即刻与延期放置牙种植体临床结局的比较:系统综述与Meta分析
本系统综述与Meta分析比较即刻与延期种植的临床结局,并估算即刻种植的效应量。检索截至2019年11月,Q1纳入6篇随机对照试验,Q2纳入53篇文献(22篇随机对照试验、11篇对照临床试验、20篇病例系列)。结果显示两组种植体生存率无显著差异,即刻组在负载后1年骨水平和PES评分上更优;即刻种植体早期并发症为三倍、后期并发症为两倍,生存率高(97%),PES评分高(范围10.36至11.25)。
要点
- 即刻与延期种植体生存率相似,但即刻组早期并发症为三倍、后期并发症为两倍。
- 负载后1年骨水平和PES评分即刻组更优,但边缘骨丧失和牙龈/龈乳头退缩信息各研究不一。
- 作者认为成功标准应更一致地报告,即刻种植相关并发症的发生率与类型需进一步探索。
核心结论
- 即刻与延期种植体生存率相似。
- 即刻种植体早期并发症为三倍、后期并发症为两倍。
- 作者认为成功标准应更一致地报告,即刻种植相关并发症的发生率与类型需进一步探索。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,电子检索MEDLINE、EMBASE、Cochrane对照试验中心注册库和OpenGray并辅以手工检索,截至2019年11月。
- Q1纳入以延期种植为对照的随机对照试验6篇;Q2纳入即刻种植的随机对照试验、对照临床试验和前瞻性病例系列共53篇(22篇随机对照试验、11篇对照临床试验、20篇病例系列)。
主要发现
- Q1:Meta分析未显示种植体生存率有显著差异,但负载后1年骨水平和PES评分有显著差异,利于即刻组。
- Q2:Meta分析显示即刻种植体生存率高(97%),PES评分高(范围10.36至11.25)。
- 各纳入研究关于边缘骨丧失和牙龈/龈乳头退缩的信息不一致。
- 即刻种植体早期并发症为三倍、后期并发症为两倍。
局限性
- 作者认为成功标准应更一致地报告,即刻种植相关并发症的发生率与类型需进一步探索。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Two focused questions were addressed: Focused question (Q1) 1) Are there any differences between immediate and delayed placement in terms of (i) survival rate, (ii) success rate, (iii) radiographic marginal bone levels, (iv) height/(v)thickness of buccal wall, (vi) peri-implant mucosal margin position, (vii) aesthetics outcomes and (viii) patient reported outcomes? Focused question 2 (Q2) What is the estimated effect size of immediate implant placement for all parameters included in Q1? MATERIALS AND METHODS: An electronic search (MEDLINE, EMBASE, The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials and OpenGray) and hand search were conducted up to November 2019. Randomised controlled trials (RCT) with delayed implant placement as controls were eligible in the analysis for Q1. Immediate dental implant arms RCTs, controlled clinical trials (CCTs) and prospective case series of immediate implant placement were eligible in the analysis for Q2. RESULTS: Six papers (RCTs) were included in the analysis for Q1 and 53 papers (22 RCTs, 11 CCTs and 20 case series) for Q2. Q1: Meta-analyses did not show any significant difference in implant survival, but it did for bone levels and PES scores at 1 year post-loading, favouring the immediate group. Q2: Meta-analyses showed that immediate implants had a high survival rate (97%) and presented high PES scores (range 10.36 to 11.25). Information regarding marginal bone loss and gingival/papillary recession varied among all included studies. CONCLUSION: Similar survival rate was found between immediate and delayed implants. Immediate implants presented threefold early complications and twofold delayed complications. Success criteria should be reported more consistently, and the incidence/type of complications associated with immediate implants should be further explored.
引用
- Garcia-Sanchez R, Dopico J, Kalemaj Z, et al. Comparison of clinical outcomes of immediate versus delayed placement of dental implants: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2022. PMID: 35044012. doi:10.1111/clr.13892
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。