牙髓组织工程治疗根尖周炎的有效性:一项系统综述
本系统综述检索MEDLINE、Embase、Cochrane Library及Google Scholar至2021年11月,比较牙髓组织工程(ETE)与氢氧化钙根尖诱导成形术、根尖屏障及根管治疗对成人或未成熟恒牙牙髓坏死的疗效。纳入2项随机临床试验共76例(未成熟牙40颗、成熟牙36颗),因异质性无法行Meta分析;12个月时ETE、根管治疗与根尖诱导成形术的患牙存留率均为100%。
要点
- 纳入2项随机临床试验共76例,未成熟牙40颗、成熟牙36颗,偏倚风险为中等担忧。
- 12个月时ETE、根管治疗与根尖诱导成形术的患牙存留率均为100%。
- ETE组牙髓活力测试阳性反应及血液灌注的病例数多于根管治疗或根尖诱导成形术。
核心结论
- ETE技术报告的获益和高存留率提示,该方法可能成为恒牙牙髓坏死传统治疗的替代方案。
- 然而,需要更多合适的研究才能得出临床推荐。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索MEDLINE、Embase、Cochrane Library及Google Scholar灰色文献,截至2021年11月。
- 纳入研究为恒牙未成熟或成熟牙伴牙髓坏死(伴或不伴根尖周炎体征)的患者,比较ETE与氢氧化钙根尖诱导成形术、根尖屏障及根管治疗。
- 要求观察期至少12个月,人体实验或纵向观察性研究结束时患者数至少20例(每组10例)。
- 采用Cochrane偏倚风险工具(RoB 2)评估偏倚风险,由两位作者独立筛选文献、评估全文合格性及偏倚风险。
- 因结局异质性和证据有限未能进行Meta分析;最终纳入2项随机临床试验,共76例参与者(未成熟牙40颗、成熟牙36颗)进行定性分析。
主要发现
- 两项纳入研究在偏倚风险方面均为中等担忧。
- ETE、根管治疗与根尖诱导成形术的患牙存留率在12个月后均为100%。
- 与根管治疗或根尖诱导成形术相比,ETE治疗的牙齿中出现牙髓活力测试阳性反应及血液灌注的病例数更多。
关键数值与推荐
- 观察期要求至少12个月,人体实验或纵向观察性研究结束时患者数至少20例(每组10例)。
- 两项纳入研究共76例参与者,其中未成熟牙40颗、成熟牙36颗。
- 12个月时ETE、根管治疗与根尖诱导成形术的患牙存留率均为100%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 纳入研究的偏倚风险为中等担忧,源于其方法学局限性,整体结果应谨慎解读。
- 文献筛选过程中缺乏稳健的对照组是常见问题。
- 除牙齿存留外的结局报告不一致。
- 未来临床试验需处理方法学及评估方面的问题并报告长期结果。
- 需要更多合适的研究才能得出临床推荐。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Regenerative endodontics has evolved in recent years with tissue engineering concepts in particular appearing promising. Endodontic tissue engineering (ETE) describes the various approaches based on the orthograde introduction of scaffolds or biomaterials (with or without cells) into the root canal to achieve pulp tissue regeneration. There are currently no systematic reviews investigating whether ETE is a suitable method for the treatment of endodontic disease in both mature and immature permanent teeth. OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this systematic review was to determine the effectiveness of ETE in permanent teeth with pulp necrosis in comparison with conventional endodontic treatment. METHODS: We searched MEDLINE, Embase and the Cochrane Library for published reports as well as Google Scholar for grey literature up to November 2021. Included were studies of patients with permanent immature or mature teeth and pulp necrosis with or without signs of apical periodontitis (P) comparing ETE (I) with calcium hydroxide apexification, apical plug and root canal treatment (C) in terms of tooth survival, pain, tenderness, swelling, need for medication (analgesics and antibiotics), radiographic evidence of reduction in apical lesion size, radiographic evidence of normal periodontal ligament space, function (fracture and restoration longevity), the need for further intervention, adverse effects (including exacerbation, restoration integrity, allergy and discolouration), oral health-related quality of life (OHRQoL), presence of sinus tract and response to sensibility testing (O). An observation period of at least 12 months was mandatory (T) and the number of patients in human experimental studies or longitudinal observational studies had to be at least 20 (10 in each arm) at the end (S). Risk of bias was appraised using the Cochrane risk-of-bias (RoB 2) tool. Two authors independently screened the records, assessed full texts for eligibility and evaluated risk of bias. Heterogeneity of outcomes and limited body of evidence did not allow for meta-analysis. RESULTS: Two randomized clinical trials investigating cell transplantation approaches with a total of 76 participants (40 treated immature teeth and 36 treated mature teeth) were included for qualitative analysis. Both studies had moderate concerns in terms of risk of bias. Due to the lack of homogeneity a meta-analysis was not possible. Tooth survival for ETE, root canal treatment and apexification was 100% after 12 months. Teeth treated with ETE showed a higher number of cases with positive pulpal responses to sensitivity tests and with blood perfusion compared with root canal treatment or apexification. DISCUSSION: This systematic review highlights that there is limited evidence for ETE approaches. Even though the results of this review suggest a high survival with ETE in mature and immature teeth, there is a moderate risk of bias due to methodological limitations in the included studies, so the overall results should be interpreted with caution. Lack of a robust control group was a common problem during literature screening, and outcomes besides dental survival were reported inconsistently. Future clinical trials need to address methodical as well as assessment concerns and report long-term results. CONCLUSION: The benefits and high survival rates reported for ETE techniques suggest that this procedure might be an alternative to conventional procedures for permanent teeth with pulpal necrosis. However, more appropriate studies are needed to derive clinical recommendations. REGISTRATION: PROSPERO (CRD42021266350).
引用
- Widbiller M, Knüttel H, Meschi N, et al. Effectiveness of endodontic tissue engineering in treatment of apical periodontitis: A systematic review. Int Endod J. 2022. PMID: 35699668. doi:10.1111/iej.13784
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。