文献速递口腔正畸

两种CAD/CAM引导托槽粘接装置的对比:GBD-U与GBD-B

Comparison of bracket bonding between two CAD/CAM guided bonding devices: GBD-U vs GBD-B.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent · 2023-02-26

本研究在体外比较了单侧接触式(GBD-U)与双侧接触式(GBD-B)CAD/CAM引导托槽粘接装置的粘接精度、效率、可重复性及3D打印时长。结果显示GBD-U的3D打印和粘接时间更短,且在近远中维度、转矩、轴倾度和旋转的偏差显著更低,两种装置均具有临床可接受的精度。

要点

  • GBD-U的3D打印时间(41.96分钟)和粘接时间(6.38分钟)均短于GBD-B(78.04分钟/7.20分钟)。
  • 两种装置100%线性偏差和超过95%角度偏差分别低于0.5 mm或2°。
  • GBD-U在近远中维度、转矩、轴倾度和旋转的偏差显著低于GBD-B(P<0.01)。

核心结论

  • GBD-U在3D打印上更省时,两种装置精度均临床可接受,但GBD-U在近远中维度、转矩、轴倾度和旋转的粘接精度高于GBD-B。

研究设计与样本

  • 体外研究,使用5套树脂牙颌模型扫描并虚拟粘接托槽,设计并3D打印GBD-U和GBD-B,由5名正畸住院医师在牙科仿头模上使用两种装置粘接托槽,共粘接50套树脂模型(1000个托槽/颊管)。

主要发现

  • GBD-U的3D打印时间为41.96分钟,短于GBD-B的78.04分钟;粘接时间为6.38分钟,短于GBD-B的7.20分钟。
  • 两种装置中,100%的线性偏差和超过95%的角度偏差分别低于0.5 mm或2°。
  • GBD-U组在近远中维度、转矩、轴倾度和旋转的偏差显著低于GBD-B组(P<0.01)。
  • 两种装置均证实了操作者间的高可重复性。

关键数值与推荐

  • GBD-U的3D打印时间41.96分钟 vs GBD-B的78.04分钟(GBD-U更短)。
  • GBD-U的粘接时间6.38分钟 vs GBD-B的7.20分钟(GBD-U更短)。
  • 线性偏差低于0.5 mm的比例:两种装置均为100%。
  • 角度偏差低于2°的比例:两种装置均超过95%。
  • 近远中维度、转矩、轴倾度和旋转偏差:GBD-U组显著低于GBD-B组(P<0.01)。

临床怎么用

  • CAD/CAM GBD-U以省时的方式提供高托槽粘接精度,具有临床应用的潜力。

局限性

  • 原文未述局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To compare the bracket bonding accuracy, efficiency, reproducibility, and three-dimensional (3D) printing duration of the computer-aided design/computer-aided manufacturing (CAD/CAM) unilateral contact guided bonding device (GBD-U) and the bilateral contact guided bonding device (GBD-B) in vitro. METHODS: Five resin dental model sets were scanned and virtually bonded with brackets. GBD-U and GBD-B were designed and 3D printed for each model. GBD-Us had guide blocks that fit the occlusal sides of the bracket tie-wings, while GBD-Bs had guide arms that fit the occlusal and distal sides of the tie-wings. Five orthodontic residents were recruited to bond brackets on the same 3D-printed copies of resin models in a dental mannequin using GBD-Us and GBD-Bs, respectively. The time for 3D printing of GBDs and bracket bonding was recorded. The linear and angular deviations between the bonded brackets and the virtually bonded ones were measured. RESULTS: A total of 50 sets of resin models (1000 brackets/tubes) were bonded. The time for 3D printing and bracket bonding was shorter for GBD-Us (41.96 mins/6.38 mins) than for GBD-Bs (78.04 mins/7.20 mins). In both devices, 100% linear deviations and over 95% angular deviations were below 0.5 mm or 2°, respectively. Deviations in the mesiodistal dimension, torque, angulation, and rotation were significantly lower in the GBD-U group (P<0.01). High inter-operator reproducibility of bracket bonding was confirmed for both devices. CONCLUSION: GBD-U was more time-efficient in 3D printing. Both GBDs showed clinically acceptable accuracy, whereas GBD-U had higher bonding accuracy in the mesiodistal dimension, torque, angulation, and rotation than GBD-B. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: CAD/CAM GBD-U provides high bracket bonding accuracy in a time-efficient manner and has the potential to be clinically applied.

来源:J Dent,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Wang P, Li W, Li B, et al. Comparison of bracket bonding between two CAD/CAM guided bonding devices: GBD-U vs GBD-B. J Dent. 2023. PMID: 36849067. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2023.104456

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。