文献速递牙体牙髓病

牙体牙髓病领域动物研究PRIASE 2021报告质量分析

Critical analysis of the reporting quality of animal studies within Endodontics using the Preferred Reporting Items for Animal Studies in Endodontics (PRIASE) 2021 quality standard checklist.
PubMed 文献 · Int Endod J · 2023-06-20

4篇(8%)报告质量为高,46篇(92%)为中等;报告质量与作者数、通讯作者来源、期刊类型、影响因子或发表年份均无关联。

要点

  • 牙体牙髓病动物研究多数(92%)报告质量为中等,仅8%为高质量。
  • 背景、方法/结果相关性及图像解读条目在所有研究中均充分报告。
  • 报告质量与作者数、通讯作者来源、期刊类型、影响因子及发表年份无关。

核心结论

  • 牙体牙髓病专业发表的动物研究按PRIASE 2021清单评价,报告质量大多为中等。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用PRIASE 2021清单逐项评分:完全报告记1分,未报告记0分,部分报告记0.5分。
  • 根据总分将报告质量分为低、中、高三类,并分析研究特征与报告质量评分的关联。

主要发现

  • 4篇(8%)动物研究报告质量为高,46篇(92%)为中等。
  • 背景(条目4a)、方法/结果相关性(7a)和图像解读(11e)在所有研究中均充分报告。
  • 方案变更(6d)是唯一在所有研究中均未报告的条目。
  • 报告质量评分与作者数量、通讯作者来源、期刊类型(牙体牙髓专科与非专科)、影响因子或发表年份均无关联。

关键数值与推荐

  • PRIASE 2021清单评分:完全报告记1分,未报告记0分,部分报告记0.5分。
  • 报告质量分为低、中、高三类,具体分类阈值原文未报告。

临床怎么用

  • 口腔科医生在解读牙体牙髓病动物研究时,需注意多数研究报告质量为中等,应谨慎评估其证据强度。
  • 建议研究者在发表动物研究时遵循PRIASE 2021指南,以提升报告质量。

局限性

  • 报告质量分类的低、中、高阈值未在原文中明确说明。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: To critically evaluate the reporting quality of a random sample of animal studies within the field of endodontics against the Preferred Reporting Items for Animal Studies in Endodontics (PRIASE) 2021 checklist and to investigate the association between the quality of reporting and several characteristics of the selected studies. METHODOLOGY: Fifty animal studies related to endodontics were randomly selected from the PubMed database with publication dates from January 2017 to December 2021. For each study, a score of '1' was given when the item of the PRIASE 2021 checklist was fully reported, whereas a score of '0' was given when an item was not reported; when the item was inadequately or partially reported, a score of '0.5' was given. Based on the overall scores allocated to each manuscript, they were allocated into three categories of reporting quality: low, moderate and high. Associations between study characteristics and reporting quality scores were also analysed. Descriptive statistics and Fisher's exact tests were used to describe the data and determine associations. The probability value of .05 was selected as the level of statistical significance. RESULTS: Based on the overall scores, four (8%) and 46 (92%) of the animal studies evaluated were categorized as 'High' and 'Moderate' reporting quality, respectively. A number of items were adequately reported in all studies related to background (Item 4a), relevance of methods/results (7a) and interpretation of images (11e), whereas only one item related to changes in protocol (6d) was not reported in any. No associations were confirmed between reporting quality scores and number of authors, origin of the corresponding author, journal of publication (endodontic specialty vs. non- specialty), impact factor or year of publication. CONCLUSIONS: Animal studies published in the specialty of endodontics were mostly of 'moderate' quality in terms of the quality of reporting. Adherence to the PRIASE 2021 guidelines will enhance the reporting of animal studies in the expectation that all future publications will be high quality.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Tzanetakis G, Jakovljevic A, Koletsi D, et al. Critical analysis of the reporting quality of animal studies within Endodontics using the Preferred Reporting Items for Animal Studies in Endodontics (PRIASE) 2021 quality standard checklist. Int Endod J. 2023. PMID: 37300853. doi:10.1111/iej.13944

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。