峡部形态影响活化冲洗的清创效果:一项涉及模拟生物膜水凝胶去除与高速成像的实验室研究
本研究用CAD-CAM制作四种峡部形态的根管模型(长宽、长窄、短宽、短窄),以含牙本质碎屑的水凝胶模拟生物膜,比较激光活化冲洗(LAI)、EDDY和针头冲洗(NI)的清除效果,并用高速成像分析LAI与EDDY的清洁机制。结果显示峡部形态影响所有冲洗组的清创效果,短宽峡部最易清洁、窄峡部最难,宽度似比长度更关键;LAI和EDDY在各形态下均优于NI。
要点
- 峡部形态影响所有冲洗组的清创效果,短宽峡部最易清洁,窄峡部最难清洁。
- LAI和EDDY在每种峡部形态下去除的水凝胶均多于NI(p < .001)。
- EDDY在峡部产生涡流和稳定空化,LAI每个脉冲产生瞬态空化和脉冲水平流。
核心结论
- 峡部形态影响所有冲洗组的清创效果,短宽峡部最易清洁而窄峡部最难清洁,宽度似乎是比长度更关键的解剖参数。
- LAI和EDDY去除生物膜最多,效果优于NI;EDDY在峡部产生涡流和稳定空化,LAI表现为瞬态空化和脉冲水平流。
研究设计与样本
- 实验室研究:用CAD-CAM制作4种峡部形态的根管模型(根尖直径0.30 mm、锥度0.06、弯曲度23°、长度20 mm),峡部内填充含牙本质碎屑的水凝胶。
- 模型随机分为NI(30G针头)、EDDY和LAI(2940 nm Er:YAG激光,15 Hz,40 mJ,SWEEPS,工作尖位于根管口)三组,n = 240。
- 冲洗前后拍摄峡部标准化图像,用图像分析软件测定水凝胶去除量,组间比较采用Kruskal-Wallis检验后行Dunn多重比较;并用高速相机可视化活化过程中的峡部流场。
主要发现
- LAI、EDDY和NI在短宽峡部去除的水凝胶均多于窄峡部(p < .001)。
- LAI和EDDY在每种峡部形态下去除的水凝胶均多于NI(p < .001)。
- EDDY在峡部显示涡流和稳定空化;LAI每个脉冲显示瞬态空化,并在闭合短峡部中显示颗粒速度最高的脉冲水平流。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: Little is known about the influence of isthmus morphology on the debridement efficacy of activated irrigation. The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of isthmus morphology on the debridement efficacy of laser-activated irrigation (LAI), EDDY and needle irrigation (NI), and to explain the methods of isthmus cleaning by LAI and EDDY. METHODOLOGY: Four root canal models (apical diameter: 0.30 mm, taper: 0.06, curvature: 23°, length: 20 mm) were produced by CAD-CAM with different isthmus morphologies: long-wide (4 mm; 0.4 mm), long-narrow (4 mm; 0.15 mm), short-wide (2 mm; 0.4 mm) and short-narrow (2 mm; 0.15 mm). The isthmuses were filled with a hydrogel containing dentine debris. The canals were filled with irrigant and models were assigned to the following irrigation protocols (n = 240): needle irrigation (NI) with a 30G needle, Eddy, and LAI (2940 nm Er:YAG-laser, 15 Hz, 40 mJ, SWEEPS, tip at the canal entrance). Standardized images of the isthmuses were taken before and after irrigation, and the amount of removed hydrogel was determined using image analysis software and compared across groups using Kruskal-Wallis test followed by Dunn's multiple comparison. Visualization of the isthmus during activation was achieved using a high-speed camera. The pattern and speed of the flow in the isthmus as well as transient and stable cavitation were analysed using imaging software. RESULTS: Laser-activated irrigation, EDDY and NI removed more hydrogel in short-wide isthmuses than in narrow isthmuses (p < .001). LAI and EDDY removed more hydrogel than NI in every isthmus configuration (p < .001). EDDY showed eddies and stable cavitation, and LAI showed transient cavitation at each pulse, and pulsed horizontal flow with the highest particle speed in closed short isthmuses. CONCLUSIONS: Isthmus morphology influences debridement in all irrigation groups. Short-wide isthmuses were the easiest to clean while narrow isthmuses were the most challenging to clean. Width seems to be a more critical anatomical parameter than length. LAI and EDDY resulted in the greatest biofilm removal and performed better than NI. EDDY produced eddies and stable cavitation in the isthmus, and LAI showed transient cavitation and pulsed horizontal flow.
引用
- Robberecht L, Delattre J, Meire M, et al. Isthmus morphology influences debridement efficacy of activated irrigation: A laboratory study involving biofilm mimicking hydrogel removal and high-speed imaging. Int Endod J. 2022. PMID: 36148855. doi:10.1111/iej.13836
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。