文献速递牙体牙髓病

往复式与平侧热处理旋转单锉系统的设计与机械性能对比分析

Comparative analysis of reciprocating and flat-side heat-treated rotary single-file systems: Design, metallurgical characteristics, and mechanical performance.
PubMed 文献 · Int Endod J · 2023-04-19

本研究通过多方法评估比较了两种平侧单锉旋转系统(AF F One Blue 25/0.06 和 Platinum V.EU 25/0.06)与三种单锉往复系统(One Files Blue R25、Reciproc Blue R25、Reciproc R25)的设计、冶金特征和机械性能。共纳入 290 根新镍钛锉,评估宏观/微观设计、镍钛元素比、相变温度及机械性能。结果显示平侧旋转锉在循环疲劳(两种顺时针运动学)、最大扭矩、旋转角度和最大屈曲强度方面均低于往复锉,且部分平侧锉存在制造不一致性。

要点

  • 平侧旋转锉在循环疲劳(两种顺时针运动学)、最大扭矩、旋转角度和最大屈曲强度方面均低于往复锉(p < .05)。
  • 旋转系统也表现出较低的柔韧性(p < .05)。
  • AF F One Blue 显微硬度最低,Reciproc 最高;部分平侧锉存在不连续段、方向不同和蓝色均匀性不一致等制造问题。

核心结论

  • 平侧旋转锉在循环疲劳(两种顺时针运动学)、最大扭矩、旋转角度、最大屈曲强度和柔韧性方面均低于往复锉。
  • 部分平侧锉存在制造不一致性,包括不连续段、方向不同和热处理导致的蓝色均匀性不一致。

研究设计与样本

  • 选取 290 根新的镍钛单锉旋转系统(AF F One Blue 25/0.06 和 Platinum V.EU 25/0.06)和往复系统(One Files Blue R25、Reciproc Blue R25、Reciproc R25)进行多方法评估。
  • 评估内容包括宏观和微观设计、镍钛元素比、相变温度以及机械性能(断裂时间/旋转、最大扭矩、旋转角度、显微硬度、最大弯曲和屈曲强度)。
  • 统计比较采用单因素方差分析 post hoc Tukey、T 检验和非参数 Mood 中位数检验(α = 5%)。

主要发现

  • 测试锉的刃数相同,螺旋角接近,旋转锉约为 24°,往复锉约为 151°。
  • 平侧分析显示少数不一致性,如不连续段、方向不同和蓝色均匀性间隙。
  • 显微镜下,平侧锉表现出刃不连续和不完整的 S 形横截面。
  • One Files Blue 表面更光滑,两种旋转锉表面更不规则。
  • 所有热处理锉在测试温度(20°C)下为 R 相排列,Reciproc 为 R 相加奥氏体。

关键数值与推荐

  • 与往复锉相比,两种平侧锉在两种不同顺时针运动学的循环疲劳测试、最大扭矩、旋转角度和最大屈曲强度方面均显示较低结果(p < .05)。
  • 旋转系统也表现出较低的柔韧性(p < .05)。
  • AF F One Blue 显微硬度最低,Reciproc 最高。

临床怎么用

  • 根据体外机械性能测试结果,平侧旋转单锉系统在循环疲劳、最大扭矩、旋转角度、最大屈曲强度和柔韧性方面低于往复单锉系统。
  • 部分平侧旋转锉存在制造不一致性,包括不连续段、方向不同和蓝色均匀性不一致。

局限性

  • 原文未述局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: To compare two flat-side single-file rotary instruments with three single-file reciprocating systems through a multimethod assessment. METHODOLOGY: A total of 290 new NiTi single-file rotary (AF F One Blue 25/0.06 and Platinum V.EU 25/0.06) and reciprocating (One Files Blue R25, Reciproc Blue R25, Reciproc R25) instruments were selected, carefully examined for any major deformations, and evaluated regarding their macroscopic and microscopic design, nickel and titanium elements ratio, phase transformation temperatures, and mechanical performance (time/rotation to fracture, maximum torque, angle of rotation, microhardness, maximum bending, and buckling strengths). One-way anova post hoc Tukey, T-test, and nonparametric Mood's median tests were used for statistical comparisons (α = 5%). RESULTS: Tested instruments had identical blade counts and near-identical helical angles of approximately 24° (rotary instruments) and 151° (reciprocating instruments). The flat-side analysis revealed a few inconsistencies, such as discontinuity segments, different orientations, and gaps in the homogeneity of the bluish colour. Microscopically, flat-side instruments exhibited blade discontinuity and an incomplete S-shaped cross-section. The surface finish was smoother for One Files Blue and more irregular for both rotary instruments. There were distinct phase transformation temperatures amongst all instruments. All heat-treated instruments were in R-phase arrangement, and Reciproc was in R-phase plus austenite at test temperature (20°C). Compared with the reciprocating instruments, both flat-side instruments exhibited lower results in the cyclic fatigue tests using two different clockwise kinematics, maximum torque, angle of rotation, and maximum buckling strength (p < .05). The rotary systems also exhibited low flexibility (p < .05). AF F One Blue had the lowest microhardness, whilst Reciproc had the highest value. CONCLUSION: This multimethod investigation revealed that the flat-side rotary instruments underperformed the reciprocating instruments regarding cyclic fatigue (with two different clockwise kinematics), maximum torque, angle of rotation, maximum buckling strength, and flexibility. Manufacturing inconsistencies were also observed in some of the flat-side instruments, including discontinuity segments, different orientations, and in the homogeneity of their bluish colour given by the heat treatment.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Martins JNR, Silva EJNL, Baruwa AO, et al. Comparative analysis of reciprocating and flat-side heat-treated rotary single-file systems: Design, metallurgical characteristics, and mechanical performance. Int Endod J. 2023. PMID: 37029571. doi:10.1111/iej.13920

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。