扫描辅助装置提升无牙颌多颗种植体口内扫描精度:一项体内研究
本研究在22例患者87颗种植体上,比较使用与不使用扫描辅助装置时两种口内扫描仪(CS3600与TRIOS3)的扫描精度。结果显示扫描辅助装置显著改善CS3600的线性偏差(189 μm降至135 μm,p=.001),对TRIOS3无显著影响,但两系统扫描体识别成功率均提高。
要点
- 扫描辅助装置可改善主动三角测量型扫描仪的线性偏差
- 扫描辅助装置对共聚焦显微镜型扫描仪精度无显著影响
- 使用扫描辅助装置可提高两种系统扫描体的识别成功率
核心结论
- 扫描辅助装置改善了CS3600组的线性偏差,但对TRIOS3组无改善。
- 差异可能源于主动三角测量与共聚焦显微镜两种扫描技术不同。
- 扫描辅助装置提高了两种系统成功识别扫描体的能力,可能具有整体临床益处。
研究设计与样本
- 体内研究,纳入22例患者共87颗种植体。
- 分别使用CS3600(CS)和TRIOS3(TR)两种口内扫描仪,在有扫描辅助装置(SA)和无扫描辅助装置(NO)条件下扫描。
- 以实验室扫描仪数字化主模型作为参考,通过检查软件 superimpose 虚拟模型并测量线性偏差与精度。
- 统计分析采用线性混合模型,α=.05。
主要发现
- CS组总平均线性偏差:无扫描辅助装置189 μm,使用扫描辅助装置135 μm。
- TR组总平均偏差:使用与不使用扫描辅助装置均为165 μm。
- CS组使用扫描辅助装置改善显著(p=.001),TR组无差异。
- 扫描体成功扫描率:TR-SA组96%,TR-NO组86%,CS-SA组83%,CS-NO组70%。
临床怎么用
- 对使用主动三角测量型口内扫描仪的无牙颌多颗种植体扫描,可考虑使用扫描辅助装置以降低线性偏差。
- 扫描辅助装置有助于提高扫描体识别成功率,可能减少重复扫描。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性相关内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Intraoral scans of multiple implants in the edentulous arch are challenged by the absence of a distinct surface morphology between scan bodies. A scan aid was applied in such situation and evaluated for intraoral scanning accuracy in vivo. MATERIALS AND METHODS: 87 implants in 22 patients were scanned with scan aid (SA) and without scan aid (NO) using two different intraoral scanners (CS3600 [CS] and TRIOS3 [TR]). Master casts were digitized by a laboratory scanner. Virtual models were superimposed using an inspection software and Linear deviation and precision were measured. Statistical analysis was performed using linear mixed models (α = .05). RESULTS: Total mean linear deviation within the CS group was 189 μm without scan aid and 135 μm when using the scan aid. The TR group's total mean deviation was 165 μm with and without a scan aid. Significant improvement with scan aid was observed for the CS group (p = .001), and no difference was found in the TR group. 96% of scan bodies were successfully scanned in the TR-SA group compared to 86% for the TR-NO group, 83% for the CS-SA, and 70% for the CS-NO group, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The evaluated scan aid improved linear deviation compared to unsplinted scans for the CS group but not for the TR group. These differences could originate from different scanning technologies used, active triangulation (CS) and confocal microscopy (TR). The scan aid improved the ability to recognize scan bodies successfully with both systems, which could have a favorable clinical impact overall.
引用
- Kernen F, Brändle D, Wagendorf O, et al. Enhancing intraoral scanner accuracy using scan aid for multiple implants in the edentulous arch: An in vivo study. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2023. PMID: 37314046. doi:10.1111/clr.14107
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。