深螺纹种植体非手术清洁效果与钛颗粒释放的体外组织模型研究
本研究在猪软组织包绕水平骨缺损的塑料模型中,比较刮治器、超声洁治器和赤藓糖醇粉气流喷砂对两种螺纹深度种植体的清洁效率及钛颗粒残留。结果显示气流喷砂对两种种植体清洁率最高且钛残留最少,但所有器械均存在未清洁区域,非手术清创临床相关性仍具挑战。
要点
- 赤藓糖醇粉气流喷砂在两种种植体上清洁率最高且对表面改变最小。
- 刮治器和超声洁治器造成明显种植体表面改变并残留较多钛颗粒。
- 所有器械均存在未清洁区域,非手术清创效果受种植体设计影响。
核心结论
- 基于体外数据,赤藓糖醇粉气流喷砂仍是最有效且最温和的清洁方法。
- 所有三种器械均存在未清洁区域,具体取决于不同种植体设计,非手术清创的临床相关性仍具挑战性,需要进一步改进。
研究设计与样本
- 使用刮治器(CUR)、超声洁治器(US)和赤藓糖醇粉气流喷砂(APWJ)三种器械清洁150秒,随后拍照和扫描电镜观察,并定量溶解样本中的钛及组织学确认。
主要发现
- ATAP种植体清洁表面百分比:CUR为26.4±3.0%,US为33.7±3.8%,APWJ为45.5±4.1%;FTAP种植体:CUR为17.1±2.4%,US为28.1±2.3%,APWJ为24.7±3.8%。
- 扫描电镜显示种植体表面显著改变,尤其在CUR和US器械处理后,而APWJ几乎没有影响。
- ATAP种植体清洁后钛残留最多见于CUR(152.0±75.5),其次US(89.5±73.8)和APWJ(0.3±0.8);FTAP种植体CUR和US分别为129.5±58.6 μg和67.0±14.4 μg。
- APWJ清洁ATAP种植体未检测到钛残留。
临床怎么用
- 基于体外数据,赤藓糖醇粉气流喷砂在清洁效率和减少钛颗粒释放方面表现最佳。
- 刮治器和超声洁治器可能导致种植体表面改变和钛颗粒残留,临床选择非手术清创器械时需考虑种植体螺纹设计。
- 所有器械均存在未清洁区域,非手术清创方案仍需进一步改进。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To measure the efficiency of three cleaning modalities on two implant designs with similar diameters but different thread depths as well as the presence of titanium particles. METHODS: Sixty dyed implants (30 × 4.8 apically tapered (ATAP) and 30 × 5.0 fully tapered (FTAP)) were fixed in plastic models. The horizontal bone defects were surrounded with porcine soft tissue. Three instrumentation modalities were used to clean for 150 s: Curette (CUR), ultrasonic scaler (US), and air powder waterjet device (APWJ) with erythritol powder. Afterward, implants were photographed and scanning electron microscopic (SEM) images were taken. Titanium in the soft tissues was quantified in dissolved samples and histologically confirmed. RESULTS: For ATAP and FTAP implants, the percentage of the cleaned surface was 26.4 ± 3.0 and 17.1 ± 2.4% for CUR, 33.7 ± 3.8% and 28.1 ± 2.3% for US, and 45.5 ± 4.1% and 24.7 ± 3.8% for APWJ, respectively. SEM images showed significant implant surface changes, especially after instrumentation with CUR and US, whereas APWJ had little to no effect. Most titanium residues were found after cleaning ATAP implants with CUR (152.0 ± 75.5), followed by US (89.5 ± 73.8) and APWJ (0.3 ± 0.8). For the FTAP implants, respective values accounted for 129.5 ± 58.6 μg and 67.0 ± 14.4 μg for CUR and US, respectively. No titanium residues were detected on ATAP with APWJ. CONCLUSION: Based on in vitro data, erythritol-powered APWJ still appears to be the most efficient and gentle cleaning method. All three instruments, however, were found to have unprocessed areas depending on different implant designs, hence, clinical relevance for non-surgical approaches remains challenging and warrants further improvement.
引用
- Fischer KR, Büchel J, Gubler A, et al. Nonsurgical cleaning potential of deep-threaded implants and titanium particle release: A novel in vitro tissue model. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2023. PMID: 36757141. doi:10.1111/clr.14045
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。