辅助治疗对根尖周炎治疗有效性的系统评价与Meta分析
本系统评价由欧洲牙髓病学会预先设定框架,检索5个数据库至2021年10月,纳入14项研究(13项随机对照试验和1项回顾性队列),评估多种根管辅助治疗对根尖周炎愈合及术后疼痛的效果;Meta分析仅对超声活化冲洗和部分激光辅助治疗可行,显示12个月愈合及7天疼痛与对照无显著差异,证据强度低至极低,结论为证据不足以推荐任何辅助治疗。
要点
- 共纳入14项研究(13项随机对照试验和1项回顾性队列),评估6类根管辅助治疗。
- 超声活化冲洗12个月愈合与对照无显著差异,证据强度低。
- 光动力疗法和二极管激光7天疼痛与对照无显著差异,证据强度低至极低。
核心结论
- 证据不足以推荐任何辅助治疗用于根尖周炎的治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与Meta分析,由欧洲牙髓病学会预先设定人群、干预、对照、结局、时间和研究设计框架。
- 检索PubMed、Embase、Scopus、Cochrane和Web of Science共5个电子数据库,检索截止至2021年10月,纳入比较辅助治疗与无辅助治疗的临床研究。
- 纳入14项研究(13项随机对照试验和1项回顾性队列),每臂少于10例患者及随访不足1年(术后疼痛不足7天)的研究被排除。
- 采用RoB2评估随机对照试验偏倚风险,Newcastle-Ottawa量表评估观察性研究质量,随机效应模型进行Meta分析,GRADE方法评估证据确定性。
主要发现
- 纳入研究评估的辅助治疗包括:抗菌光动力疗法(3项)、二极管激光根管照射(3项)、Nd:YAG激光根管照射(2项)、Er;Cr:YSGG激光根管照射(1项)、臭氧治疗(2项)和超声活化冲洗(4项)。
- 7项研究报告影像学愈合,仅超声活化冲洗(2项研究)可行Meta分析,显示12个月后愈合与对照无统计学显著差异。
- 7项研究报告7天疼痛,使用抗菌光动力疗法的3项研究和使用二极管激光照射的2项研究的Meta分析显示,7天疼痛发生率在对照与辅助治疗间无显著差异。
- 根据RoB2工具,6项研究高偏倚风险,5项研究存在一些担忧,2项研究低偏倚风险。
- GRADE评估显示二极管激光证据强度极低,光动力疗法、臭氧和超声活化冲洗研究证据强度低。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论为证据不足以推荐任何辅助治疗用于根尖周炎治疗,未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 纳入研究在辅助治疗类型、每种辅助治疗的技术细节、结局报告及其多种组合方面存在显著异质性,限制了Meta分析的可行性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Adjunct therapy refers to any intracanal procedure going beyond chemomechanical preparation with instruments and traditionally delivered irrigants (excluding interim dressings). It is not clear whether and which of these adjunct therapies have a significant impact on the outcome of root canal treatment [healing of apical periodontitis (AP) and other patient-related outcomes]. OBJECTIVES: This systematic review aimed to analyse available evidence on the effectiveness of adjunct therapy for the treatment of AP in permanent teeth, according to a population, intervention, comparison, outcome, time and study design framework formulated a priori by the European Society of Endodontology. METHODS: Five electronic databases (PubMed, Embase, Scopus, Cochrane and Web of Science) were searched up to October 2021 to identify clinical studies comparing adjunct therapy to no adjunct therapy in adult patients with AP. Animal studies, reviews, studies with less than 10 patients per arm and studies with a follow-up time of less than 1 year, or less than 7 days for postoperative pain, were excluded. The quality of the included studies was appraised by the appropriate tools [Risk of Bias 2 (RoB2) for randomized clinical trials (RCTs) and Newcastle-Ottawa Scale for observational studies]. Meta-analysis was performed using a random-effects model. The certainty of the evidence was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) approach. RESULTS: Fourteen studies (13 RCTs and one retrospective cohort) fulfilled the inclusion criteria for this review. They evaluated different types of adjunct therapy: antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (aPDT; three studies), diode laser canal irradiation (3), Nd:YAG laser canal irradiation (2), Er;Cr:YSGG laser canal irradiation (1), ozone therapy (2) and ultrasonically activated irrigation (UAI) (4). Radiographical healing was reported in seven studies, but meta-analysis was only possible for UAI (two studies), showing no statistically significant difference in healing after 12 months. Pain after 7 days was reported in seven studies. Meta-analysis on three studies that used aPDT and on two studies using diode laser irradiation showed no significant difference in the prevalence of pain after 7 days between the control and adjunct therapy. According to RoB2 tool, six studies had a high risk of bias, five studies had some concerns, and two studies low risk of bias. The GRADE assessment revealed a very low strength of evidence for diode laser, and low strength of evidence for PDT, ozone and UAI studies. DISCUSSION: The included studies displayed significant heterogeneity in terms of type of adjunct therapy, technical details per adjunct therapy, outcome reporting and several combinations of these, limiting the potential for meta-analysis. CONCLUSIONS: There is insufficient evidence to recommend any adjunctive therapy for the treatment of apical periodontitis. REGISTRATION: Prospero CRD42021261869.
引用
- Meire MA, Bronzato JD, Bomfim RA, et al. Effectiveness of adjunct therapy for the treatment of apical periodontitis: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Int Endod J. 2022. PMID: 36156804. doi:10.1111/iej.13838
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。