深度学习用于龋齿检测:一项系统综述
本系统综述检索2010年后发表的深度学习龋齿检测诊断准确性研究,最终纳入42项研究,使用分类、目标检测或分割模型。图像、目标或像素准确率范围为68%-99%,但仅11项研究在所有领域偏倚风险低,研究质量偏低。作者认为深度学习模型可作为判断龋损存在与否的辅助工具。
要点
- 纳入42项深度学习龋齿检测研究,图像、目标或像素准确率在68%-99%之间。
- 不同影像类型的分类模型准确率各异,口内照片为71%-96%,根尖片为82%-99.2%。
- 仅11项研究在所有领域偏倚风险低,13项研究(31.0%)适用性担忧风险低。
核心结论
- 深度学习用于龋齿检测的研究数量不断增加,采用了多种网络架构,报告的准确率似乎有前景,但研究和报告质量目前较低。
- 深度学习模型可被视为判断龋损存在与否的决策辅助工具。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述纳入42项诊断准确性研究,使用深度学习模型分析牙科影像(包括X线片、照片、光学相干断层扫描图像、近红外光透照图像)。
- 检索数据库包括Medline(通过PubMed)、Google Scholar、Scopus、Embase及ArXiv预印本库,纳入2010年后发表、不限语言的文献。
主要发现
- 从252篇可能合格的文献中,48篇进行全文评估,最终纳入42篇,其中分类模型26篇、目标检测模型6篇、分割模型10篇。
- 图像、目标或像素准确率范围为68%-99%;仅11篇研究在所有领域偏倚风险低,13篇(31.0%)适用性担忧风险低。
- 分类模型准确率:口内照片71%-96%,根尖片82%-99.2%,咬翼片87.6%-95.4%,近红外透照图像68.0%-78.0%,光学相干断层扫描图像88.7%-95.2%,全景片86.1%-96.1%。
- 合并诊断比值比范围为2.27至32767;检测和分割模型因报告异质性无法进行有效合并。
关键数值与推荐
- 使用QUADAS-2最新版工具进行偏倚风险评估。
- 因研究方法及性能指标异质性未进行Meta分析。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为深度学习模型可被视为判断龋损存在与否的决策辅助工具。
局限性
- 因研究方法及性能指标异质性未进行Meta分析。
- 仅11项研究在所有领域偏倚风险低,13项研究(31.0%)适用性担忧风险低,研究和报告质量目前较低。
- 检测和分割模型因报告异质性无法进行有效合并。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Detecting caries lesions is challenging for dentists, and deep learning models may help practitioners to increase accuracy and reliability. We aimed to systematically review deep learning studies on caries detection. DATA: We selected diagnostic accuracy studies that used deep learning models on dental imagery (including radiographs, photographs, optical coherence tomography images, near-infrared light transillumination images). The latest version of the quality assessment tool for diagnostic accuracy studies (QUADAS-2) tool was used for risk of bias assessment. Meta-analysis was not performed due to heterogeneity in the studies methods and their performance measurements. SOURCES: Databases (Medline via PubMed, Google Scholar, Scopus, Embase) and a repository (ArXiv) were screened for publications published after 2010, without any limitation on language. STUDY SELECTION: From 252 potentially eligible references, 48 studies were assessed full-text and 42 included, using classification (n = 26), object detection (n = 6), or segmentation models (n = 10). A wide range of performance metrics was used; image, object or pixel accuracy ranged between 68%-99%. The minority of studies (n = 11) showed a low risk of biases in all domains, and 13 studies (31.0%) low risk for concerns regarding applicability. The accuracy of caries classification models varied, i.e. 71% to 96% on intra-oral photographs, 82% to 99.2% on peri-apical radiographs, 87.6% to 95.4% on bitewing radiographs, 68.0% to 78.0% on near-infrared transillumination images, 88.7% to 95.2% on optical coherence tomography images, and 86.1% to 96.1% on panoramic radiographs. Pooled diagnostic odds ratios varied from 2.27 to 32,767. For detection and segmentation models, heterogeneity in reporting did not allow useful pooling. CONCLUSION: An increasing number of studies investigated caries detection using deep learning, with a diverse types of architectures being employed. Reported accuracy seems promising, while study and reporting quality are currently low. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Deep learning models can be considered as an assistant for decisions regarding the presence or absence of carious lesions.
引用
- Mohammad-Rahimi H, Motamedian SR, Rohban MH, et al. Deep learning for caries detection: A systematic review. J Dent. 2022. PMID: 35367318. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2022.104115
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。