牙周易感患者牙齿存留30年随访:临床结局与失牙风险因素
本研究回顾性纳入154例在1984至1986年间于私人诊所接受牙周治疗的患者,随访30年支持性牙周护理(SPC)。结果显示30年间总体失牙201颗(5.1%),其中牙周原因失牙39颗;III或IV期牙周炎较I或II期失牙风险更高(OR=2.10),广泛型牙周炎较局限型风险更高(OR=3.24)。
要点
- 30年SPC期间总体失牙率5.1%,牙周原因失牙仅39颗。
- III或IV期牙周炎患者SPC期间失牙风险是I或II期的2.10倍。
- 广泛型牙周炎患者失牙风险是局限型的3.24倍。
核心结论
- 牙周治疗联合严格SPC可有效保留中重度牙周炎患者大多数牙齿达30年。
- 年龄、性别、磨牙、探诊深度、骨丧失、根管治疗和牙冠是与失牙相关的预后因素。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究纳入154例牙周炎患者(4083颗牙),于1984至1986年间在私人诊所治疗。
- 患者接受非手术治疗后酌情行手术治疗、正畸治疗和牙齿夹板固定,SPC为每3至6个月严格复查,持续30年。
- 在基线(T0)、活动治疗结束(T1)、25年(T2)和30年(T3)时测量牙科和牙周变量,采用广义混合模型和生存分析评估失牙预后因素。
主要发现
- 活动治疗期间拔除160颗(3.9%)被认为无治疗价值的牙齿,再评估时(T1)拔除13颗(0.3%)。
- 25年SPC后,154例患者3910颗牙中失牙140颗(3.6%),其中18例患者24颗因牙周原因失牙。
- 25至30年间,20例患者(482颗牙)退出,失牙61颗(2%),其中14例患者15颗因牙周原因失牙。
- 30年SPC期间总体失牙201颗(5.1%),其中39颗因牙周原因失牙。
- 广义混合模型显示III或IV期牙周炎较I或II期失牙更多(OR=2.10;p=.048),广泛型牙周炎较局限型OR=3.24(p=.016)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: (i) To evaluate the efficacy of active periodontal therapy supplemented by supportive periodontal care (SPC) in retaining dentition during a 30-year follow-up period in patients susceptible to periodontitis, and (ii) to assess the prognostic factors associated with tooth loss. MATERIALS AND METHODS: One-hundred and fifty-four patients with periodontitis, retrospectively classified as stage I-IV and grade B-C periodontitis, treated between 1984 and 1986 in a private practice, were enrolled in this study. After periodontal assessment, patients received non-surgical treatment followed by surgical periodontal therapy, orthodontic treatment, and tooth-splinting, where appropriate. SPC consisted of a strict recall programme every 3-6 months over a 30-year period. Recurrences were treated either with subgingival root planing or flap surgery. Dental and periodontal variables were measured at baseline (T0), end of active therapy (T1), and after 25 (T2) and 30 (T3) years. Generalized mixed models were analysed to assess the prognostic factors associated with and survival analyses for tooth loss. RESULTS: Data on 154 patients (4083 teeth) were available at baseline (T0). Teeth considered unworthy of treatment were extracted during active therapy (160, 3.9%) and at re-assessment (13, 0.3%; T1). After 25 years of SPC, 140 teeth out of 3910 in 154 patients (3.6%) were lost (24 in 18 patients for periodontal reasons). Between 25 and 30 years, 20 patients (482 teeth) dropped out, and 61 teeth (2%) were lost (15 in 14 patients for periodontal reasons). Overall, 201 teeth (5.1%) were lost (39 for periodontal reasons) in 30 years of SPC. Generalized mixed models showed that stage III or stage IV periodontitis was associated with greater tooth loss during SPC compared to stage I or stage II (OR = 2.10; p = .048). Generalized periodontitis showed a statistically significant OR = 3.24 (p = .016) compared to the localized one. In SPC (T1-T3), age (p = .011), gender (male; p = .038), molar teeth (p = < .001), T0 and T1 pocket depth (p = < .001), tooth mobility grades 2 (p = .018) and 3 (p = .050), T0 and T1 bone loss (p = < .001), and presence of a root canal treatment (p = < .001) and a crown (p = .009) were statistically significantly associated with tooth loss. CONCLUSION: (i) Periodontal therapy and a stringent SPC are effective in maintaining most of the teeth in patients with moderate/advanced periodontitis for 30 years, and (ii) age, gender, molar teeth, pocket depth, bone loss, and the presence of a root canal treatment and a crown are prognostic factors associated with tooth loss.
引用
- Agudio G, Buti J, Bonaccini D, et al. Longevity of teeth in patients susceptible to periodontitis: Clinical outcomes and risk factors associated with tooth loss after active therapy and 30 years of supportive periodontal care. J Clin Periodontol. 2023. PMID: 36631984. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13770
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。