牙髓病学网状Meta分析系统评价的方法学质量评估与结果总体可信度
本研究采用AMSTAR 2工具评估牙髓病学领域网状Meta分析系统评价的方法学质量及结果总体可信度。共纳入12篇系统评价,其中8篇结果总体可信度为「极低」,1篇「低」,2篇「中」,1篇「高」。结论认为多数牙髓病学网状Meta分析系统评价的方法学质量低于必要标准。
要点
- 牙髓病学领域12篇网状Meta分析系统评价中,8篇结果总体可信度为「极低」。
- 所有系统评价均充分报告了PICO、纳入研究细节、偏倚风险评估和利益冲突条目。
- 仅1篇系统评价充分报告了纳入研究的资金来源。
核心结论
- 牙髓病学领域大多数网状Meta分析系统评价的结果总体可信度被判定为「极低」,因其方法学质量低于必要标准。
- AMSTAR 2和PRISMA for NMA指南可用于指导作者制作高质量的网状Meta分析系统评价,并供编辑和同行评审在评估投稿时使用。
研究设计与样本
- 研究评估牙髓病学领域网状Meta分析系统评价的方法学质量及结果总体可信度。
- 从PubMed、EbBSCOhost和SCOPUS数据库检索自建库至2021年7月发表的英文系统评价。
- 由两名评价员独立进行文献选择、数据提取、方法学质量评估和总体可信度评级,分歧通过讨论解决,若持续存在则由第三名评价员最终决定。
- 采用包含16个条目的AMSTAR 2清单评估方法学质量,每个条目评为「是」「部分是」或「否」。
- 根据AMSTAR 2开发者报告的标准,将每篇系统评价的结果总体可信度分为「高」「中」「低」或「极低」。
主要发现
- 共纳入12篇网状Meta分析系统评价。
- 所有网状Meta分析均充分报告了条目1(研究问题和纳入标准是否包含PICO组成部分)、条目8(是否充分详细描述纳入研究)、条目9(是否使用满意的方法评估纳入研究的偏倚风险)和条目16(是否报告任何潜在利益冲突来源,包括开展综述所获资金)。
- 仅1篇网状Meta分析充分报告了条目10(是否报告纳入研究的资金来源)。
- 8篇系统评价的结果总体可信度被判定为「极低」,1篇为「低」,2篇为「中」,1篇为「高」。
关键数值与推荐
- AMSTAR 2清单包含16个条目,每个条目评为「是」「部分是」或「否」。
- 结果总体可信度分为「高」「中」「低」或「极低」,依据AMSTAR 2开发者报告的标准。
- 所有12篇网状Meta分析均充分报告条目1、8、9和16。
- 仅1篇网状Meta分析充分报告条目10。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: The aims of the study were to assess the methodological quality of systematic reviews with network meta-analyses (NMAs) in Endodontics using the 'A MeaSurement Tool to Assess systematic Reviews' (AMSTAR 2) tool, and to evaluate the overall confidence in the results of the individual reviews included in the analysis. METHODOLOGY: Systematic reviews with NMAs within the specialty of Endodontics published in English were identified from the PubMed, EbBSCOhost and SCOPUS databases from inception to July 2021. Two reviewers were involved independently in the selection of the reviews, data extraction, methodological quality assessment and overall confidence rating. Disagreements were resolved by discussion between the reviewers to achieve consensus; if disagreements persisted, a third reviewer made the final decision. The methodological quality of the included NMAs was appraised using the AMSTAR 2 checklist, which contains 16 items. The reviewers scored each item-'Yes'-when the item was fully addressed, 'Partial Yes'-when the item was not fully addressed, or 'No'-when the item was not addressed. The overall confidence in the results of each review was classified as 'High', 'Moderate', 'Low' or 'Critically low' based on the criteria reported by the AMSTAR 2 developers. RESULTS: Twelve systematic reviews with NMAs were included. All the NMAs adequately reported Item 1 ('Did the research questions and inclusion criteria for the review include the components of PICO?'), Item 8 ('Did the review authors describe the included studies in adequate detail?'), Item 9 ('Did the review authors use a satisfactory technique for assessing the risk of bias (RoB) in individual studies that were included in the review?') and Item 16 ('Did the review authors report any potential sources of conflict of interest, including any funding they received for conducting the review?'), whereas only one NMA reported Item 10 adequately ('Did the review authors report on the sources of funding for the studies included in the review?'). The overall confidence in the results of eight reviews was categorized as 'Critically low', one review was 'Low', two reviews were 'Moderate' and one review was 'High'. CONCLUSION: The overall confidence in the results for the majority of systematic reviews with NMAs in Endodontics was judged to be 'Critically low' as their methodological quality was below the necessary standard. AMSTAR 2 and PRISMA for NMA guidelines are available to guide authors to produce high-quality systematic reviews with NMAs and for editors and peer-reviewers when assessing submissions to journals.
引用
- Nagendrababu V, Faggion CM, Pulikkotil SJ, et al. Methodological assessment and overall confidence in the results of systematic reviews with network meta-analyses in Endodontics. Int Endod J. 2022. PMID: 35080025. doi:10.1111/iej.13693
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。