field of «Technology». Focused research questions were: (1) additive versus subtractive manufacturing of implant restorations; (2) survival, complications, and esthetics comparing prefabricated versus customized abutments; and (3) survival of posterior implant-supported multi-unit fixed dental prostheses. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Literature was systematically screened, and 67 publications could be critically reviewed following PRISMA guidelines, resulting in three systematic reviews. Consensus statements were presented to the plenary where after modification, those were accepted. RESULTS: Additively fabricated implant restorations of zirconia and polymers were investigated for marginal/internal adaptation and mechanical properties without clear results in favor of one technology or material. Titanium base abutments for screw-retained implant single crowns compared to customized abutments did not show significant differences concerning 1-year survival. PFM, veneered and monolithic zirconia implant-supported multi-unit posterior fixed dental prostheses demonstrated similar high 3-year survival rates, whereas veneered restorations exhibited the highest annual ceramic fracture and chipping rates. CONCLUSIONS: For interim tooth-colored implant single crowns both additive and subtractive manufacturing are viable techniques. The clinical performance of additively produced restorations remains to be investigated. Implant single crowns on titanium base abutments show similar clinical performance compared to other type of abutments; however, long-term clinical data from RCTs are needed. The abutment selection should be considered already during the planning phase. Digital planning facilitates 3D visualization of the prosthetic design including abutment selection. In the posterior area, monolithic zirconia is recommended as the material of choice for multi-unit implant restorations to reduce technical complications.
引用
- Derksen W, Joda T, Chantler J, et al. Group 2 ITI Consensus Report: Technological developments in implant prosthetics. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2023. PMID: 37750528. doi:10.1111/clr.14148
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。