病理特征聚类分析在口腔病理学教学中的应用
本研究提出以学生为主导的病理学特征聚类分析(PFC)教学法,纳入武汉大学口腔医学院77名本科生,分层随机分为4组(每组18~20名)。课前测试中主题1、2、3的总结组得分均高于非总结组,期末考试成绩两组无显著差异;81.8%(63/77)学生对PFC教学法非常满意。PFC教学法可提高本科生病理鉴别诊断能力。
要点
- 课前测试中主题1、2、3的总结组得分均显著高于非总结组。
- 期末考试成绩在主题1、2、3、4中总结组与非总结组差异均无统计学意义。
- 81.8%(63/77)学生对PFC教学法非常满意,各问卷条目均分4.19~4.77分。
核心结论
- 本研究提出的PFC教学方法可提高本科生的病理鉴别诊断能力。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入武汉大学口腔医学院2018级77名本科生,采用分层随机抽样方法分为4组,每组18~20名同学。
- 每组从口腔黏膜疾病、牙源性肿瘤及瘤样病变与口腔颌面部囊肿、唾液腺疾病、上皮源性肿瘤和瘤样病变4个主题中选择一类疾病总结组织学特征。
- 讨论特定类型疾病时,选择该类疾病为主题的小组为总结组(SG组),其他组为非总结组(NSG组)。
- 通过比较课前测试成绩和期末考试成绩评价教学效果,通过李克特量表问卷(8个客观问题和1个主观问题,每个问题1~5分)评估学生接受度。
- 各组间差异采用Mann-Whitney U非参数检验进行比较。
主要发现
- 课前测试中,主题1的SG组得分为(5.6±0.8)分,高于NSG组的(5.1±1.0)分(U=402.50,P=0.047)。
- 课前测试中,主题2的SG组得分为5.0(1.0)分,高于NSG组的4.0(2.5)分(U=392.00,P=0.026)。
- 课前测试中,主题3的SG组得分为(2.9±1.0)分,高于NSG组的1.5(2.5)分(U=295.00,P=0.003)。
- 期末考试成绩显示,在主题1、2、3、4中,SG组与NSG组的分数差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
- 问卷调查显示,81.8%(63/77)学生非常满意,13.0%(10/77)学生感到满意,5.2%(4/77)学生基本满意;李克特量表每个问题的平均分在4.19~4.77分之间。
关键数值与推荐
- 课前测试主题1:SG组(5.6±0.8)分 vs NSG组(5.1±1.0)分(U=402.50,P=0.047)。
- 课前测试主题2:SG组5.0(1.0)分 vs NSG组4.0(2.5)分(U=392.00,P=0.026)。
- 课前测试主题3:SG组(2.9±1.0)分 vs NSG组1.5(2.5)分(U=295.00,P=0.003)。
- 期末考试成绩主题1、2、3、4中SG组与NSG组差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
- 问卷满意度:非常满意81.8%(63/77),满意13.0%(10/77),基本满意5.2%(4/77);李克特量表各问题平均分4.19~4.77分。
临床怎么用
- PFC教学法通过学生聚类相同病理特征疾病并组间分享总结结果,可提高本科生病理鉴别诊断能力。
- 组间分享后SG组与NSG组课前测试差异缩小,期末考试成绩无显著差异,进一步证明PFC教学方法的有效性。
- 学生反馈认为PFC教学法对口腔病理学的学习有较积极的影响。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
To propose a new student-guided teaching method, in which students carried out the clustering of different diseases with the same pathological characteristics, and differentiated diagnosis of these diseases. This method was named pathological feature clustering (PFC). Seventy-seven undergraduates of School of Stomatology, Wuhan University were enrolled. Stratified random sampling method was adopted to divide the students into 4 groups with 18-20 students in each group. Each group of students selected a disease from the following four topics as the theme and summarize the histological characteristics of the disease: ①oral mucosal disease;②odontogenic tumors and tumor-like lesions, oral and maxillofacial cysts; ③salivary gland diseases;④epithelial-derived tumors and tumor-like lesions (referred to as topics 1, 2, 3, and 4, respectively). When discussing a specific type of disease, the group which select the topic was the summary group (SG), and the other groups were the non-summary group (NSG). After summarizing, students shared the summary results through PPTs, and teachers made comments and supplements. The teaching effect was evaluated by comparing the results of the pre-class test and the final examination. Students' acceptance of PFC teaching method was evaluated