根据开髓洞形预备与颈周牙本质保留情况的上颌磨牙生物力学行为与寿命:有限元分析
本研究用有限元分析探讨颈周牙本质在冠部根管敞开后的意义,比较完整牙、保守开髓洞形及3种冠部4 mm根管预备器械模型在50 N循环载荷下的失效循环次数与应力分布。结果显示保守开髓洞形使失效循环次数较完整牙模型显著降低(93.99%),冠部根管预备即使到极端(Gates-Glidden:92.02%)也无显著影响。
要点
- 保守开髓洞形使失效循环次数较完整牙模型显著降低(93.99%)。
- 冠部根管预备即使到极端(Gates-Glidden:92.02%)对失效循环次数无显著影响。
- 最大von Mises应力在Gates-Glidden模型咬合面最高(7.88 MPa),完整牙模型最低(7.01 MPa)。
核心结论
- 在本研究局限内,冠部根管敞开对牙齿完整性影响很小,当载荷条件处于正常功能范围时,牙体结构有能力将增加的应力分散到更大表面积上。
研究设计与样本
- 研究采用有限元分析,除完整牙模型外设计4个实验模型:保守开髓洞形模型,以及针对冠部4 mm分别使用ProTaper SX、OneFlare和Gates-Glidden 3种器械的3个根管预备模型。
- 在咬合面施加50 N循环载荷,比较各模型与完整牙模型的失效循环次数,并进行数学分析评估应力分布模式、计算最大von Mises应力和最大主应力。
主要发现
- 与完整牙模型相比,开髓洞形预备使失效循环次数显著降低(93.99%)。
- 冠部根管预备对失效循环次数无显著影响,即使预备到极端(Gates-Glidden:92.02%)。
- von Mises分析证实应力向根尖分散,最大值出现在Gates-Glidden模型咬合面(7.88 MPa),最小值出现在完整牙模型(7.01 MPa)。
- 根分叉区显示较高的最大主应力,但应力值仍很小,且随模型间逐步扩大而分布在更大表面上。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: This study investigated the significance of pericervical dentin after coronal canal flaring on the biomechanical behavior and life span of a maxillary molar using finite element analysis (FEA). METHODS: In addition to the intact tooth (IT) model, 4 experimental FE models were designed: conservative access cavity model (CON), and 3 models with different radicular preparations for the coronal 4 mL considering 3 instruments: ProTaper SX model (SX), OneFlare model (OF), and Gates-Glidden model (GG). Cyclic loading of 50 N was applied on the occlusal surface and number of cycles until failure (NCF) was compared with the IT model. Mathematical analysis was done to evaluate the stress distribution patterns and calculated maximum von Mises (VM) and maximum principal stresses. RESULTS: Access cavity preparation (CON) decreased NCF significantly when compared with the IT model (93.99%). The coronal preparation of the root canal did not have a significant effect even when the preparation was taken to the extreme (GG: 92.02%). VM analysis confirmed apical dispersion of stresses, with maximum value registered on the occlusal surface in the GG model (7.88 MPa), and minimum on the IT model (7.01 MPa). The furcation area showed higher maximum principal stresses, yet stress values remained minimal and distributed over larger surfaces with the progressive enlargement among models. CONCLUSIONS: Within the limitations of this study, coronal canal flaring affects tooth integrity minimally, and when loading conditions lie within normal functional ranges, tooth structure has the capacity to disperse increasing stresses over a wider surface area.
引用
- Nawar NN, Kataia M, Omar N, et al. Biomechanical Behavior and Life Span of Maxillary Molar According to the Access Preparation and Pericervical Dentin Preservation: Finite Element Analysis. J Endod. 2022. PMID: 35398148. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2022.03.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。