阳极氧化与喷砂种植体表面在急性开裂型缺损动物模型中的基准性能比较
本项对照临床前研究在小型猪颊侧急性开裂型缺损模型中,比较三种种植体的组织学与组织形态计量学表现,观察期分别为愈合2周和8周。结果显示,愈合8周时对照组(2)和(3)的新生嵴顶骨量(BATA)及相关骨结合参数显著高于试验组(1);愈合2周时骨结合(nBIC)受种植体几何形态影响,组(3)优于组(1)和组(2)。作者认为嵴顶骨形成程度主要受表面特征及其促进骨结合与直接骨沉积能力的影响。
要点
- 愈合8周时,对照组(2)和(3)的新生嵴顶骨量(BATA)显著高于试验组(1)。
- 愈合8周时,与骨结合和直接骨沉积相关的dBIC、VBC、fBIC在对照组(2)和(3)中表现更优。
- 愈合2周时nBIC受种植体几何形态影响,组(3)优于组(1)和组(2);愈合8周时组(2)和(3)的nBIC显著高于组(1)。
核心结论
- 在急性开裂型缺损中,新生嵴顶骨形成程度(BATA)主要受种植体表面特征及其促进骨结合和直接骨沉积能力的影响。
- 根尖部分的骨结合(nBIC)受表面特征与种植体几何形态共同影响。
- 作者认为在早期愈合阶段,种植体几何形态相对于特定表面特征可能对促进骨结合有更明显的作用。
研究设计与样本
- 本项对照临床前研究采用小型猪颊侧标准化急性开裂型缺损模型,观察期为愈合2周和8周。
- 采用组织学与组织形态计量学分析,比较三组种植体:(1)新型商用梯度阳极氧化种植体;(2)种植体「1」的定制几何复制体,表面为超亲水微粗糙大颗粒喷砂酸蚀;(3)商用种植体,表面同「2」但几何形态不同。
主要发现
- 愈合8周时,对照组(2)和(3)的新生嵴顶骨量(BATA)显著高于试验组(1)。
- 与骨结合和直接骨沉积相关的参数(dBIC、VBC、fBIC)在对照组(2)和(3)中结果相似,均显示中等粗糙表面优于梯度阳极氧化功能化表面。
- 愈合2周时,骨结合(nBIC)受种植体几何形态影响,组(3)在该参数上优于组(1)和组(2)。
- 愈合8周时,组(2)和(3)的nBIC显著高于组(1)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Crestal bone formation represents a crucial aspect of the esthetic and biological success of dental implants. This controlled preclinical study analyzed the effect of implant surface and implant geometry on de novo crestal bone formation and osseointegration. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Histological and histomorphometrical analysis was performed to compare three implant groups, that is, (1) a novel, commercially available, gradient anodized implant, (2) a custom-made geometric replica of implant "1," displaying a superhydrophilic micro-rough large-grit sandblasted and acid-etched surface, and (3) a commercially available implant, having the same surface as "2" but a different implant geometry. The study applied a standardized buccal acute-type dehiscence model in minipigs with observation periods of 2 and 8 weeks of healing. RESULTS: The amount of newly formed crestal bone (BATA) around control groups (2) and (3) was significantly increased when compared to the test group (1) at the 8 weeks of healing time point. Similar results were obtained for all parameters related to osseointegration and direct bone apposition, to the implant surface (dBIC, VBC, and fBIC), demonstrating superior osseointegration of the moderately rough, compared to the gradient anodized functionalization. After 2 weeks, the osseointegration (nBIC) was found to be influenced by implant geometry with group (3) outperforming groups (1) and (2) on this parameter. At 8 weeks, nBIC was significantly higher for groups (2) and (3) compared to (1). CONCLUSIONS: The extent (BATA) of de novo crestal bone formation in the acute-type dehiscence defects was primarily influenced by implant surface characteristics and their ability to promote osseointegration and direct bone apposition. Osseointegration (nBIC) of the apical part was found to be influenced by a combination of surface characteristics and implant geometry. For early healing, implant geometry may have a more pronounced effect on facilitating osseointegration, relative to the specific surface characteristics.
引用
- Shahdad S, Bosshardt D, Patel M, et al. Benchmark performance of anodized vs. sandblasted implant surfaces in an acute dehiscence type defect animal model. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2022. PMID: 36120735. doi:10.1111/clr.13996
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。