单冠与三单位双层氧化锆基固定牙修复体的临床结局:一项最长6年回顾性临床研究
该回顾性临床研究评估了2015—2021年间由本科牙科学生在大学牙科中心制作的147件双层氧化锆基单冠和三单位固定牙修复体的生存率及技术、生物学并发症,并分析牙髓活力、基牙位置和粘接水门汀类型对临床结局的影响。结果显示三单位固定牙修复体5.5年累积生存率96%,单冠4.8年累积生存率90%,两者5年成功率均为68%;活髓牙临床结局优于死髓牙,粘接水门汀类型影响最终临床结局。
要点
- 三单位氧化锆基固定牙修复体5.5年累积生存率96%,单冠4.8年累积生存率90%。
- 单冠与三单位固定牙修复体的5年估计成功率均为68%。
- 活髓牙与死髓牙之间临床结局差异有统计学意义(p = .006),粘接水门汀类型间差异有统计学意义(p = .028)。
核心结论
- 本研究中单冠和三单位氧化锆基固定牙修复体的估计累积生存率与系统综述报告的范围一致。
- 活髓牙上的氧化锆基修复体临床结局优于死髓牙上的修复体,粘接水门汀类型影响最终临床结局。
- 使用本研究所用特定CAD-CAM系统在受控环境中制作的氧化锆单冠和三单位固定牙修复体临床性能良好,饰面瓷崩瓷极少。
- 与活髓牙相比,根管治疗后的牙齿似乎具有更高的氧化锆修复体失败风险。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性临床研究,共纳入94例患者的147件修复体,包括单冠77件和三单位固定牙修复体70件。
- 修复体由本科牙科学生在大学牙科中心于2015—2021年期间制作。
- 单冠平均随访37个月(范围6—63个月),三单位固定牙修复体平均随访25个月(范围6—68个月)。
- 采用改良美国公共卫生署(USPHS)标准和加利福尼亚牙科协会(CDA)标准进行临床检查,采用Kaplan-Meier法估计累积生存率和成功率(α=0.05),采用交叉表和χ²检验分析牙髓活力、粘接水门汀和位置对临床结局的差异(α=0.05)。
主要发现
- Kaplan-Meier累积生存率:三单位氧化锆基固定牙修复体5.5年后为96%,单冠4.8年后为90%。
- 三单位固定牙修复体和单冠的5年估计成功率均为68%。
- 单冠记录失败7件(9.1%,7/77),三单位固定牙修复体记录失败2件(2.9%,2/70);咬合面粗糙是最常见的并发症(单冠4件[5.6%],三单位固定牙修复体8件[11.4%])。
- 全部纳入的活髓牙与死髓牙之间临床结局差异有统计学意义(p = .006),粘接水门汀类型之间差异有统计学意义(p = .028)。
- 单独分析单冠时,牙髓活力对临床结局的影响有统计学意义(p = .036),三单位固定牙修复体则无;修复体位置对两种修复体单独或合并分析的临床结局均无显著差异(p > .05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 单冠(n = 77)平均随访37个月(范围6—63个月),三单位固定牙修复体(n = 70)平均随访25个月(范围6—68个月)。
- 三单位氧化锆基固定牙修复体5.5年累积生存率96%,单冠4.8年累积生存率90%。
- 单冠和三单位固定牙修复体的5年估计成功率均为68%。
- 活髓牙与死髓牙全部纳入分析时临床结局差异有统计学意义(p = .006),粘接水门汀类型间差异有统计学意义(p = .028)。
- 单冠中牙髓活力对临床结局的影响有统计学意义(p = .036);修复体位置对临床结局无显著差异(p > .05)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
- 作者指出,活髓牙上的氧化锆基修复体临床结局优于死髓牙上的修复体,粘接水门汀类型影响最终临床结局。
- 作者指出,根管治疗后的牙齿似乎具有更高的氧化锆修复体失败风险。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this retrospective clinical study was to evaluate the survival and the occurrence of technical and biological complications in bi-layered zirconia-based (Zi) single crown and 3-unit fixed dental prostheses (FDPs). Also, the study aimed to analyze the effects of tooth vitality (vital versus non-vital), abutment location (anterior versus posterior), and luting cement (self-adhesive resin versus resin-reinforced glass ionomer) on clinical outcomes. METHODS: A total of 147 prostheses (in 94 patients) placed by undergraduate dental students in a university dental center during the period 2015-2021 were examined clinically using modified United States Public Health Service (USPHS) and California Dental Association (CDA) criteria. The mean duration of follow-up was 37 months (range, 6 - 63 months) for the single crowns (n = 77) and 25 months (range, 6 - 68 months) for the 3-unit FDPs (n = 70). Data were descriptively analyzed to determine the types and rates of complications based on USPHS and CDA criteria. The Kaplan-Meier survival estimation method was used to determine the cumulative survival and success rates of the prostheses (α=0.05). Differences in clinical outcomes (survival or failure) according to tooth vitality, luting cement, and location were statistically analyzed using cross-tabulations and Х2 test (α=0.05). RESULTS: The Kaplan-Meier cumulative survival rate was estimated as 96% for the Zi 3-unit FDPs after 5.5 years, and 90% for the Zi single crowns after 4.8 years. The 5-year estimated success rate was 68% for both 3-unit FDPs and single crowns. Seven (9.1%) 77Zi single crowns and 70 2 (2.9%) Zi 3-unit FDPs were recorded as failures with occlusal roughness being the most commonly-observed complication (crowns: 4 [5.6%]; 3-unit FDPs: 8 [11.4%]). In terms of clinical outcomes, statistically significant differences were found between all included vital and non-vital teeth (p = .006), and cement types (p = .028). Taking single crowns alone, significant differences in clinical outcomes according to tooth vitality were noted (p = .036), but not for PFDPs. The location of the prostheses did not produce any significant differences in the clinical outcomes, for both prostheses types independently or combined (p > .05). CONCLUSIONS: The estimated cumulative survival rates in this study for single crowns and 3-unit Zi FDPs concurred with the ranges reported in systematic reviews. Zi-based prostheses on vital teeth produced better clinical outcomes than those placed on non-vital teeth, and type of luting cement influenced the final clinical outcome. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Zi crowns and 3-unit PFDPs fabricated using the specific CAD-CAM system used in the controlled environment of this study showed good clinical performance with minimal veneer porcelain chipping. Root canal treated teeth seem to be at higher risk for failure of Zi prostheses compared with vital teeth.
引用
- Alfadhli R, Alshammari Y, Baig MR, et al. Clinical outcomes of single crown and 3-unit bi-layered zirconia-based fixed dental prostheses: An upto 6- year retrospective clinical study: Clinical outcomes of zirconia FDPs. J Dent. 2022. PMID: 36220517. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2022.104321
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。