through a questionnaire, which included 8 objective questions and 1 subjective question. Likert-scale was used to design the questionnaire, with 1 to 5 points for each question. Students rated each question according to their own situation. Differences among groups were compared by Mann-Whitney U nonparametric test. The pre-class test results showed that the scores of students in SG group in subjects 1, 2, 3 [(5.6±0.8), 5.0(1.0) and (2.9±1.0) points for subjects 1, 2 and 3, respectively] were higher than those in NSG group [(5.1±1.0), 4.0(2.5) and 1.5(2.5) points] (U=402.50, P=0.047; U=392.00, P=0.026; U=295.00, P=0.003). The final examination results showed that there was no significant difference between the scores of the SG group and the NSG group in subjects 1, 2, 3 and 4 (P>0.05). These results showed that the differences between SG and NSG groups were reduced after the summarizing and share between groups, further demonstrating the effectiveness of the PFC teaching method. The results of questionnaire showed that 81.8%(63/77) students were completely satisfied with PFC teaching method, 13.0%(10/77) students were satisfied and 5.2%(4/77) students were basically satisfied. According to the feedback of Likert scale objective evaluation questionnaire, the mean score of each question ranged from 4.19 to 4.77, indicating that students believed that PFC teaching method had a positive impact on the learning of oral pathology. The PFC teaching method proposed in this study could improve the ability of pathological differential diagnosis of undergraduates. 本研究提出一种以学生为主导的新教学方法,即病理学特征聚类分析(pathological feature clustering,PFC)法,学生将具有相同病理特征的不同疾病进行聚类,并对这些疾病进行鉴别诊断。纳入武汉大学口腔医学院2018级77名本科生,采用分层随机抽样方法将学生分为4组,每组18~20名同学。每组学生将从以下4个主题中选择一类疾病作为主题并总结疾病的组织学特征:①口腔黏膜疾病;②牙源性肿瘤及瘤样病变,口腔颌面部囊肿;③唾液腺疾病;④上皮源性肿瘤和瘤样病变(简称为主题1、2、3、4)。在讨论特定类型疾病时,选择该类疾病为主题的小组为总结组(SG组),其他组为非总结组(NSG组)。各组学生通过相同的病理特征对疾病进行总结后,通过幻灯片分享展示总结结果,并由教师进行点评和补充。通过比较课前测试成绩和期末考试成绩评价教学效果。通过调查问卷评估学生对PFC教学方法的接受度(≥3分表示满意),问卷包括8个客观问题和1个主观问题,问卷采用李克特量表(Likert-scale)设计,每个问题1~5分,学生根据自身情况对每个问题打分。各组间的差异采用Mann-Whitney U非参数检验进行比较。课前测试结果显示,主题1、2、3的SG组学生得分[分别为(5.6±0.8)、5.0(1.0)和(2.9±1.0)分]均显著高于NSG组[分别为(5.1±1.0)、4.0(2.5)和1.5(2.5)分](U=402.50,P=0.047;U=392.00,P=0.026;U=295.00,P=0.003)。期末考试成绩显示,在主题1、2、3、4中,SG组与NSG组的分数差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。经过组间分享PFC教学方法的总结结果后,SG组与NSG组之间的差异缩小,进一步证明PFC教学方法的有效性。问卷调查结果显示,81.8%(63/77)学生对PFC教学方法非常满意,13.0%(10/77)学生感到满意,5.2%(4/77)学生基本满意。根据李克特量表客观评价问卷的反馈,每个问题的平均分在4.19~4.77分之间不等,表明学生认为PFC教学法对口腔病理学的学习有较积极的影响。本研究提出的PFC教学方法可提高本科生的病理鉴别诊断能力。.
引用
- Sun YN, Wang L, Yang SD, et al. [Application of pathological feature clustering in oral pathology teaching]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2023. PMID: 37082850. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20220730-00425
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。