文献速递口腔修复与种植

静态与动态计算机辅助种植手术精度比较:体外研究

Accuracy of dental implant placement using static versus dynamic computer-assisted implant surgery: An in vitro study.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent · 2023-03-21

该体外研究在3D打印部分缺牙上颌模型上比较静态与动态计算机辅助种植手术(CAIS)在FDI 15、16位点植入种植体的精度。每种方法各10个模型、20枚种植体。两种方法均实现准确植入,但动态CAIS在体外环境中近中方向偏差更高,且种植位点影响两种方法的精度。

要点

  • 静态与动态CAIS均能实现准确的种植体植入。
  • 动态CAIS在体外环境中近中方向偏差更高。
  • 种植位点(15 vs 16)影响两种CAIS方法的精度。

核心结论

  • 静态与动态CAIS均实现准确的种植体植入,但动态CAIS在体外环境中近中方向偏差更高,且种植位点影响两种方法的精度。

主要发现

  • 静态CAIS在15位点冠部和根尖全局偏差分别为0.88±0.31 mm和1.45±0.37 mm,16位点分别为0.67±0.31 mm和1.07±0.32 mm。
  • 动态CAIS在15位点冠部和根尖全局偏差分别为0.97±0.32 mm和1.58±0.56 mm,16位点分别为0.79±0.29 mm和1±0.37 mm。
  • 静态CAIS的颊腭向偏差更高,动态CAIS的近远中向偏差更高。
  • 在15位点,静态CAIS的根尖和平台近远中向偏差低于动态CAIS;在16位点,动态CAIS的根尖颊腭向偏差低于静态CAIS。
  • 双向分析显示,磨牙位点静态CAIS的平台颊腭向偏差(P = 0.0028)和根尖近远中向偏差(P = 0.0056)显著更低;动态CAIS在16位点的根尖近远中向偏差显著更低(P = 0.0246)。

临床怎么用

  • 两种CAIS方法均可用于引导种植体植入,但需注意动态CAIS在体外环境中近中方向偏差更高,且种植位点会影响精度。

局限性

  • 原文未述局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: This in-vitro study compared the accuracy of implant placement using static versus dynamic computer-assisted implant surgery (CAIS) at two implant sites. METHODS: Partially edentulous maxillary models were 3D-printed, and two implants (Straumann TL RN 4.1 × 10 mm) were inserted in FDI positions 15 and 16 per model using two CAIS approaches (10 models per approach). A three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction tool was used for implant planning, surgical guide design, and measuring implant positioning accuracy. In static CAIS, the implants were placed with 3D-printed surgical guides (n = 20); in dynamic CAIS, real-time navigation was performed (n = 20). Primary outcomes were defined as coronal and apical global deviation as well as angular deviations and deviation comparison between implants placed at positions 15 and 16; the secondary outcome was the bi-directional deviation in mesial-distal, buccal-palatal, and apical-coronal direction. RESULTS: The mean coronal and apical global deviation for static CAIS for implant positions 15 were 0.88±0.31 mm and 1.45±0.37 mm, and for implant position 16 were 0.67±0.31 mm, and 1.07±0.32 mm, respectively. In dynamic CAIS, the mean coronal and apical global deviation for implant position 15 were 0.97±0.32 mm and 1.58±0.56 mm, and for implant position 16 were 0.79±0.29 mm and 1 ± 0.37 mm, respectively. Buccal-palatal deviation was higher using static CAIS, and mesial-distal deviation was higher in dynamic CAIS. In position 15, mesial-distal deviation at the apex and the platform were lower in static approaches than in dynamic ones. In implant position 16, buccal-palatal deviation at the apex was lower in the dynamic group than with static ones. For bi-directional analysis, buccal-palatal deviation at the platform (P = 0.0028) and mesial-distal deviation at the apex (P = 0.0056) were significantly lower in molar sites using static CAIS. Mesial-distal deviation at the apex (P = 0.0246) revealed significantly lower values in position 16 following dynamic CAIS. CONCLUSIONS: Both static and dynamic CAIS resulted in accurate implant placement. However, dynamic CAIS exhibited higher deviation in the mesial direction in an in-vitro setting. In addition, the implant site affects the accuracy of both CAIS approaches. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Both static and dynamic CAIS demonstrate high accuracy for guided implant placement..

来源:J Dent,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Taheri Otaghsara SS, Joda T, Thieringer FM, et al. Accuracy of dental implant placement using static versus dynamic computer-assisted implant surgery: An in vitro study. J Dent. 2023. PMID: 36948382. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2023.104487

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。