非手术根管治疗与再治疗对比根尖手术治疗根尖周炎的系统综述
本系统综述比较根尖手术与非手术根管治疗或再治疗在根尖周炎患牙中的临床及患者相关结局。纳入5项研究共529颗随访牙齿,随访6个月至8.7年,偏倚风险高,因异质性未行Meta分析。结论为无治疗方式显示明确优越性,需更多高质量对比试验。
要点
- 根尖手术在根尖周愈合和减少额外干预需求方面似乎更优,但对照组牙齿生存率更高。
- 纳入研究异质性大,无法进行Meta分析,4项研究偏倚风险高。
- 无治疗方式显示明确优越性,需额外高质量对比试验以得出统计学支持的结论。
核心结论
- 无治疗方式显示明确优越性,需额外高质量对比试验以得出统计学支持的结论。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述纳入随机对照试验、非随机对照试验和纵向观察性研究,比较根尖手术(治疗组)与非手术根管治疗或再治疗(对照组)治疗根尖周炎患牙。
- 共纳入5项研究:2项随机临床试验、2项非随机临床试验和1项回顾性队列研究。
- 共529颗牙齿可用于随访,随访时间从6个月到8.7年。
- 使用Cochrane偏倚风险工具、ROBINS-I和Newcastle-Ottawa量表评估偏倚风险。
主要发现
- 根尖手术在根尖周愈合和减少更多及进一步干预需求方面似乎结果更好,但对照组牙齿生存率更高。
- 4项研究总体偏倚风险高,1项研究存在一些担忧。
- 因研究异质性,无法进行Meta分析。
- 观察者间一致性高,kappa相关系数良好。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 4项研究总体偏倚风险高,1项研究存在一些担忧。
- 因研究异质性,无法进行Meta分析。
- 需额外高质量对比试验以得出统计学支持的结论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In addition to non-surgical root canal treatment or retreatment, apical surgery may be carried out to manage teeth with apical periodontitis. However, it is unclear which treatment option is more effective. OBJECTIVE: To systematically review the effectiveness of apical surgery compared with non-surgical treatment or retreatment in terms of clinical and patient-related outcomes in teeth with apical periodontitis. METHODS: A literature search of electronic databases, the grey literature, the reference lists of included articles and previous reviews, and a hand search of leading endodontic journals, was conducted. Randomised and non-randomised control trials, and longitudinal observational studies on patients undergoing surgical (treatment group) and non-surgical root canal treatment or retreatment (control group) of teeth with apical periodontitis were included. The risk of bias was appraised using the Cochrane risk-of-bias tool; ROBINS-I and the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. RESULTS: Five studies, consisting of two randomised clinical trials, two non-randomised clinical trials, and a retrospective cohort study, were included. The interobserver agreement was high and kappa correlation coefficient was good. In total 529 teeth were available for follow-up that varied from 6 months to 8.7 years. The overall risk of bias was high for four studies and raised some concerns in one study. Apical surgery showed seemly better results regarding periapical healing and less need for more and further intervention, although tooth survival was higher in the control group. Given the heterogeneity of the studies, meta-analysis was not possible. DISCUSSION: Previous systematic reviews have conducted an indirect comparison by separately pooling the outcomes of studies analysing either non-surgical, or surgical, treatment. In this systematic review, only studies that compared both treatments were included. Most results of this and previous reviews were similar. CONCLUSION: No treatment option showed clear superiority. However, to arrive at statistically supported conclusions there is a need for additional high-quality comparative trials. REGISTRATION: PROSPERO database (Registration number CRD42021260300).
引用
- Bucchi C, Rosen E, Taschieri S, et al. Non-surgical root canal treatment and retreatment versus apical surgery in treating apical periodontitis: A systematic review. Int Endod J. 2022. PMID: 35762859. doi:10.1111/iej.13793
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。