口内光学扫描与立体摄影测量全牙弓种植印模精度对比
这项前瞻性体内研究纳入11例需种植支持氧化锆全牙弓固定修复的患者,比较口内光学扫描(IOS)与立体摄影测量(SPG)的全牙弓种植印模精度。以开窗托盘石膏印模为参考,SPG在三维偏差和角度偏差上均显著优于IOS,且精度不受牙弓类型或种植体数量的影响。
要点
- SPG全牙弓种植印模精度显著优于IOS。
- IOS出现更高极端偏差,临床应用需谨慎。
- 建议螺丝固位修复前进行刚性原型试戴。
核心结论
- SPG在全牙弓种植印模中表现出显著更高的线性与角度精度。
- 未检测到牙弓类型或种植体数量对精度的影响。
- IOS出现更高的极端偏差,SPG可谨慎用于全牙弓数字印模。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性体内比较研究,连续纳入需种植支持氧化锆全牙弓固定修复的患者。
- 共11例患者11个全牙弓(上颌5、下颌6),由4颗(n=8)和6颗(n=3)种植体支持。
- 每例取三种印模:IOS、SPG(试验组)和开窗托盘石膏印模(参考)。
主要发现
- 共50颗种植体、100个种植位点被两种设备捕获并与参考比较。
- 平均ΔEUC:IOS为137.2 μm,SPG为87.6 μm;平均ΔANGLE:IOS为0.79°,SPG为0.38°。
关键数值与推荐
- 平均ΔEUC:IOS 137.2 μm,SPG 87.6 μm。
- 平均ΔANGLE:IOS 0.79°,SPG 0.38°。
临床怎么用
- 全牙弓种植数字印模可优先考虑SPG以获得更高精度。
- 使用IOS进行全牙弓印模时应警惕更高极端偏差。
- SPG印模后建议制作刚性原型试戴,再行螺丝固位修复体制造。
局限性
- 样本量较小(11例患者、11个全牙弓、50颗种植体)。
- 仅评估了IOS和SPG两种设备,未涉及其他印模技术。
- 研究为体内研究,但未报告长期修复体存活或并发症数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess accuracy of intraoral optical scanning (IOS) and stereophotogrammetry (SPG), complete-arch digital implant impressions in vivo. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Consecutive patients needing implant-supported screw-retained zirconia complete-arch fixed-dental prostheses (ISZ-FDP) were recruited. For each patient, three impressions were taken: IOS, SPG (tests), and open-tray plaster (reference). Linear (ΔX, ΔY, and ΔZ), three-dimensional (ΔEUC), and angular deviations (ΔANGLE) were evaluated and stratified according to scanning technology for each implant. Potential effects of impression device (IOS and SPG), arch (maxilla and mandible), and implant number (4 and 6) were evaluated through multivariable analysis. Significance level was set at .05. RESULTS: A total of 11 complete arches (5 maxillae, 6 mandibles) in 11 patients were rehabilitated with ISZ-FDPs supported by 4 (n = 8) and 6 implants (n = 3). A total of 50 implants and 100 implant positions were captured by two investigated devices and compared to respective reference (mean ΔEUC IOS 137.2, SPG 87.6 μm; mean ΔANGLE 0.79, 0.38°). Differences between measurements (SPG-IOS) were computed for each implant, with negative values indicating better SPG accuracy. Significant mean ΔEUC difference of -49.60 μm (p = .0143; SD 138.15) and mean ΔANGLE difference of -0.40° (p < .0001; SD 0.65) were observed in favor of SPG. Multivariable analysis showed significant effect on ΔEUC (p = .0162) and ΔANGLE (p = .0001) only for impression devices, with SPG performing better. CONCLUSIONS: SPG experienced significantly higher linear and angular accuracy. No effect of type of arch or implant number was detected. Higher extreme deviations were experienced for IOS. SPG can be feasible for complete-arch digital impressions with caution, and rigid prototype try-in is recommended before screw-retained prosthesis manufacturing.
引用
- Pozzi A, Carosi P, Gallucci GO, et al. Accuracy of complete-arch digital implant impression with intraoral optical scanning and stereophotogrammetry: An in vivo prospective comparative study. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2023. PMID: 37485737. doi:10.1111/clr.14141
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。