文献速递牙体牙髓病

牙髓病学系统评价中实验室研究的方法学质量评估标准:一项开发方案

Methodological quality assessment criteria for the evaluation of laboratory-based studies included in systematic reviews within the specialty of Endodontology: A development protocol.
PubMed 文献 · Int Endod J · 2022-02-10

本文旨在概述在牙髓病学领域内开发用于评估系统评价中纳入的实验室研究(非在人体或动物体内进行的研究)的综合方法学质量评估标准的流程。该开发将遵循三阶段过程:首先由指导委员会制定初步标准清单,并经40人德尔菲专家组用九点李克特量表评审;随后由10人专家组会议进一步完善;最后修订标准并选择作者进行试点,根据反馈可能再次修订后由指导委员会批准。

要点

  • 牙髓病学系统评价中的实验室研究缺乏统一、客观的方法学质量评估标准。
  • 将开发综合评估标准,流程包括指导委员会制定、40人德尔菲专家组评审和10人专家组会议完善。
  • 新标准将试点后发布,并定期根据用户反馈更新。

核心结论

  • 本文概述了开发牙髓病学系统评价中实验室研究方法学质量评估标准的三阶段流程。

研究设计与样本

  • 制定方案:成立指导委员会制定初步标准清单,经德尔菲专家组(n=40)用九点李克特量表评审,再由专家组(n=10)会议讨论完善,最后试点并修订。

主要发现

  • 目前牙髓病学系统评价中实验室研究使用作者主观制定的质量评估标准,缺乏全面、结构良好且普遍接受的标准。

关键数值与推荐

  • 初步评估标准将由德尔菲专家组(n=40)使用九点李克特量表评审其相关性和纳入性。
  • 商定的条目将由专家组(n=10)通过在线或面对面会议进一步完善。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

High-quality systematic reviews in the field of Dentistry provide the most definitive overarching evidence for clinicians, guideline developers and healthcare policy makers to judge the foreseeable risks, anticipated benefits, and potential harms of dental treatment. In the process of carrying out a systematic review, it is essential that authors appraise the methodological quality of the primary studies they include, because studies which follow poor methodology will have a potentially serious negative impact on the overall strength of the evidence and the recommendations that can be drawn. In Endodontology, systematic reviews of laboratory studies have used quality assessment criteria developed subjectively by the individual authors as there are no comprehensive, well-structured, and universally accepted criteria that can be applied objectively and universally to individual studies included in reviews. Unfortunately, these subjective criteria are likely to be inaccurately defined, unreliably applied, inadequately analysed, unreasonably biased, defective, and non-repeatable. The aim of the present paper is to outline the process to be followed in the development of comprehensive methodological quality assessment criteria to be used when evaluating laboratory studies, that is research not conducted in vivo on humans or animals, included in systematic reviews within Endodontology. The development of new methodological quality assessment criteria for appraising the laboratory-based studies included in systematic reviews within Endodontology will follow a three-stage process. First, a steering committee will be formed by the project leaders to develop a preliminary list of assessment criteria by modifying and adapting those already available, but with the addition of several new items relevant for Endodontology. The initial draft assessment criteria will be reviewed and refined by a Delphi Group (n = 40) for their relevance and inclusion using a nine-point Likert scale. Second, the agreed items will then be discussed in an online or face-to-face meeting by a group of experts (n = 10) to further refine the assessment criteria. Third, based on the feedback received from the online/face-to-face meeting, the steering committee will revise the quality assessment criteria and subsequently a group of authors will be selected to pilot the new system. Based on the feedback collected, the criteria may be revised further before being approved by the steering committee. The assessment criteria will be published in relevant journals, presented at national and international congresses/meetings, and will be freely available on a dedicated website. The steering committee will update the assessment criteria periodically based on feedback received from end-users.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nagendrababu V, Abbott PV, Boutsioukis C, et al. Methodological quality assessment criteria for the evaluation of laboratory-based studies included in systematic reviews within the specialty of Endodontology: A development protocol. Int Endod J. 2022. PMID: 35043398. doi:10.1111/iej.13682

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。