不同冲洗技术在模拟重度弯曲复杂根管系统中的清洁效率
本研究在3D打印的60°弯曲、半径5 mm、尺寸25/.06的根管模型(含侧支根管)中,比较激光激活冲洗(LAI)与另外五种冲洗技术对模拟生物膜水凝胶的清除效率。结果显示LAI在全系统(89.3%±5.9%)和侧支根管中清除率最高,声波激活冲洗EDDY(SAI-E)在主根管中效果相当,传统针头冲洗、手动搅动和EndoActivator效果最差。
要点
- LAI在全系统和侧支根管中清除模拟生物膜效果最佳。
- SAI-E在主根管中清除效果与LAI相当。
- 传统针头冲洗、手动搅动和EndoActivator清除效果最差。
核心结论
- 在模拟重度弯曲复杂根管系统中,LAI对模拟生物膜水凝胶的清除效果优于其他技术,尤其在侧支根管中优势明显。
研究设计与样本
- 采用3D打印根管模型(60°弯曲,半径5 mm,尺寸25/.06,总长20 mm,距根尖2、5、8 mm处各方向设直径0.2 mm侧支根管),填充着色模拟生物膜水凝胶,比较六种冲洗方案(每组n=20,每次3×20秒连续冲洗,蒸馏水3 ml/20秒)。
主要发现
- LAI全系统水凝胶清除率为89.3%±5.9%,显著高于SAI-E(65.5%±3.3%)和超声激活冲洗(59.1%±4.7%)(P < .05)。
- 传统针头冲洗、手动搅动和EndoActivator之间无显著差异(P > .05),且清除值显著最低(P < .05)。
- LAI和SAI-E在主根管中清除率显著最佳(P < .05)。
- 在三个侧支根管水平上,LAI的清除率均显著高于所有其他技术(P < .05)。
临床怎么用
- 对于重度弯曲且存在侧支根管的复杂根管系统,可优先考虑激光激活冲洗以提高清洁效果。
局限性
- 研究使用3D打印模型和模拟生物膜水凝胶,结果是否适用于真实根管系统需进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: To compare the biofilm-mimicking hydrogel removal efficiency of laser-activated irrigation (LAI) with five other irrigation techniques in simulated curved root canals with lateral canals. METHODS: Three-dimensional-printed root canal models (60°-curvature, radius 5 mm; dimension 25/.06) with a total length of 20 mm and lateral canals in all directions at 2, 5, and 8 mm (diameter 0.2 mm) from the apex were filled with a colored biofilm-mimicking hydrogel. The following protocols (each 3 × 20 seconds continuous irrigation with distilled water 3 ml/20 seconds; n = 20) were carried out: conventional needle irrigation; manual agitation ([MA], gutta-percha point 25/.06); EndoActivator (=sonically-activated irrigation EndoActivator, 25/.04); EDDY (=sonically-activated irrigation EDDY [SAI-E]; 25/.04); ultrasonically-activated irrigation and LAI (Erbium-doped Yttrium Aluminum Garnet laser; P400FL tip at canal entrance; 25 pps, 50 mJ, 300 μs). Standardized photos were taken with a microscope and the removal of the hydrogel was determined as a percentage for the entire system, the main canal and the lateral canals. Statistical analysis was performed using analysis of variance and Scheffé test (P = .05). RESULTS: LAI (89.3% ± 5.9%) showed the greatest hydrogel removal followed by SAI-E (65.5% ± 3.3%) and ultrasonically-activated irrigation (59.1% ± 4.7%), with significant differences between these groups (P < .05). Needle irrigation, MA, and sonically-activated irrigation EndoActivator performed equally (P > .05) and obtained the significantly lowest values (P < .05). LAI and SAI-E showed the significantly best hydrogel removal from the main canal (P < .05). At all three levels, LAI removed significantly more hydrogel from the lateral canals than all other techniques (P < .05). CONCLUSIONS: LAI was superior to other techniques in both the entire system and the lateral canals in removing the hydrogel. SAI-E achieved comparable results in the main canal.
引用
- Donnermeyer D, Averkorn C, Bürklein S, et al. Cleaning Efficiency of Different Irrigation Techniques in Simulated Severely Curved Complex Root Canal Systems. J Endod. 2023. PMID: 37586645. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2023.08.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。