锥形束CT对牙外伤病例诊断思维、治疗方案及信心的影响:一项前后对照研究
本研究纳入12名牙髓科医生对15例牙外伤病例进行前后对照评估,比较根尖片与锥形束CT(CBCT)对诊断思维、治疗决策及信心的影响。结果显示,使用CBCT后诊断思维改变(P < .05),提出临床干预的比例更高(P < .05),对治疗决策的信心发生变化(P < .05),但对诊断思维本身的信心无差异(P > .05)。
要点
- 使用根尖片时「不确定」诊断答案更多,诊断思维与CBCT有差异(P < .05)。
- 根尖片后最常见决策为「不开始常规牙髓治疗并拍摄CBCT」,CBCT后最常见为「开始常规牙髓治疗」。
- 基于CBCT提出临床干预的比例高于根尖片(P < .05),治疗决策信心有差异(P < .05)。
核心结论
- 在牙外伤病例中,CBCT影像影响参与者的诊断思维、治疗方式选择,并影响决策过程中的信心。
研究设计与样本
- 前后对照研究,12名牙髓科医生对15例牙外伤病例先后基于临床病史和根尖片(PR)以及一个月后基于CBCT影像进行两次评估并填写问卷。
- 对参与者的回答进行统计分析。
主要发现
- 使用根尖片或CBCT时诊断思维存在差异(P < .05),使用根尖片与更多「不确定」诊断答案相关。
- 根尖片后最常被支持的方案是「不开始常规牙髓治疗并预约CBCT」,而分析CBCT影像后最常见的决策是「开始常规牙髓治疗」。
- 使用CBCT评估临床病例时提出临床干预的比例高于使用根尖片时(P < .05)。
- 参与者对诊断思维的确信程度在使用根尖片或CBCT后无差异(P > .05)。
- 参与者对治疗决策的信心在根尖片与CBCT之间存在差异(P < .05);初始对诊断或治疗方案缺乏信心的参与者在有CBCT影像时获得信心,而初始基于根尖片有信心的参与者出现相反表现(P < .05);决定在CBCT分析后开始治疗的参与者比使用根尖片时信心更低(P < .05)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The aim of this study was to identify whether cone-beam computed tomographic (CBCT) imaging affects endodontists' diagnostic thinking, treatment option, and confidence in dental trauma cases. METHODS: Twelve endodontists reviewed 15 dental trauma cases with clinical histories and periapical radiography (PR) and answered questions regarding their diagnostic thinking and treatment decisions and their confidence in both. One month later, the same participants reviewed the same cases and answered similar questionnaires with the aid of CBCT imaging. A statistical analysis of their responses was conducted. RESULTS: Differences were observed in diagnostic thinking when using PR or CBCT imaging (P < .05), and the use of PR was associated with a higher number of "unsure" answers to questions about diagnoses. After reviewing periapical radiographic images, the approach most frequently endorsed was "don't start conventional endodontic treatment and order CBCT," whereas the most common decision made after analyzing the CBCT images was "start conventional endodontic treatment." Clinical interventions were proposed more often when participants evaluated the clinical case using CBCT imaging than when using PR (P < .05). The participants' degree of confidence in their diagnostic thinking was not different after analysis using PR or CBCT imaging (P > .05). However, there was a difference between PR and CBCT imaging in participants' confidence in their treatment decisions (P < .05). Participants who initially indicated a lack of confidence in their diagnosis or treatment option gained confidence when CBCT images were available. However, the inverse behavior was also observed for participants who were initially confident on the basis of PR (P < .05). Participants who decided to start treatment after CBCT analysis were less confident than when using PR (P < .05). CONCLUSIONS: In dental trauma cases, CBCT imaging influenced participants' diagnostic thinking and choice of treatment modality and affected their confidence in the decision-making process.
引用
- Luz LB, Vizzotto MB, Xavier PNI, et al. The Impact of Cone-beam Computed Tomography on Diagnostic Thinking, Treatment Option, and Confidence in Dental Trauma Cases: A Before and After Study. J Endod. 2022. PMID: 34999095. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2021.12.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。