牙周预后系统预测牙齿丧失效能的比较
该分析评估四种牙周预后系统在97例接受5年支持性牙周治疗的前瞻性队列中对牙齿丧失的预测能力。四种系统均具良好可重复性且能识别高丧失风险牙,风险随预后类别恶化而升高(p < .0001),但敏感性及阳性预测值均低。
要点
- 四种牙周预后系统在5年支持性牙周治疗队列中均显示良好可重复性。
- 牙齿丧失风险随预后类别恶化而升高(p < .0001)。
- 所有系统敏感性及阳性预测值均低,最差预后类别中多颗牙5年时仍被保留。
核心结论
- 已发表的牙周预后系统具有良好可重复性和预测牙齿保留的能力,但检测到低敏感性,最差预后类别中多颗牙在5年时仍被保留。
- 建议对类别数量及其定义进行一些修改。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性队列分析,纳入97例接受定期支持性牙周治疗5年的牙周炎患者。
- 使用四种预后系统(McGuire & Nunn, 1996;Kwok & Caton, 2007;Graetz等,2011;Nibali等,2017)分配牙齿预后。
- 三名独立检查者在校准练习后使用所有四种系统分配牙齿预后。
主要发现
- 所有四种系统均显示良好可重复性,并能识别5年支持性牙周治疗期间丧失风险较高的牙齿。
- 牙齿丧失风险随牙齿预后类别恶化而增加(p < .0001)。
- 所有系统的特异性和阴性预测值良好,但敏感性和阳性预测值均低。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 所有系统均检测到低敏感性。
- 最差预后类别中多颗牙在5年时仍被保留。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: The aim of this analysis was to assess how different tooth-prognosis systems could predict tooth loss in a cohort of periodontitis patients followed up prospectively during supportive periodontal care (SPC). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Clinical and radiographic data of 97 patients undergoing regular SPC for 5 years were used to assign tooth prognosis using four different systems (McGuire & Nunn, 1996; Kwok & Caton, 2007; Graetz et al., 2011; Nibali et al., 2017). Three independent examiners assigned tooth prognosis using all four systems, following a calibration exercise. The association between prognostic categories and tooth loss was tested for each prognostic system separately and across prognostic systems. RESULTS: All four systems showed good reproducibility and could identify teeth at higher risk of being lost during 5 years of SPC; the risk of tooth loss increased with the worsening of tooth-prognosis category (p < .0001). Although specificity and negative predictive values were good, low sensitivity and positive predictive values were detected for all systems. CONCLUSIONS: Previously published periodontal prognostic systems exhibited good reproducibility and predictive ability for tooth retention. However, low sensitivity was detected, with several teeth in the worst prognosis category being retained at 5 years. Some modifications in the number of categories and their definitions are suggested.
引用
- Saydzai S, Buontempo Z, Patel P, et al. Comparison of the efficacy of periodontal prognostic systems in predicting tooth loss. J Clin Periodontol. 2022. PMID: 35702014. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13672
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。