公众对口腔种植体的社交媒体认知:基于评论文本分析的横断面研究
该研究分析YouTube前100个观看最多的种植牙相关视频的评论,纳入74个视频的61,618条评论,通过主题模型和情感分析发现公众最关注手术过程、费用、预后感受和期望,整体情感偏正面,并建议临床医生针对这些关注点传达合理预期。
要点
- 公众讨论热点为手术过程、费用、预后感受和期望。
- 公众对种植牙整体情感偏正面,但对疼痛负面、费用中性。
- 临床应针对公众关注点传达合理预期并提供多学科方案。
核心结论
- 公众对种植牙的关注热点为手术过程、费用、预后感受和期望。
- 公众对种植牙的整体情感以正面为主。
- 多学科联合治疗已成为手术过程主题下的新热门子话题。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,分析YouTube前100个观看最多的种植牙相关视频的评论。
- 最终纳入74个视频,共61,618条评论。
- 采用LDA主题模型、词共现分析和情感分析,并用GQS标准和9分有用性评分评估视频质量。
主要发现
- 多数视频面向公众且观看和评论量高,但主题单一且质量低。
- 评论中最常讨论的主题是手术过程、费用、与预后相关的感受和期望。
- 公众对美学和健康表达正面情感,对疼痛表达负面情感,对费用持中性情感。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应针对公众最关注的手术过程、费用、感受和期望传达合理预期与理解。
- 提供有充分依据的多学科治疗方案以满足公众日益增长的需求。
- 可利用文本挖掘从社交媒体探索公众对口腔医学的兴趣点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the most discussed topics and possible new interests in dental implants among the public, as well as the public sentiments toward dental implants through topic and sentiment analysis of online comments. METHODS: Comments of the top 100 most viewed dental implant-related YouTube videos were studied. The comments were analyzed by topic analysis (LDA topic model, Word co-occurrence analysis) and sentiment analysis. The basic information of videos was collected and classified. Video quality was evaluated by GQS criteria and 9-point usefulness scoring system. Statistical analyses were performed using Kruskal-Wallis test, Mann-Whitney U-tests, and Spearman correlation analysis. RESULTS: 74 videos with 61,618 comments were considered eligible in this study. Most videos targeted the public with high viewing and comments, but the theme was single and the quality was low. From topic analysis, the most discussed topics in the comments were procedure, cost, feelings associated with prognosis, and expectations. Multidisciplinary approaches in implant dentistry were frequently discussed. From sentiment analysis, the public mainly expressed positive sentiment through comments. In detail, the public had positive feelings about aesthetics and health, negative feelings about pain, and neutral feelings about cost. CONCLUSION: The hot topics of public concern were procedure, cost, feelings associated with prognosis, and expectations. Intriguingly, multidisciplinary approaches in implant dentistry have emerged as a new hot subtopic within the topic "procedure". Based on the sentiment analysis of the comments, the general sentiment expressed by the public toward dental implants was predominantly positive. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Text mining can extract data from social media to explore public interest in dentistry. Clinicians should convey reasonable expectations and understanding about dental implants, especially addressing the most public-concerned topics (procedure, cost, feelings, and expectations), and provide patients with well-grounded multidisciplinary treatment plans to meet the growing public demand.
引用
- Ma S, Bai C, Chen C, et al. Public sense of dental implants on social media: A cross-sectional study based on text analysis of comments. J Dent. 2023. PMID: 37604395. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2023.104671
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。