大蒜、氢氧化钙及其联合用作感染成熟前牙根管内封药抗菌效果的比较评价:一项随机临床试验
这项前瞻性双盲、对照、平行、优效性随机临床试验在66名男性患者的66颗坏死恒切牙(伴无症状根尖周炎)中,用实时PCR比较大蒜提取物、氢氧化钙及两者联合作为根管内封药的抗菌效果。结果显示,大蒜对粪肠球菌的降低效果优于氢氧化钙及其联合,对链球菌属的抗菌效力与氢氧化钙相当,而两者联合的抗菌效果反而降低。
要点
- 大蒜对粪肠球菌的抗菌效果优于氢氧化钙及两者联合。
- 大蒜对链球菌属的抗菌效力与氢氧化钙相当。
- 氢氧化钙与大蒜联合使用时抗菌效果降低。
核心结论
- 在研究的局限性内,大蒜根管内封药抗链球菌效力与氢氧化钙相当,而对粪肠球菌更有效。
- 氢氧化钙与大蒜联合时其抗菌效果降低。
- 将受试根管内封药时间延长至一周以上无额外抗菌效果。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性双盲、对照、平行、优效性随机临床试验。
- 纳入66名男性患者的66颗伴无症状根尖周炎的坏死恒切牙。
- 患者随机分为三组(每组n=22),按所用根管内封药分组。
- 于器械预备前(S1)、清洁成形后(S2)及封药后7天(S3)和14天(S4)各取微生物样本。
- 用相对定量实时PCR测定粪肠球菌和链球菌属的相对基因表达倍数变化。
主要发现
- 所有组在机械器械处理后(S1至S2)两种细菌的平均倍数变化均显著下降。
- 除大蒜组外,放置根管内封药后(S2至S3及S3至S4)未见统计学显著差异。
- 与氢氧化钙及氢氧化钙+大蒜联合相比,大蒜在S3和S4显著降低粪肠球菌倍数变化。
- 大蒜与氢氧化钙在S3对链球菌属的降低程度相似,而在S4大蒜的降低显著多于氢氧化钙。
- 氢氧化钙与大蒜提取物联合显示的细菌降低最少。
局限性
- 原文在结论中表述为「Within the study limitations」,但摘要未具体列出各项局限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: The purpose of this study was to compare the antibacterial effects of Allium sativum (garlic extract), calcium hydroxide (Ca [OH]2 ) and their combination as intracanal medicaments in infected mature anterior teeth using real-time PCR. METHODOLOGY: This prospective double-blind, controlled, parallel, superiority, randomized clinical trial was carried out on 66 permanent, necrotic incisors associated with asymptomatic apical periodontitis in 66 male patients. Patients were randomly divided into three groups (n = 22) according to the intracanal medications used. After access preparation, four microbiological samples (S) were taken using sterile absorbent paper points as follows: S1: before canal instrumentation and S2: after cleaning and shaping. The third sample (S3) and fourth sample (S4) were taken after the placement of the tested intracanal medications into their corresponding canals for 7 and 14 days, respectively. Total DNA was extracted from microbiological samples and relative quantitative real-time PCRs were done to quantify the relative gene expression fold change (FC) for Enterococcus faecalis and Streptococcus species. At significance level p ≤ .05, the data were statistically analysed in SPSS software using Kruskal-Wallis and Freidman's tests, followed by Dunn-Bonferroni post hoc test for pairwise comparisons. RESULTS: Both bacterial mean FC decreased significantly after mechanical instrumentation (S1 to S2) in all groups. However, no statistically significant differences were found after intracanal medicament placement (from S2 to S3 and from S3 to S4) except in the garlic group. Garlic significantly reduced Enterococcus faecalis FC in S3 and S4 when compared to Ca (OH)2 and Ca (OH)2 + garlic combination. However, garlic and Ca (OH)2 reduced Streptococcus bacteria in S3 similarly. Whilst in S4, garlic showed significantly more reduction than Ca (OH)2 . The combination of Ca (OH)2 with garlic extract showed the least significant bacterial reduction. CONCLUSION: Within the study limitations, garlic intracanal medicament has a comparable anti-Streptococcus efficiency to Ca (OH)2 , whilst it is more effective against Enterococcus faecalis species. When Ca (OH)2 and garlic are combined, their antibacterial effectiveness is reduced. Increasing the time of application for tested intracanal medicaments by more than one week has no additional antibacterial effectiveness.
引用
- Mahfouz Omer SM, Mohamed DA, Ali Abdel Latif RM, et al. Comparative evaluation of the antibacterial effect of Allium sativum, calcium hydroxide and their combination as intracanal medicaments in infected mature anterior teeth: A randomized clinical trial. Int Endod J. 2022. PMID: 35852013. doi:10.1111/iej.13801
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。