初次根管治疗对牙髓再治疗中硅酸钙基封闭剂牙本质小管渗透的影响
本研究评估初次根管治疗对再治疗时硅酸钙基封闭剂牙本质小管渗透深度的影响,并比较两种测量技术。下颌前磨牙根管分别用AH Plus、MTA Fillapex和WellRoot ST封闭后,再治疗时使用相同或不同封闭剂。结果显示既往治疗限制再治疗封闭剂的渗透深度,再治疗时使用AH Plus和MTA Fillapex具有优势,两种测量技术在根尖区表现相似。
要点
- 既往根管治疗使用的封闭剂会影响再治疗时硅酸钙基封闭剂的渗透深度。
- 再治疗时使用AH Plus或MTA Fillapex在渗透深度上具有优势。
- 两种测量技术在根尖区结果相似,但在冠部和中部区域结果有差异。
核心结论
- 既往根管治疗影响硅酸钙基封闭剂的渗透深度,再治疗时使用AH Plus和MTA Fillapex具有优势;两种测量技术在根尖区表现相似,但在冠部和中部区域结果有差异,因此仍需更稳定的封闭剂渗透测量技术。
研究设计与样本
- 体外研究,使用下颌前磨牙,去除牙冠后预备根管,分别用AH Plus、MTA Fillapex和WellRoot ST封闭剂进行初次根管治疗。
- 储存3周(37°C,100%湿度)后,按初次/再治疗封闭剂组合分组(n=8):AH/AH、AH/MTAF、AH/WRST、MTAF/AH、MTAF/MTAF、MTAF/WRST、WRST/AH、WRST/MTAF、WRST/WRST。
- 再治疗时封闭剂加入绿色Fluo-3染料,采用两种技术测量渗透深度:技术一测量8个点并平均,记录再治疗与初次封闭剂的平均小管渗透深度比值;技术二计算再治疗与初次封闭剂的环周渗透面积比百分比。
- 统计分析采用Kolmogorov-Smirnov、Kruskal-Wallis和Mann-Whitney U检验。
主要发现
- 在对照组中,AH和MTAF的平均渗透深度在冠部三分之一区域较高(P < .05)。
- 两种方法均显示组间在冠部和中部区域有显著差异(P < .05)。
- AH/WRST、MTAH/AH、MTAF/MTAF、MTAF/WRSTS和WRST/WRST组显示更深的管间渗透(技术一,P = .01)。
- 两种技术均显示封闭剂在根尖区的渗透深度相同(P > .05),而在冠部和中部区域技术间存在差异。
- 初次根管治疗使用的封闭剂限制了再治疗过程中所用封闭剂的渗透深度(P < .05);当MTAF作为初始封闭剂时,第二次封闭剂的渗透深度未改变,而当WRST为初始封闭剂时,再治疗过程中中部和根尖区的渗透深度受到负面影响(P < .05)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,再治疗过程中使用AH Plus和MTA Fillapex显示出优势。
- 作者指出,两种测量技术在根尖区表现相似,但在冠部和中部区域结果有差异,因此仍需更稳定的封闭剂渗透测量技术。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of previous root canal treatment on dentinal tubule penetration of calcium silicate-based sealers during endodontic retreatment and to compare 2 different (commonly used and modified) tubule penetration depth measurement techniques. METHODS: The crowns of mandibular premolar teeth were removed, and root canals were prepared (ProTaper Universal; Dentsply Sirona, York, PA) and obturated using AH Plus (AH; Dentsply DeTrey, Konstanz, Germany), MTA Fillapex (MTAF; Angelus, Londrina, Brazil), and WellRoot ST (WRST; Vericom, Gyeonggi-do, South Korea); 0.1% red Rhod-2 dye (Chemodex, St Gallen, Switzerland) was added to the sealers. After storage for 3 weeks (37°C, 100% humid), the following sealer combination subgroups were created (the sealer used during the primary root canal treatment/the sealer used during the retreatment, n = 8): AH/AH, AH/MTAF, and AH/WRST; MTAF/AH, MTAF/MTAF, and MTAF/WRST; and WRST/AH, WRST/MTAF, and WRST/WRST. Green Fluo-3 dye (0.1%) was added to the sealers during retreatment. Sealer penetration depths were measured at 8 points and averaged, and the ratio of the retreatment sealer to the initial sealer was recorded as the mean tubule penetration depth ratio in the first technique, whereas the percentage of the circumferential penetration area ratios of the retreatment and initial sealers was calculated in the second technique. Statistical analyses were performed using Kolmogorov-Smirnov, Kruskal-Wallis, and Mann-Whitney U tests. RESULTS: The mean penetration depth of AH and MTFA was found to be higher at the coronal third region in the control groups (P < .05). Both methods showed a significant difference among the groups at the coronal and median regions (P < .05). The AH/WRST, MTAH/AH, MTAF/MTAF, MTAF/WRSTS, and WRST/WRST groups showed deeper tubule penetration (first technique, P = .01). Both techniques showed that the penetration depth of the sealers was the same at the apical region (P > .05), whereas a difference was found among the techniques at the coronal and median regions. The sealers used in the previous root canal treatment limited the penetration depth of the sealers used during the retreatment process (P < .05). When MTAF was used as the initial sealer, the penetration depth of the second sealer did not change, whereas if WRST was the initial sealer, the penetration depth of the sealers at the median and apical regions is negatively affected during the retreatment process (P < .05). CONCLUSIONS: Previous root canal treatment affects the penetration depth of calcium silicate-based sealers. The use of AH Plus and MTA Fillapex during the retreatment process showed an advantage. Both measurement techniques showed similar performances at the apical region, whereas the results varied at the coronal and midcoronal regions; therefore, a more stable sealer penetration measurement technique is still necessary.
引用
- Eğemen A, Belli S. The Effect of Primary Root Canal Treatment on Dentinal Tubule Penetration of Calcium Silicate-based Sealers during Endodontic Retreatment. J Endod. 2022. PMID: 35667566. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2022.05.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。