文献速递牙体牙髓病

通过三种复杂度分级系统评估二级医疗机构中用于培训的根管治疗病例复杂度:一项服务评估

Case complexity of root canal treatments accepted for training in a secondary care setting assessed by three complexity grading systems: A service evaluation.
PubMed 文献 · Int Endod J · 2022-08-26

该服务评估使用美国牙髓病医师协会病例复杂度表、修复治疗需求指数和英国修复牙科委托标准三种分级系统,对卡迪夫大学牙科医院研究生培训等级接诊的200份根管治疗病例记录进行评分,比较各系统评分频率。结果显示多数病例被评为最高复杂度3级(AAE 99.5%、RIOTN 65.5%、ECS 55.5%),差异主要归因于牙髓治疗史、根管再治疗和根管充填质量三个因素。

要点

  • 三种分级系统对同一批病例的复杂度评分分布差异明显,3级占比从55.5%到99.5%不等。
  • 牙髓治疗史是AAE与RIOTN、ECS评分差异的主要因素,分别占78%和64%。
  • 根管再治疗是RIOTN较ECS判定复杂度增加的最常见原因,占74%。

核心结论

  • 在服务评估的局限范围内,使用ECS、AAE和RIOTN三种指南评估时,卡迪夫大学牙科医院培训等级治疗的病例中高比例属于高复杂度3级。
  • 这些病例适合在不同监督级别下进行研究生培训,并得到本报告结果的支持。

研究设计与样本

  • 服务评估,使用AAE、RIOTN和ECS三种评分系统对200份病例记录进行评估。
  • 每个病例获得从最小到高复杂度的评分(1-3级),检查者经过校准,检查者间信度采用一致率计算。

主要发现

  • 大多数病例为3级,评分因所用标准而异:AAE为99.5%,RIOTN为65.5%,ECS为55.5%。
  • AAE的「牙髓治疗史」因素是与RIOTN(78%)和ECS(64%)评分差异的主要原因。
  • RIOTN中关于治疗后疾病的「根管再治疗」因素在大多数病例(74%)中是较ECS复杂度增加的原因。
  • ECS的「根管充填质量」因素是与RIOTN相比复杂度增加的最常见原因(85%)。

关键数值与推荐

  • AAE评分3级占比99.5%,RIOTN评分3级占比65.5%,ECS评分3级占比55.5%。
  • AAE「牙髓治疗史」因素导致与RIOTN差异占78%,与ECS差异占64%。
  • RIOTN「根管再治疗」因素导致较ECS复杂度增加占74%。
  • ECS「根管充填质量」因素导致较RIOTN复杂度增加占85%。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文述及「within the limitations of this service evaluation」,未进一步具体说明局限性内容。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIMS: To evaluate the complexity of root canal treatments accepted for treatment by postgraduate training grades at Cardiff University Dental Hospital (CUDH) using the English Commissioning Standard for Restorative Dentistry (ECS) in comparison with the American Association of Endodontists case complexity form (AAE) and the Restorative Index of Treatment Need (RIOTN). METHODOLOGY: Two hundred case records were evaluated using the AAE, RIOTN and ECS scoring systems. Each case received a score from minimal to high complexity (1-3). Examiners were calibrated and inter-examiner reliability calculated using the percentage agreement. Frequency of scores were then compared. RESULTS: Most cases were at level 3 and assessment varied amongst the criteria used (AAE: 99.5%, RIOTN: 65.5% and ECS: 55.5%). The AAE factor 'endodontic treatment history' was largely responsible for differing scores when compared with the RIOTN (78%) and ECS (64%). The RIOTN factor regarding post treatment disease ('endodontic retreatment') was responsible for increased complexity compared with ECS in most cases (74%). The ECS factor 'quality of root filling' was the most common reason (85%) for an increase in complexity compared with RIOTN. CONCLUSIONS: Within the limitations of this service evaluation, it was possible to conclude that a high proportion of cases treated by training grades at CUDH were of a high complexity level (level 3) using the three guidelines (ECS, AAE and RIOTN). These cases were appropriate for postgraduate training under various levels of supervision and substantiated by the findings reported here. The factors responsible for a large part of difference in allocation of scores amongst the systems were 'endodontic treatment history', 'root canal retreatment' and 'quality of root filling'.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Long R, Dutta A, Thomas MBM, et al. Case complexity of root canal treatments accepted for training in a secondary care setting assessed by three complexity grading systems: A service evaluation. Int Endod J. 2022. PMID: 35976108. doi:10.1111/iej.13815

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。