牙髓切除术与根管治疗在处理伴自发性疼痛的非创伤性牙髓炎中的有效性:系统评价与Meta分析
该系统评价与Meta分析比较牙髓切除术与根管治疗在伴自发性疼痛的恒牙牙髓炎中的效果,纳入2项随机临床试验。Meta分析显示术后第7天疼痛无差异(OR=0.99,95%CI 0.63-1.55,I²=0%),证据质量高;1年临床成功率均为98%,5年降至牙髓切除术78.1%、根管治疗75.3%。作者认为证据不足,需更多设计良好的试验。
要点
- 伴自发性疼痛的恒牙牙髓炎中,牙髓切除术与根管治疗术后第7天疼痛无显著差异(OR=0.99,95%CI 0.63-1.55)。
- 1年临床成功率两种治疗均为98%,5年时牙髓切除术为78.1%、根管治疗为75.3%。
- 仅纳入2项随机临床试验,证据不足以得出稳健结论,需更多设计良好的试验。
核心结论
- 本综述仅纳入2项试验,证据不足以得出稳健结论;现有临床数据提示牙髓切除术与根管治疗术后第7天疼痛无差异,一项随机对照试验提示两种治疗长期临床成功率相似。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与Meta分析,检索Web of Science、Scopus、PubMed和Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials,纳入比较根管治疗与牙髓切除术患者及临床报告结局的英文临床试验,采用固定效应模型进行Meta分析,并用GRADE方法评估证据质量。
- 共纳入2项随机临床试验,其中一项试验在不同时间点发表了4篇报告,涉及同一队列。
主要发现
- Meta分析显示根管治疗与牙髓切除术术后第7天疼痛无差异(OR=0.99,95%CI 0.63-1.55,I²=0%),证据质量评为「高」。
- 1年临床成功率两种干预均为98%,随时间下降至5年时牙髓切除术为78.1%、根管治疗为75.3%。
关键数值与推荐
- 术后第7天疼痛:根管治疗 vs 牙髓切除术 OR=0.99(95%CI 0.63-1.55,I²=0%),证据质量「高」。
- 1年临床成功率:牙髓切除术98%,根管治疗98%。
- 5年临床成功率:牙髓切除术78.1%,根管治疗75.3%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为牙髓切除术是一种确定性治疗方式,其有效性不劣于根管治疗,可能对这类患者的治疗产生显著影响,具有保留活髓和避免根管治疗的优点。
- 原文未据此给出具体推荐。
局限性
- 本综述仅能纳入2项试验,因此证据不足以得出稳健结论。
- 需要不同研究组开展更多设计良好的试验以建立更强的证据基础。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Pulpitis characterized by spontaneous pain can result in debilitating pain. Dogma has existed to offer only have two treatment options, namely root canal treatment (RCT) or extraction, although pulpotomy has always remained a potential treatment modality. OBJECTIVE: This review aimed to answer the following research question: 'Does pulpotomy (partial or full) (I) result in better patient and clinical reported outcomes (O), compared with RCT (C) in permanent teeth with pulpitis characterized by spontaneous pain (P) evaluated at various time intervals?' (T). METHODS: Two authors independently performed study selection, data extraction and risk of bias assessment. The literature search was conducted in the following electronic databases: Clarivate Analytics' Web of Science, Scopus, PubMed and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials. English language clinical trials comparing the patient and clinical reported outcomes between RCT and pulpotomy were included. The meta-analysis was performed on a fixed-effect model and the quality of evidence assessed by the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations (GRADE) approach. RESULTS: Two randomized clinical trials were included. Amongst two trials, one has published four reports at different time points involving the same cohorts. The meta-analysis revealed no difference in postoperative pain (Day 7) between RCT and pulpotomy (OR = 0.99, 95% CI 0.63-1.55, I2 = 0%) and quality of evidence was graded as 'High'. Clinical success was high at year 1, 98% for both interventions, however, decreased over time to 78.1% (pulpotomy) and 75.3% (RCT) at 5 years. DISCUSSION: Pulpotomy is a definitive treatment modality that is as effective as RCT. This could have a significant impact on treatment of such patients affording the advantages of retaining a vital pulp and preventing the need for RCT. CONCLUSION: This review could only include two trials, hence there is insufficient evidence to draw robust conclusions. The clinical data accumulated so far suggests no difference in pain between RCT and pulpotomy at Day 7 postoperatively and a single randomized control trial suggests that the clinical success rate for both treatment modalities is similar long term. There is a need for more well-designed trials by different research groups to develop a stronger evidence base in this area. REGISTRATION: PROSPERO database (CRD42021259744).
引用
- Tomson PL, Vilela Bastos J, Jacimovic J, et al. Effectiveness of pulpotomy compared with root canal treatment in managing non-traumatic pulpitis associated with spontaneous pain: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Int Endod J. 2022. PMID: 36209498. doi:10.1111/iej.13844
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。