文献速递牙体牙髓病

全根管再治疗与选择性根管再治疗的成本效果分析

Cost-effectiveness analysis of full versus selective root canal retreatment.
PubMed 文献 · Int Endod J · 2023-09-21

该研究采用马尔可夫模型,基于荷兰私人支付方视角,模拟50岁患者上颌磨牙仅近中颊根有根尖病变时,选择性再治疗与全根管再治疗的终身成本和效果。结果显示,选择性再治疗在100%模拟中成本更低且牙齿保留时间更长,不受支付意愿阈值影响,但基础数据质量有限,结论需谨慎解读。

要点

  • 选择性再治疗在多根牙单根病变时可能更具成本效果。
  • 模拟中选择性再治疗成本更低且牙齿保留时间更长。
  • 结论需谨慎,因 underlying 数据质量有限。

核心结论

  • 在临床适用时,选择性再治疗对于根管治疗后磨牙伴持续性根尖周炎可能比全再治疗更具成本效果。

研究设计与样本

  • 构建马尔可夫模型,模拟50岁患者上颌磨牙近中颊根根尖病变,接受选择性或全根管再治疗,采用荷兰私人支付方视角,进行蒙特卡洛微模拟和概率敏感性分析。

主要发现

  • 基础案例中,选择性再治疗成本为2137欧元(2.5%-97.5%百分位:1944-2340),效果为19.6年(18.3-20.8);全再治疗成本为2495欧元(2305-2671),效果为16.5年(15.2-17.9)。
  • 在100%的模拟中,选择性再治疗成本更低且更有效,且不受支付意愿阈值影响。
  • 仅在最差情景下选择性再治疗成本更高,但仍更有效。

临床怎么用

  • 对于根管治疗后磨牙伴持续性根尖周炎且病变仅限单根时,可考虑选择性再治疗以节省成本并延长牙齿保留时间。

局限性

  • underlying 数据质量有限,结果应谨慎解读。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: Selective root-canal retreatment has been proposed as an alternative to full retreatment in multirooted, root-canal-filled teeth with evidence of apical pathology, where only the affected root(s) is retreated. Whilst this option may save costs initially, failures and retreatments may compensate for these initial savings. We assessed the cost-effectiveness of full versus selective root-canal retreatment using data from a recent clinical pilot study, employing a modelling approach. METHODOLOGY: A Markov model was constructed to follow up a previously root-canal treated maxillary molar with apical pathology on a single root (mesio-buccal), receiving either selective or full root-canal retreatment. A private-payer perspective in Dutch health care was adopted. Permanent molar teeth with apical lesions on the mesial root were simulated over the lifetime of initially 50-year-old patients. Teeth could have endodontic complications and require interventions such as retreatment or tooth extraction and replacement. Costs were calculated based on the Dutch dental fee catalogues. Monte-Carlo microsimulations were performed to assess lifetime costs and effectiveness (measured as tooth retention time), and the resulting cost-effectiveness. Probabilistic joint uncertainty and sensitivity analyses were performed, and cost-effectiveness at different willingness-to-pay-thresholds was evaluated. RESULTS: In the base-case scenario, selective retreatment was less costly (2137; 2.5%-97.5% percentiles: 1944-2340 Euro) and more effective (19.6; 18.3-20.8 Years) than full retreatment (2495; 2305-2671 Euro; 16.5; 15.2-17.9 Years) in 100% of the simulations and regardless of the willingness-to-pay threshold. Only in a worst case scenario was selective retreatment more costly, but remained more effective. CONCLUSIONS: Selective retreatment, when clinically applicable, is likely to be more cost-effective than full retreatment in endodontically treated molars with persistent apical periodontitis. Our results should be interpreted with caution because the quality of the underlying data is limited.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Brochado Martins JF, Hagay S, Herbst SR, et al. Cost-effectiveness analysis of full versus selective root canal retreatment. Int Endod J. 2023. PMID: 37732616. doi:10.1111/iej.13972

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。