牙冠外形对邻间清洁工具去除人工生物膜效果的影响:一项体外研究
凹形冠基底面清洁率显著更优(p < .001),牙线与Superfloss去除效果显著优于其他工具(p < .05),但所有工具均无法完全去除邻间/基底面生物膜。
要点
- 凹形冠基底面人工生物膜去除效果最佳,直形次之,凸形最差
- 牙线与Superfloss的清洁效果显著优于其他受测工具
- 所有受测清洁工具均无法完全去除邻间/基底面人工生物膜
核心结论
- 凹形冠外形在基底面的人工生物膜去除效果最佳,其次为直形冠和凸形冠。
- 牙线与Superfloss是去除人工生物膜最有效的邻间清洁工具。
- 所有受测清洁工具均无法完全去除邻间/基底面的人工生物膜。
研究设计与样本
- 体外研究:下颌缺第一磨牙模型安装单种植体类似体并载入凹形、直形、凸形三种牙冠。
- 牙冠卸下后标准化拍照,以清洁率(清洁面积/受测表面积)为结局指标。
主要发现
- 基底面凹形冠清洁率显著更优(p < .001),除冲牙器外所有工具均显示该优势。
- 清洁工具、表面与牙冠外形Overall效应显著(p < .0001),受试者因素不显著。
- 各工具平均清洁率(%):牙线43.02 ± 23.93,Superfloss 42.51 ± 25.92,电动邻间刷36.21 ± 18.78,邻间刷29.10 ± 15.95,电动冲牙器9.72 ± 8.14。
- 牙线与Superfloss去除菌斑效果显著优于其他工具(p < .05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 凹形冠基底面清洁率显著优于其他外形(p < .001),但冲牙器未显示该差异。
- 牙线与Superfloss清洁效果显著优于其他工具(p < .05)。
- 平均清洁率:牙线43.02 ± 23.93%,Superfloss 42.51 ± 25.92%,电动邻间刷36.21 ± 18.78%,邻间刷29.10 ± 15.95%,电动冲牙器9.72 ± 8.14%。
临床怎么用
- 种植冠邻面外形设计可优先考虑凹形以利于邻间清洁。
- 向种植冠患者推荐牙线或Superfloss作为邻间清洁工具。
- 应告知患者现有清洁工具无法完全清除邻间/基底面生物膜。
局限性
- 为体外研究,使用人工生物膜与模型,结论外推至临床需谨慎。
- 受试者包含非专业人员,可能影响清洁效果的普遍性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the efficacy of various interdental cleaning aids for artificial biofilm removal on different implant-supported crown designs. METHODS: Mandibular models with missing first molar were fabricated and installed with single implant analogs and loaded with crowns of different designs (concave, straight, and convex). Artificial biofilm was made with occlusion spray. Thirty volunteers (periodontists, dental hygienists, and laypersons) were asked to clean the interproximal areas. The crowns were unscrewed and photographed in a standardized setting. The outcome was measured by the cleaning ratio which represents the cleaned surfaces in relation to the area of the tested surface. RESULTS: A significant difference in favor of concave crown (p < .001) on the basal surface was cleaned by all tools, except the water flosser. There was evidence of an overall effect of "cleaning tool," "surface," and "crown design" (p < .0001) except for the "participant" factor. The mean cleaning ratio for each cleaning tool and overall combined surfaces were (in%): dental floss: 43.02 ± 23.93, superfloss: 42.51 ± 25.92, electric interspace brush: 36.21 ± 18.78, interdental brush: 29.10 ± 15.95, and electric water flosser: 9.72 ± 8.14. Dental floss and superfloss were significantly better (p < .05) than other tools in removing plaque. CONCLUSIONS: Concave crown contour had the greatest artificial biofilm removal, followed by straight and convex crowns at the basal surface. Dental floss and superfloss were the most effective interdental cleaning devices for artificial biofilm removal. None of the tested cleaning devices were able to completely remove the artificial biofilm from the interproximal/basal surfaces.
引用
- Sirinirund B, Siqueira R, Li J, et al. Effects of crown contour on artificial biofilm removal efficacy with interdental cleaning aids: An in vitro study. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2023. PMID: 37269176. doi:10.1111/clr.14105
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。