文献速递口腔修复与种植

口腔修复学本科课程的教学与评估方法:一项国际德尔菲调查

Undergraduate teaching and assessment methods in prosthodontics curriculum: An international Delphi survey.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent · 2022-06-26

本研究采用德尔菲法,通过三轮电子问卷征询11个国家23名口腔修复学/修复牙科学高级学术专家的意见,旨在就本科口腔修复学最佳教学与评估方法达成共识。18名专家完成全部问卷(应答率78.3%),189条陈述中175条(92.6%)达成共识,共识声明可作为改进本科口腔修复学课程的详细指南与推荐。

要点

  • 三轮德尔菲调查中189条陈述有175条(92.6%)达成共识,仅14条未达成共识。
  • 23名来自11个国家的高级学术专家参与,18名完成全部问卷(应答率78.3%)。
  • 共识声明可作为改进本科口腔修复学课程的详细指南与推荐。

核心结论

  • 175条共识声明代表了来自四大洲九个不同国家参与的高级口腔修复学学术专家的共识意见。
  • 这些共识声明可被视为改进未来本科口腔修复学课程的详细指南与推荐。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用德尔菲法,通过三轮连续半结构化电子问卷收集口腔修复学教学高级临床学术专家的意见。
  • 邀请邮件发送给36名国际牙科高级学术专家,23名来自11个国家的专家同意参与。
  • 18名专家(代表9个不同国家)完整完成问卷,应答率78.3%。
  • 每轮间应答率至少70%被视为维持严谨性的适当标准,每个问题的目标共识水平设定为≥70%。

主要发现

  • 三轮迭代中189条陈述有175条(92.6%)达成共识,仅14条未达成共识。
  • 达成共识的陈述数量远高于未达成共识的陈述数量。

关键数值与推荐

  • 每个问题的目标共识水平设定为≥70%。
  • 轮次间应答率至少70%被视为维持严谨性的适当标准。
  • 189条陈述中175条(92.6%)达成共识,14条未达成共识。

临床怎么用

  • 共识声明可作为改进本科口腔修复学课程的详细指南与推荐。
  • 该共识有助于减少目前国际与国内牙学院口腔修复学课程的分歧,可能使未来牙医及患者受益。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To achieve consensus amongst an expert panel of prosthodontics/restorative dentistry academics on the best undergraduate teaching and assessments, and to develop recommendations regarding teaching and assessment of undergraduate prosthodontics. METHODS: Semi-structured electronic questionnaires were used to collect data from senior clinical academics involved in the teaching of prosthodontics on three consecutive occasions (Delphi method). The questionnaires asked the experts' opinion on best teaching and assessment methods in the undergraduate prosthodontics curriculum. Invitation emails, with a hyperlink to the Round 1 questionnaire, were sent to 36 international dental academic experts. In later rounds, panellists were invited to consider their previous responses in light of the overall group response in attempt to bring the panel to a consensus. The group response was summarized using simple descriptive statistics, and the target level of consensus for each question was set at ≥ 70%. A response rate of at least 70% between rounds was deemed appropriate to maintain rigour. RESULTS: Twenty-three senior academic experts from eleven countries agreed to participate. Eighteen (representing nine different countries) completed the questionnaires in its entirety (response rate 78.3%). The number of statements that attained consensus agreement was much higher than the number of non-consensus statements-92.6%, 175 statements out of 189 over three iterative rounds. Only 14 statements did not obtain a consensus during this Delphi study. CONCLUSIONS: A total of 175 consensus statements represent the agreement expert views of participated senior academics in prosthodontics from nine different countries and across four continents. These consensus statements could be considered detailed guidelines and recommendations to improve future undergraduates' curriculum in prosthodontics. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: This Delphi study achieved a high consensus among a panel of senior academics in the teaching and assessment of undergraduate prosthodontics. This consensus could help minimise the current international and national divergence in dental schools' prosthodontics curricula, which could benefit future dentists and, subsequently, the patients.

来源:J Dent,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Khalaf KA, Moore C, McKenna G, et al. Undergraduate teaching and assessment methods in prosthodontics curriculum: An international Delphi survey. J Dent. 2022. PMID: 35760208. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2022.104207

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。