经验丰富从业者完成牙髓治疗与种植治疗两年后患者的生活质量与满意度
本研究纳入同一批既接受过牙髓专科医生根管治疗、又接受过口腔外科医生种植治疗且从业均超过15年的患者,在治疗后两年比较口腔健康相关生活质量与满意度。两种治疗的总口腔健康影响程度量表(OHIP)评分均较低,除生理疼痛维度根管治疗显著高于种植治疗(P=0.044)外,其余维度及总分无显著差异;患者对两种治疗均满意,但回忆治疗中疼痛根管治疗显著更差(P=0.003)。
要点
- 根管治疗与种植治疗两年后OHIP总分分别为8.82和7.87,均处于较低水平。
- 生理疼痛维度根管治疗显著高于种植治疗(P=0.044),其余维度及总分无显著差异。
- 患者对两种治疗均满意,但回忆治疗中疼痛根管治疗显著更差(P=0.003)。
核心结论
- 由经验丰富从业者完成的种植治疗或根管治疗均可获得较高的长期口腔健康相关生活质量和满意度,但根管治疗的生理疼痛维度更高。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入研究前两年分别由从业超过15年的牙髓专科医生和口腔外科医生完成根管治疗与种植治疗的患者,以临床和影像学数据核实两种治疗的存活和满意结局,参与者填写两份自建问卷(每种治疗一份)。
- 口腔健康相关生活质量评估包含24个条目(OHIP-14加上原OHIP-49问卷中其他10个相关条目),治疗时长、费用和疼痛(治疗中及治疗后)满意度采用0-10分量表评估,感知采用正误题评估。
- 计算种植治疗与根管治疗各维度加权和、OHIP总分、影响患病率和总体满意度,采用相关样本Wilcoxon检验比较,患者感知采用卡方检验比较。
主要发现
- 根管治疗与种植治疗的OHIP总分分别为8.82和7.87,均较低。
- 除生理疼痛维度根管治疗显著高于种植治疗(P=0.044)外,OHIP总分及任何其他维度均未检出显著差异。
- 所有患者对两种治疗均满意,但患者回忆治疗中疼痛根管治疗显著差于种植治疗(P=0.003)。
临床怎么用
- 作者指出,若治疗提供功能平衡并由经验丰富的从业者实施,种植治疗和根管治疗均可获得较高的长期生活质量和满意度。
- 所有参与者均接受了两种治疗模式并作为自身对照,消除了个体变异性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To compare oral health related quality of life (OHRQoL) and patients´ satisfaction with root canal treatment (RCT) and dental implant (DI) therapy performed by experienced practitioners. METHODS: Patients with both an RCT and a DI performed respectively by an endodontist and an oral surgeon with more than 15 years of experience two years prior to the study were included. The survival and satisfactory outcome of both treatments were verified with clinical and radiographic data. Participants completed two constructed questionnaire (one for each treatment). OHRQoL assessment included 24 items (OHIP-14 plus other relevant 10 items from the original OHIP-49 questionnaire). Satisfaction regarding duration, cost and pain (both during and after treatment) of treatment was assessed with a 0-10 scale and perceptions with true/false questions. Weighted sums for each dimension, total OHIP scores, prevalence of impact and general satisfaction of patients were then calculated for DI and RCT and compared using the Wilcoxon test for related samples. Patients´ perceptions were compared with Chi-square test. RESULTS: Total OHIP scores were low for both treatments (8.82 and 7.87, respectively for RCT and DI). No significant differences were detected in OHIP total score or any dimension, except for physical pain (significantly higher for RCT than DI (p=0.044)). All patients were satisfied with both treatments; however, patients recalled that pain during treatment was significantly worse for RCT than DI (p=0.003). CONCLUSIONS: High long-term OHRQoL and satisfaction is expected with either DI or RCT performed by experienced practitioners; however, physical pain dimension is higher for RCT. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: This study demonstrated a high satisfaction and long-term quality of life of patients undergoing both DI and RCT if treatments provide a functional balance and are performed by experienced practitioners. Very importantly, all participants had received both treatment modalities and being their own control eliminates individual variability.
引用
- Sanz E, Azabal M, Arias A, et al. Quality of life and satisfaction of patients two years after endodontic and dental implant treatments performed by experienced practitioners. J Dent. 2022. PMID: 36075535. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2022.104280
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。