传统方法与数字化方法评估牙龈退缩的比较
本研究比较传统临床法与数字化法评估晚期牙周炎患者非手术治疗前后牙龈退缩变化(ΔREC)的一致性。样本为10例牙周炎患者(III/IV期,B/C级),共99颗上颌牙、594个位点。结果显示两法完全一致率仅38%,数字化法灵敏度与准确度更高。
要点
- 传统临床法与数字化法测量的牙龈退缩变化完全一致率仅38%。
- Bland-Altman分析显示两法95%一致性界限为-2.6至1.8mm。
- 数字化法可提高牙周病学与种植学研究数据的质量。
核心结论
- 传统临床法评估牙龈退缩变化(ΔREC)的灵敏度与准确度低于数字化法。
研究设计与样本
- 在10例牙周炎患者(III/IV期,B/C级)中比较传统临床法与数字化法评估牙龈退缩变化(ΔREC)的一致性。
- 评估上颌牙从右侧到左侧第二前磨牙共99颗牙,每个牙6个位点共594个位点。
- 临床评估由校准检查者于基线(T0)和非手术治疗后12个月(T1)测量牙龈缘至釉牙骨质界距离并相减,检查者内一致性>90%。
- 数字化评估直接在重叠的T0和T1数字模型上测量牙龈缘间距离。
主要发现
- 传统临床法测得ΔREC中位数(第5和第95百分位)为0.0mm(-2.0至1.0),数字化法为-0.4mm(-1.6至0.8),p<0.0001。
- 两法四舍五入后ΔREC值完全一致率仅38%。
- Bland-Altman分析显示两法95%一致性界限为-2.6至1.8mm。
- 两法绝对差异>0.5mm和>1mm的位点分别占61%和38%。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出数字化法可显著提高牙周病学和种植学临床与研究数据的质量,同时保持与传统临床法的兼容性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The present study aimed to compare the conventional clinical and a digital method for evaluating differences in gingival recession (ΔREC) in patients with advanced periodontitis treated with the non-surgical treatment protocol. METHODS: Agreement between the methods was evaluated on a sample of ten patients with periodontitis (stage III/IV, grade B/C) with acquired clinical measurements and digital models from baseline (T0) and 12-months after non-surgical treatment of periodontitis (T1). The evaluation was performed on maxillary teeth from right to left second premolar resulting in overall 99 teeth. Clinical evaluation was performed by subtracting the distance measurements between gingival margin and cemento-enamel junction, obtained at T0 and T1 by a calibrated examiner (intra-examiner agreement >90%). The digital evaluation was performed directly by measuring the distance between the gingival margins on superimposed T0 and T1 digital models. Using Bland-Altman and statistical analysis, all six measurements sites around each included tooth (n=594) acquired with both methods were compared. RESULTS: Median ΔREC (5th and 95th percentile) acquired with a conventional clinical and digital method was 0.0mm (-2.0 - 1.0) and -0.4mm (-1.6 - 0.8), respectively (p<0.0001). The complete agreement between rounded digital and clinical ΔREC values was only 38%, revealing high disagreement also confirmed by Bland-Altman analysis with 95% limits of agreement ranging from -2.6 to 1.8mm. Absolute differences between the methods higher than 0.5 and 1 mm, was found in 61% and 38% of measurement sites, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The conventional clinical method for ΔREC evaluation exhibits lower sensitivity and accuracy than the digital method. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The quality of both clinical and research data in periodontology and implantology can be considerably improved by the digital method while still preserving the compatibility with the conventional clinical method.
引用
- Kuralt M, Cmok Kučič A, Gašperšič R, et al. Evaluation of gingival recessions with conventional versus digital methods. J Dent. 2022. PMID: 35301080. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2022.104093
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。