四种热处理往复式镍钛器械的设计、冶金学、机械性能与冲洗流场特征
本研究比较了EdgeOne Fire、Easy-File Flex、WaveOne Gold与Reciproc Blue四种热处理往复式镍钛器械的设计、冶金学与机械性能,并用计算流体动力学评估模拟根管预备中的冲洗流型。结果显示各器械在设计、相变温度和扭转/弯曲性能上存在差异,但四组间冲洗流型无显著差异。
要点
- WaveOne Gold与Reciproc Blue的最大扭矩值最高,EdgeOne Fire最低。
- EdgeOne Fire与Reciproc Blue柔韧性最好,差异有统计学意义。
- 四种器械在模拟根管预备中的冲洗流型无显著差异。
核心结论
- 四种热处理往复式器械在设计、相变温度和扭转/弯曲性能上存在差异,但模拟根管预备中冲洗流型无显著组间差异。
研究设计与样本
- 体外实验研究,共纳入124支新器械(EdgeOne Fire Primary、Easy-File Flex Regular 25、WaveOne Gold Primary、Reciproc Blue R25),采用体视显微镜、扫描电镜与3D表面扫描评估设计,能谱分析测定元素组成,差示扫描量热法评估相变温度,并进行扭转与弯曲测试;基于真实牙齿与器械扫描行计算流体动力学评估冲洗流型、根尖压力与壁面剪切应力;统计采用Mood中位数检验与单因素方差分析post hoc Tukey检验(α=5%)。
主要发现
- Reciproc Blue刃数最多(n=8),EdgeOne Fire总体积(4.38 mm3)与表面积(32.32 mm2)最大。
- 距尖端3 mm轴向水平,EdgeOne Fire核心直径最小(0.13 mm),Reciproc Blue最大(0.16 mm)。
- 所有器械刃对称、尖端非切割但彼此不同;EdgeOne Fire与Easy-File Flex表面最不规则。
- 所有器械均为镍钛合金且相变温度各异;WaveOne Gold与Reciproc Blue最大扭矩值最高(分别为1.87与1.62 N cm),EdgeOne Fire最低(1.21 N cm)(p < .05)。
- 柔韧性最好(p < .05)的是EdgeOne Fire(旋转角度602.6°;最大弯曲载荷251.4 g.f)与Reciproc Blue(533.2°与235.6 g.f);四组冲洗流型无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- WaveOne Gold与Reciproc Blue最大扭矩值分别为1.87与1.62 N cm,EdgeOne Fire为1.21 N cm(p < .05)。
- EdgeOne Fire旋转角度602.6°、最大弯曲载荷251.4 g.f;Reciproc Blue为533.2°与235.6 g.f(p < .05)。
- EdgeOne Fire总体积4.38 mm3、表面积32.32 mm2;3 mm轴向水平核心直径EdgeOne Fire 0.13 mm、Reciproc Blue 0.16 mm。
- Reciproc Blue刃数n=8。
- 四组间冲洗流型无显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 选择器械时可参考其在最大扭矩与柔韧性上的差异,结合临床根管解剖与操作需求权衡。
- 本研究提示四种器械的冲洗流型无显著差异,冲洗效果可能更多取决于冲洗方案而非器械类型。
局限性
- 冲洗流型评估基于计算流体动力学模拟,非临床体内验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To compare the design, metallurgy, and mechanical properties of four heat-treated reciprocating instruments coupled with the evaluation of the irrigation flow using an in silico model. METHODOLOGY: New EdgeOne Fire Primary, Easy-File Flex Regular 25, WaveOne Gold Primary and Reciproc Blue R25 instruments (n = 124) were initially evaluated regarding their design through stereomicroscopy, scanning electron microscopy and 3D surface scanning. In addition, energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy was utilized to determine their elemental composition, and differential scanning calorimetry tests to evaluate their phase transformation temperatures. Their mechanical performance was further assessed through torsional and bending tests. Using scans obtained from a real tooth and the instruments, a computational fluid dynamics assessment was conducted to determine the irrigation flow pattern, apical pressure, and wall shear stress in simulated canal preparation. Mood's median and One-way anova post hoc Tukey tests were used for statistical comparisons (α = 5%). RESULTS: Reciproc Blue exhibited a superior number of blades (n = 8), whereas EdgeOne Fire had the highest overall volume (4.38 mm3 ) and surface area (32.32 mm2 ). At the 3-mm axial level, EdgeOne Fire displayed the lowest core diameter (0.13 mm), while Reciproc Blue had the highest (0.16 mm). All blades were symmetrical, and the tips of the instruments were non-active but differed from each other. The most irregular surfaces were observed in EdgeOne Fire and Easy-File Flex. All instruments were manufactured from nickel-titanium alloys and exhibited distinct phase transformation temperatures. WaveOne Gold and Reciproc Blue demonstrated the highest maximum torque values (1.87 and 1.62 N cm, respectively), while the lowest was observed on EdgeOne Fire (1.21 N cm) (p < .05). The most flexible (p < .05) were EdgeOne Fire (angle of rotation: 602.6°; maximum bending load: 251.4 g.f) and Reciproc Blue (533.2° and 235.6 g.f). There were no significant differences observed in the irrigation flow among the four domains generated by the tested instruments. CONCLUSIONS: Despite observing variations in the design, phase transformation temperatures, and in the torsional and bending test outcomes among the four heat-treated reciprocating instruments, no significant differences were found in the irrigation flow pattern among the different groups in the simulated root canal preparations.
引用
- Martins JNR, Silva EJNL, Marques D, et al. Characterization of four heat-treated reciprocating instruments: Design, metallurgy, mechanical performance, and irrigation flow patterns. Int Endod J. 2023. PMID: 37698946. doi:10.1111/iej.13971
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。