摄影测量与传统印模技术用于全牙弓种植修复的精度对比:一项体外比较研究
该体外研究以含8个螺丝固位基台替代体的上颌牙列缺失石膏模型为参考模型,由同一名主治医师分别用摄影测量法(10次扫描)和传统开窗夹板式印模法(10个石膏模型)制取基台水平印模。结果显示摄影测量组正确度和精密度均显著优于传统印模组(P<0.001),作者认为摄影测量技术精度更优。
要点
- 摄影测量组正确度(17.33±0.34)μm,显著优于传统印模组(24.30±4.16)μm(P<0.001)。
- 摄影测量组精密度(2.50±0.79)μm,显著优于传统印模组(26.12±4.54)μm(P<0.001)。
- 体外模型研究提示全牙弓种植基台水平印模中摄影测量精度优于传统印模。
核心结论
- 制取牙列缺失种植修复基台水平印模时,摄影测量技术的精度优于传统印模技术。
研究设计与样本
- 体外比较研究,以1例2019年9月就诊于首都医科大学口腔医学院种植中心的74岁男性上颌牙列缺失患者的上颌石膏模型(含8个螺丝固位基台替代体)复制后作为参考模型。
- 由同1名主治医师制取印模,摄影测量组扫描重复10次,传统印模组灌注石膏模型10个。
- 两组数据分别与参考模型数据配准评估正确度,并进行组内两两配准评估精密度。
主要发现
- 摄影测量组正确度(17.33±0.34)μm显著优于传统印模组(24.30±4.16)μm(t=-5.29,P<0.001)。
- 摄影测量组精密度(2.50±0.79)μm显著优于传统印模组(26.12±4.54)μm(t=-34.35,P<0.001)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To compare the accuracy of photogrammetry and conventional impression techniques for complete-arch implant rehabilitation. Methods: An edentulous maxillary stone cast containing 8 screw-retained implant abutment replicas was derived from a 74-year-old male patient who visited the Department of Dental Implant Center, Capital Medical University School of Stomatology in September 2019. The stone cast was copied through the open-tray splinted impression, and the copied cast was used as the master cast for this study. The abutment-level impressions of master cast were made by photogrammetry (PG) and the conventional impression technique (CNV) by one attending doctor. Group PG: after which scan bodies were connected to each implant replica, a photogrammetry system was used to obtain digital impressions of the master cast (n=10); Group CNV: conventional open-tray splinted impression technique was performed to fabricate conventional definitive casts (n=10). After connecting the scan bodies onto each implant replicas, the master cast and the 10 definitive casts from group CNV were digitized with a laboratory reference scanner. All data of group PG, group CNV and mater cast were saved as ".stl" files. For all test scans and reference scan, the three-dimensional information of scan bodies were converted to implant abutment replicas using a computer aided design software (Exocad). The data of the group PG and the group CNV were respectively registered with the reference data (trueness analysis) and pairwise within group (precision analysis) for accuracy evaluation in a three-dimensional analysis software (Geomagic Control X). Results: The trueness and precision of group PG [(17.33±0.34) and (2.50±0.79) μm ] were significantly statistically better than those of group CNV [(24.30±4.16) and (26.12±4.54) μm] respectively (t=-5.29 and -34.35, P<0.001). Conclusions: For complete-arch implant abutment-level impression, photogrammetry produces significantly better accuracy than conventional impression technique. 目的: 通过体外实验对比摄影测量与传统印模技术制取牙列缺失种植修复印模的精度。 方法: 选择1例2019年9月就诊于首都医科大学口腔医学院种植中心的74岁男性上颌牙列缺失患者的上颌石膏模型,其上含螺丝固位基台替代体8个。通过开窗夹板式印模复制该石膏模型,将复制模型作为参考模型。由同1名主治医师用两种方法制取参考模型种植体基台水平印模,摄影测量组:在基台替代体上安装摄影测量专用基台扫描体,使用基于摄影测量技术的口外扫描仪扫描参考模型,获取“.stl”数据(扫描重复10次);传统印模组:应用开窗个别托盘制取参考模型的夹板式印模,灌注石膏模型(10个)。在传统印模组石膏模型和参考模型上安装模型扫描专用基台扫描体,应用高精度模型扫描仪进行扫描,获取印模组和参考模型“.stl”数据。在计算机辅助设计软件(exocad)中,根据扫描体三维坐标,将两组模型和参考模型的扫描体替换为基台替代体。将数据输入三维分析软件(Geomagic Control X),摄影测量组和传统印模组数据分别与参考模型数据配准(正确度评估)以及组内两两配准(精密度评估),评估精度。 结果: 摄影测量组正确度和精密度[分别为(17.33±0.34)和(2.50±0.79)μm]均显著优于传统印模组[(24.30±4.16)和(26.12±4.54)μm](t=-5.29和-34.35,P<0.001)。 结论: 制取牙列缺失种植修复基台水平印模时,摄影测量技术的精度优于传统印模技术。.
引用
- Sun YJ, Ma BW, Yue XX, et al. [Accuracy of photogrammetry and conventional impression techniques for complete-arch implant rehabilitation: an in vitro comparative study]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2022. PMID: 35152653. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20210407-00164
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。