公众对直接修复体的价值评估:一项离散选择实验
该研究采用离散选择实验(DCE)调查英国普通人群对后牙直接修复体7个属性的偏好及支付意愿(WTP),共1002名受访者完成。受访者愿为缩短等待时间、由牙医而非治疗师操作、白色充填、减少治疗时间、消除术后疼痛及延长修复体寿命付费;支付能力影响WTP,低收入者更可能选择不治疗,且对白色充填和延长寿命的估值显著低于高收入者。
要点
- 受访者愿支付£39.52将6周等待缩短至2周,£13.55由牙医而非治疗师操作。
- 愿支付£41.66将充填颜色从银灰色改为白色,£116.52从持续术后疼痛转为无痛。
- 低收入受访者更可能选择不治疗,对白色充填和延长寿命的支付意愿显著低于高收入者。
核心结论
- 英国普通人群对直接修复体的等待时间、操作者类型、颜色、治疗时长、术后不适、寿命和费用存在可量化的支付意愿,且支付能力影响这些偏好。
研究设计与样本
- 采用离散选择实验(DCE),通过在线调查发放给英国普通人群的代表性样本,受访者完成17个选择任务,每个任务比较两个情景,情景在7个属性水平上变化,并包含不治疗选项。
- 共1002名受访者完成DCE,使用混合logit模型分析数据,计算各属性水平的边际支付意愿(WTP)和相对属性重要性。
主要发现
- 受访者愿意支付£39.52将6周治疗等待缩短至2周,£13.55由牙医而非治疗师操作,£41.66将充填颜色从银灰色改为白色。
- 受访者愿意支付£0.27每分钟减少的治疗时间,£116.52从持续术后疼痛转为无痛,£5.44每增加一年修复体寿命。
- 支付能力影响支付意愿,低收入受访者更可能选择不治疗,且对白色充填和延长寿命的估值显著低于高收入者。
关键数值与推荐
- 等待时间从6周缩短至2周的边际支付意愿为£39.52。
- 由牙医而非治疗师操作的边际支付意愿为£13.55。
- 充填颜色从银灰色改为白色的边际支付意愿为£41.66。
- 从持续术后疼痛转为无痛的边际支付意愿为£116.52。
- 修复体寿命每增加一年的边际支付意愿为£5.44。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,临床医生应了解修复体选择的潜在驱动因素,以便与个别患者讨论以获得知情同意。
- 作者认为,政策制定者在考虑逐步淘汰银汞合金修复体时,应考虑普通人群对修复体结果和服务的偏好,并意识到收入如何影响这些偏好。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Direct posterior dental restorations are commonly provided following management of dental caries. Amalgam use has been phased down and the feasibility of a phase-out by 2030 is being explored. Alternative direct restorative materials differ in their outcomes and provision. This research aimed to elicit the UK population's preferences for different attributes of restorations and their willingness to pay (WTP) for restorative services and outcomes. A discrete choice experiment (DCE) was designed with patient and public involvement and distributed to a representative sample of the UK general population using an online survey. Respondents answered 17 choice tasks between pairs of scenarios that varied in levels of 7 attributes (wait for filling, clinician type, filling color, length of procedure, likely discomfort after filling, average life span of filling, and cost). An opt-out (no treatment) was included. Mixed logit models were used for data analysis. Marginal WTP for attribute levels and relative attribute importance were calculated. In total, 1,002 respondents completed the DCE. Overall, respondents were willing to pay £39.52 to reduce a 6-wk wait for treatment to 2 wk, £13.55 to have treatment by a dentist rather than a therapist, £41.66 to change filling color from silvery/gray to white, £0.27 per minute of reduced treatment time, £116.52 to move from persistent to no postoperative pain, and £5.44 per year of increased restoration longevity. Ability to pay affected willingness to pay, with low-income respondents more likely to opt out of treatment and value restoration color (white) and increased longevity significantly lower than those with higher income. Clinicians should understand potential drivers of restoration choice, so they can be discussed with individual patients to obtain consent. It is important that policy makers consider general population preferences for restorative outcomes and services, with an awareness of how income affects these, when considering the potential phase-out of amalgam restorations.
引用
- Bailey O, Stone S, Ternent L, et al. Public Valuation of Direct Restorations: A Discrete Choice Experiment. J Dent Res. 2022. PMID: 35876387. doi:10.1177/00220345221108699
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。