非手术根管治疗系统评价的结局报告:制定核心结局集的范围综述
该范围综述检索1990年1月至2020年12月发表的英文系统评价,纳入75篇(其中40篇含Meta分析),分析非手术根管治疗所报告的结局、测量工具与随访时长,并评估选择性报告偏倚风险。多数评价报告生理与临床结局,尤其是疼痛和/或根尖周影像学评估,测量工具与随访差异大;不足40%的评价评估了选择性报告风险。
要点
- 纳入75篇系统评价(40篇含Meta分析),多数报告疼痛和/或根尖周影像学评估等生理与临床结局。
- 各结局的测量工具、量表、阈值和随访时长差异很大,跨研究比较困难。
- 不足40%的评价评估了选择性报告风险,选择性偏倚不能排除。
核心结论
- 多数研究报告生理与临床结局,尤其是疼痛和/或影像学愈合。
- 各结局的测量工具、量表、阈值和随访时长差异很大,使跨研究比较复杂。
- 不足40%的评价评估了选择性报告风险,因此不能排除选择性偏倚。
- 所报告结局、测量工具和量表及随访时长的信息可指导未来研究规划并为制定非手术根管治疗核心结局集提供参考。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,检索1990年1月至2020年12月发表的英文非手术根管治疗系统评价,由两名评价者进行研究选择和数据提取。
主要发现
- 共纳入75篇系统评价,其中40篇包含Meta分析。
- 多数评价报告生理与临床结局,主要是疼痛和/或根尖周状况的影像学评估,并使用了多种测量工具和量表。
- 较少评价关注牙齿存活、生活影响、资源使用和不良事件。
- 所有参数上各评价间的异质性均很大。
- 不足40%的评价评估了选择性报告风险。
关键数值与推荐
- 结局按医疗保健分类法分为五个核心领域:存活、临床/生理变化、生活影响、资源使用和不良事件。
- 记录了结局测量工具和随访时长。
- 不足40%的评价评估了选择性报告风险。
临床怎么用
- 所报告结局、测量工具和量表及随访时长的信息可能指导未来研究规划并为制定非手术根管治疗核心结局集提供参考。
局限性
- 所纳入评价的总体目标高度异质,因此结局及其测量方式也差异很大。
- 以患者为中心的结局和资源使用很少被报告。
- 各结局的测量工具、量表、阈值和随访时长差异很大,使跨研究比较复杂。
- 不足40%的评价评估了选择性报告风险,因此不能排除选择性偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Studies related to non-surgical root canal treatment are amongst the most frequently performed clinical studies in endodontics. However, heterogeneity in reporting outcomes and lack of standardization is a significant challenge to evidence synthesis and guideline development. OBJECTIVES: The aims of the present scoping review were to (a) identify outcomes reported in systematic reviews evaluating non-surgical root canal treatment; (b) identify how and when the reported outcomes were measured; (c) assess possible selective reporting bias in the included studies. The information obtained in this study should inform the development of a core outcome set (COS) for non-surgical root canal treatment. METHODOLOGY: Structured literature searches were performed to identify systematic reviews on non-surgical root canal treatments published in English between January 1990 and December 2020. Two reviewers undertook study selection and data extraction. Outcomes were categorized according to a healthcare taxonomy into five core areas (survival, clinical/physiological changes, life impact, resource use, and adverse events). The outcome measurement tools and length of follow-up were recorded. RESULTS: Seventy-five systematic reviews were included, of which 40 included meta-analyses. Most reviews reported on physiological and clinical outcomes, primarily pain and/or radiographic assessment of periapical status, and a variety of measurement tools and scales were used. Few reviews focused on tooth survival, life impact, resources, and adverse events. The heterogeneity amongst the reviews was large on all parameters. Less than 40% of the reviews assessed the risk of selective reporting. DISCUSSION: Overall aims of the included reviews were highly heterogenic; thus, outcomes and how they were measured also varied considerably. Patient-centred outcomes and the use of resources were rarely reported on. CONCLUSIONS: Most studies reported on physiological and clinical outcomes, in particular pain and/or radiographic healing. Measurement tools, scales, thresholds, and follow-up periods varied greatly within each outcome, making comparison across studies complicated. Less than 40% of the reviews assessed risk of selective reporting; thus, selective bias could not be ruled out. The presented information on reported outcomes, measurement tools and scales, and length of follow-up may guide the planning of future research and inform the development of a COS for non-surgical root canal treatment.
引用
- Kirkevang LL, El Karim IA, Duncan HF, et al. Outcomes reporting in systematic reviews on non-surgical root canal treatment: A scoping review for the development of a core outcome set. Int Endod J. 2022. PMID: 35969087. doi:10.1111/iej.13812
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。